The medieval inquisition of heresy strongly relied on depositions, where witnesses were expected to report on the crimes of others and oneself. The resulting patterns of incrimination could be influenced by various factors, including the characteristics of the underlying dissident social network; the investigators' choices and biases; the trial circumstances, some of which must have exerted considerable pressure upon deponents; and the deponents' decisions to protect some suspects more than others. This case study aimed at disentangling selected social factors of incrimination in the register of the inquisition in Bologna, 1291-1310. We used social network analysis and, more specifically, an Exponential Random Graph Model (ERGM) to assess the influence of four social predictors: gender, churchperson status, membership of the urban "middle class", and kinship ties between incriminators and the incriminated. To increase the validity of our results, we controlled for various trial circumstances and structural parameters of the incrimination network. Our model corroborated a tendency towards female-to-female incrimination, while we did not find any positive or negative tendency towards male-to-male incrimination. We identified no effect of churchperson status on incriminating, while we found that among Cathars, members of the middle class were more likely to be incriminated than people without this status. Our model also corroborated the tendency to incriminate one's kinship group. Overall, our study underlines the relevance, but also the non-trivial operation, of social and demographic predictors in medieval heresy trials.

Centre for the Digital Research of Religion Department for the Study of Religions Faculty of Arts Masaryk University Brno Czech Republic

See more in PubMed

Merlo GG. I registri inquisitoriali come fonti per la storia dei gruppi ereticali clandestini: il caso del Piemonte basso medievale. In: Tilloy M, Audisio G, Chiffoleau J, editors. Histoire et clandestinité du Moyen-Age à la Première Guerre mondiale: Colloque de Privas (mai 1977). Albi: Ateliers professionnels de l’O.S.J.; 1979. pp. 59–74.

Bruschi C. The wandering heretics of Languedoc. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press; 2009.

Ginzburg C. Proofs and possibilities: Postscript to Natalie Zemon Davis, The return of Martin Guerre. Threads and traces: True, false, fictive. Berkeley; Los Angeles; London: University of California Press; 2012. pp. 54–71.

Zbíral D, Shaw RLJ. Hearing voices: reapproaching medieval inquisition records. Religions. 2022;13: 1175. doi: 10.3390/rel13121175 DOI

Brundage JA. Proof in canonical criminal law. Continuity and change. 1996;11: 329–339. doi: 10.1017/S0268416000003441 DOI

Bedell J. Memory and proof of age in England 1272–1327. Past and Present. 1999; 3–27. doi: 10.1093/past/162.1.3 DOI

Sbriccoli M. “Tormentum idest torquere mentem”: Processo inquisitorio e interrogatorio per tortura nell’Italia comunale. In: Maire Vigueur J-C, Paravicini Bagliani A, editors. La parola all’accusato. Palermo: Sellerio; 1991. pp. 17–32.

Given JB. Inquisition and medieval society: Power, discipline, and resistance in Languedoc. Ithaca; London: Cornell University Press; 1997.

Biller P. Umberto Eco et les interrogations de Bernard Gui. In: Audisio G, editor. Inquisition et pouvoir. Aix-en-Provence: Publications de l’Université de Provence; 2004. pp. 257–268.

Estévez JL, Salihović D, Sgourev SV. Endogenous dynamics of denunciation: evidence from an inquisitorial trial. PNAS Nexus. 2024;3: pgae340. doi: 10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae340 PubMed DOI PMC

Given JB. The inquisitors of Languedoc and the medieval technology of power. American Historical Review. 1989;94: 336–359. doi: 10.2307/1866830 DOI

Muzzarelli MG, editor. Riferire all’autorità: denuncia e delazione tra Medioevo ed Età Moderna. Roma: Viella; 2020.

Bergemann P. Judge thy neighbor: Denunciations in the Spanish Inquisition, Romanov Russia, and Nazi Germany. New York: Columbia University Press; 2019.

Craun E. The imperatives of denunciatio: Disclosing others’ sins to disciplinary authorities. In: Flannery MC, Walter KL, editors. The culture of inquisition in medieval England. Cambridge: Brewer; 2013. pp. 30–44.

Chiffoleau J. Dire l’indicibile: osservazioni sulla categoria del nefandum dal XII al XV secolo. In: Maire Vigueur J-C, Paravicini Bagliani A, editors. La parola all’accusato. Palermo: Sellerio; 1991. pp. 42–73.

Asad T. Medieval heresy: an anthropological view. Social History. 1986;11: 345–362. doi: 10.1080/03071028608567662 DOI

Moore RI. The formation of a persecuting society: authority and deviance in western Europe, 950–1250. 2nd ed. Malden; Oxford: Blackwell; 2007.

Bergemann P. Denunciation and social control. American Sociological Review. 2017;82: 384–406. doi: 10.1177/0003122417694456 DOI

Rehr J-P. Re-mapping the ‘Great Inquisition’ of 1245–46: the case of Mas-Saintes-Puelles and Saint-Martin-Lalande. Open Library of Humanities. 2019;5: 1–52. doi: 10.16995/olh.414 DOI

Ormerod P, Roach A. The medieval inquisition: scale-free networks and the suppression of heresy. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications. 2004;339: 645–652. doi: 10.1016/j.physa.2004.03.020 DOI

Pouivet Y, Schulz B. Montaillou: Netzwerke der Katharer im beginnenden Spätmittelalter. In: Bauerfeld D, Clemens L, editors. Gesellschaftliche Umbrüche und religiöse Netzwerke: Analysen von der Antike bis zur Gegenwart. Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag; 2014. pp. 155–172.

Nieto-Isabel DI. Communities of dissent: social network analysis of religious dissident groups in Languedoc in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries. Ph.D. thesis, Universitat de Barcelona. 2018.

Nieto-Isabel DI, López-Arenillas C. From inquisition to inquiry: inquisitorial records as a source for social network analysis. In: Hutchings T, Clivaz C, editors. Christianity and the Digital Humanities. Berlin: De Gruyter; 2021. pp. 195–212. doi: 10.1515/9783110574043-009 DOI

Fazioli KP. Modeling the Middle Ages: a review of historical network research on medieval Europe and the Mediterranean world. In: Fazioli KP, Kelly MJ, editors. Social and intellectual networking in the Early Middle Ages. Santa Barbara: Punctum Books; 2023.

Gramsch-Stehfest R. Von der Metapher zur Methode. Zeitschrift für Historische Forschung. 2020;47: 2–40. doi: 10.3790/zhf.47.1.1 DOI

Gramsch-Stehfest R. Entangled Powers: Network Analytical Approaches to the History of the Holy Roman Empire during the Late Staufer Period. German History. 2018;36: 365–380. doi: 10.1093/gerhis/ghy049 DOI

Valeriola S de. Can historians trust centrality? Historical network analysis and centrality metrics robustness. Journal of Historical Network Research. 2021;6. doi: 10.25517/jhnr.v6i1.105 DOI

Brughmans T, Bobou O, Kristensen NB, Thomsen RR, Jensen JV, Seland EH, et al.. A kinship network analysis of Palmyrene genealogies. Journal of Historical Network Research. 2021;6. doi: 10.25517/jhnr.v6i1.65 DOI

Błoch A, Vasques Filho D, Bojanowski M. Networks from archives: reconstructing networks of official correspondence in the early modern Portuguese empire. Social Networks. 2022;69: 123–135. doi: 10.1016/j.socnet.2020.08.008 DOI

Di Méo G. Historical co-offending networks: a social network analysis approach. The British Journal of Criminology. 2023;20: 1–21. doi: 10.1093/bjc/azad005 DOI

Riccardo K, Zbíral D, Brys Z, Hampejs T. Incriminations in the inquisition register of Bologna (1291–1310): network data and code. Zenodo; 2024. doi: 10.5281/zenodo.13935366 PubMed DOI PMC

Erler MC, Kowaleski M, editors. Gendering the master narrative: women and power in the Middle Ages. Ithaca; London: Cornell University Press; 2003.

Bennett JM, Karras RM, editors. The Oxford handbook of women and gender in medieval Europe. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press; 2013.

Biller P. Through a glass darkly: seeing medieval heresy. In: Linehan P, Nelson JL, editors. The medieval world. London; New York: Routledge; 2001. pp. 308–326. doi: 10.4324/9781315102511-21 DOI

Vilandrau C. Inquisition et “sociabilité cathare” d’après le registre de l’inquisiteur Geoffroy d’Ablis (1308–1309). Heresis. 2001;34: 35–66.

Kelleher MA. Later medieval law in community context. In: Bennett J, Karras R, editors. The Oxford handbook of women and gender in medieval Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2013. pp. 133–147. doi: 10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199582174.013.017 DOI

Abels R, Harrison E. The participation of women in Languedocian Catharism. Mediaeval Studies. 1979; 215–251. doi: 10.1484/J.MS.2.306245 DOI

Mentzer RA. Heresy proceedings in Languedoc, 1500–1560. Philadelphia: The American Philosophical Society; 1984.

Davies RG. Lollardy and locality. Transactions of the Royal Historical Society. 1991;1: 191–212. doi: 10.2307/3679036 DOI

McSheffrey S. Gender and heresy: women and men in Lollard communities, 1420–1530. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press; 1995.

Sparks C. Heresy, inquisition and life cycle in medieval Languedoc. York: York Medieval Press; 2014.

Paolini L. Domus e zona degli eretici: L’esempio di Bologna nel XIII secolo. Rivista di storia della chiesa in Italia. 1981;2: 371–387.

Paolini L. L’eresia a Bologna fra XIII e XIV secolo I: l’eresia catara alla fine del duecento. Roma: Istituto storico italiano per il Medio Evo; 1975.

Giansante M. Eretici e usurai: l’usura come eresia nella normativa e nella prassi inquisitoriale dei secoli XIII-XIV: Il caso di Bologna. Rivista di storia e letteratura religiosa. 1987;22: 193–221.

Giansante M. L’usuraio onorato: credito e potere a Bologna in età comunale. Bologna: Il Mulino; 2008.

Galletti F. Le società delle arti a Bologna e i loro statuti: un bilancio storiografico. I Quaderni Del mæS—Journal of Mediæ Ætatis Sodalicium. 2017.

Lutton R. Lollardy and Orthodox Religion in Pre-Reformation England: Reconstructing Piety. Boydell & Brewer; 2006.

Brenon A. Catharism in the family in Languedoc in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries: an investigation based on inquisition sources. In: Reyerson K, Drendel JV, editors. Urban and rural communities in medieval France: Provence and Languedoc, 1000–1500. Leiden; Boston: Brill; 1998. pp. 291–314.

Vidal J-M. Le Tribunal d’inquisition de Pamiers. Toulouse: Privat; 1906.

Paolini L, Orioli R, editors. Introduzione. Acta S Officii Bononie ab anno 1291 usque ad annum 1310. Roma: Istituto storico italiano per il Medio Evo; 1982. p. 35.

Lansing C. Power and purity: Cathar heresy in medieval Italy. New York; Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1998.

Paolini L, Orioli R, editors. Acta S. Officii Bononie ab anno 1291 usque ad annum 1310. Roma: Istituto storico italiano per il Medio Evo; 1982.

Dupré Theseider E. L’eresia a Bologna nei tempi di Dante. Mondo cittadino e movimenti ereticali nel Medio Evo. Bologna: Pàtron; 1978. pp. 261–315.

Kurze D. Quellen zur Ketzergeschichte Brandenburgs und Pommerns. De Gruyter; 1975.

Benedetti M, editor. Milano 1300: i processi inquisitoriali contro le devote e i devoti di santa Guglielma. Milano: Libri Scheiwiller; 1999.

Rinaldi R. Comune—Capitano del popolo: Società di popolo (secc. XIII-XIX). Archivio di Stato di Bologna; Available: https://media.regesta.com/dm_0/ASBO/asboAnagrafe/I_23_Comune_-_Capitano_del_Popolo_-_Societa__di_popolo.pdf

McCulloch J, Ellerby Z, Wagner C. On the relationship between similarity measures and thresholds of statistical significance in the context of comparing fuzzy sets. IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems. 2019;28: 1785–1798. doi: 10.1109/TFUZZ.2019.2922161 DOI

Garlaschelli D, Loffredo MI. Patterns of link reciprocity in directed networks. Physical Review Letters. 2004;93: 268701. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.93.268701 PubMed DOI

Lusher D, Koskinen J, Robins G, editors. Exponential random graph models for social networks: theory, methods, and applications. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2012.

Duxbury SW. Diagnosing multicollinearity in Exponential Random Graph Models. Sociological Methods & Research. 2021;50: 491–530. doi: 10.1177/0049124118782543 DOI

Csárdi G, Nepusz T, Müller K, Horvát S, Traag V, Zanini F, et al.. igraph for R: R interface of the igraph library for graph theory and network analysis. Zenodo; 2023. doi: 10.5281/ZENODO.7682609 DOI

Schoch D. netUtils: a collection of tools for network analysis. 2023. Available: https://github.com/schochastics/netUtils

Bojanowski M, Corten R. Measuring segregation in social networks. Social Networks. 2014;39: 14–32. doi: 10.1016/j.socnet.2014.04.001 DOI

Hunter DR, Handcock MS, Butts CT, Goodreau SM, Morris M. ergm: a package to fit, simulate and diagnose Exponential-Family Models for networks. Journal of Statistical Software. 2008;24. doi: 10.18637/jss.v024.i03 PubMed DOI PMC

Krivitsky PN, Hunter DR, Morris M, Klumb C. ergm 4: new features for analyzing Exponential-Family Random Graph Models. Journal of Statistical Software. 2023;105. doi: 10.18637/jss.v105.i06 PubMed DOI PMC

Duxbury WS. ergMargins: process analysis for Exponential Random Graph Models. Available: https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=ergMargins

Arnold JH. Inquisition and power: Catharism and the confessing subject in medieval Languedoc. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press; 2001.

Pihko S. The construction of information in medieval inquisition records: a methodological reconsiderationation. I quaderni del mæ.s—Journal of Mediæ Ætatis Sodalicium. 2024;22: 165–189. doi: 10.6092/issn.2533-2325/19030 DOI

James L. The stability of implicit racial bias in police officers. Police Quarterly. 2018;21: 30–52. doi: 10.1177/1098611117732974 DOI

Norr A, Kukucka J. Racial bias in the interpretation of police interrogations. 2020. Available: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/338912472_Racial_Bias_in_the_Interpretation_of_Police_Interrogations

Eck K, Crabtree C. Gender differences in the prosecution of police assault: evidence from a natural experiment in Sweden. PLOS ONE. 2020;15: e0235894. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0235894 PubMed DOI PMC

Gender, kinship, and other social predictors of incrimination in the inquisition register of Bologna (1291-1310): Results from an exponential random graph model