This study presents, for the first time, a comprehensive dataset that documents the range of inter- and intraspecific otolith variation in aplocheiloid killifish, based on a total of 86 individuals representing five extant species of Nothobranchius PETERS, 1868, from East Africa: the sympatric pairs N. rubripinnis SEEGERS, 1986 and N. ruudwildekampi COSTA, 2009 (Eastern Tanzania), and N. orthonotus (PETERS, 1844) and N. furzeri JUBB, 1971 (Southern Mozambique), and two isolated populations of N. korthausae MEINKEN, 1973 (Eastern Tanzania). Otolith characters were analysed based on SEM images, and otolith morphometry was conducted using uni- and multivariate statistics. Two ancient clades of probably Early to Middle Miocene age in eastern Tanzania and southern Mozambique can be recognized based on otolith morphologies, which is consistent with previous work based on molecular data. The distinctive sulcus morphologies in the otoliths of sympatric species may be linked to species-specific hearing capabilities, perhaps constituting a case of character displacement in an area of secondary sympatry. The otoliths of the studied species of Nothobranchius are diagnostic at the species level, even in the case of closely related species diagnosable otherwise only by minor differences in coloration. The two populations of N. korthausae also displayed some differences in their otolith characters. The new data may facilitate future recognition of fossil species of Nothobranchius. As no fossil remains of extant aplocheiloid killifishes have yet been described, the discovery of fossil otoliths of Nothobranchius would significantly advance understanding of the evolutionary history of this interesting group of fishes.

Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences Palaeontology and Geobiology Ludwig Maximilians University Munich Germany

Institute of Vertebrate Biology Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic Brno Czech Republic

Erratum v

PLoS One. 2015 Apr 14;10(4):e0124984. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0124984. PubMed

Zobrazit více v PubMed

Popper AN (1976) Ultrastructure of the auditory regions in the inner ear of the lake whitefish. Science 192: 1020–1023. PubMed

Popper AN, Ramcharitar J, Campana SE (2005) Why otoliths? Insights from inner ear physiology and fisheries biology. Marine and Freshwater Research 56: 497–504.

Assis CA (2003) The lagenar otoliths of teleosts: their morphology and its application in species identification, phylogeny and systematics. J Fish Biol 62: 1268–1295.

Assis CA (2005) The utricular otoliths, lapilli, of teleosts: their morphology and relevance for species identification and systematics studies. Scientia Marina 69: 259–273.

Schulz-Mirbach T, Reichenbacher B (2006) Reconstruction of Oligocene and Neogene freshwater fish faunas – an actualistic study on cypriniform otoliths. Acta Palaeontol Pol 51: 283–304.

Schulz-Mirbach T, Plath M (2012) All good things come in threes - species delimitation through shape analysis of saccular, lagenar and utricular otoliths. Marine and Freshwater Research 63: 934–940.

Nolf D (1995) Studies on fossil otoliths - The state of the art. In: Secor DH, Dean JM and Campana SE, editors. Recent Developments in Fish Otolith Research. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press. pp. 513–544.

Nolf D (2013) The diversity of fish otoliths, past and present. Brussels: Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences. 222 p.

Schwarzhans W (1993) Piscium Catalogus. Part Otolithi Piscium. Volume 1. A comparative morphological treatise of recent and fossil otoliths of the family Sciaenidae (Perciformes). München: Verlag Dr. Friedrich Pfeil.

Volpedo AV, Echeverría DD (2000) Catálogo y claves de otolitos para la identificación de peces del Mar Argentino 1. Peces de importanica comercial. Buenos Aires: Editorial Dunken. 90 p.

Campana SE (2004) Photographic atlas of fish otoliths of the northwest Atlantic ocean. Ottawa, Ontario: NRC Research Press. 284 p.

Smale MJ, Watson G, Hecht T (1995) Otolith atlas of southern African marine fishes. Ichthyological Monographs. Grahamstown: J. L. B. Smith Institute of Ichthyology pp. 253.

Tuset VM, Lombarte A, Assis CA (2008) Otolith atlas for the western Mediterranean, north and central eastern Atlantic. Scientia Marina 72: 7–198.

Parenti LR (1981) A phylogenetic and biogeographic analysis of cyprinodontiform fishes (Teleostei, Atherinomorpha). Bull American Mus Nat Hist 168: 335–557.

Froese R, Pauly D (2014) FishBase, World Wide Web electronic publication, version (04/2014). Available: http://www.fishbase.org. Accessed 1 July 2014.

Wildekamp RH (1993) A world of killies: atlas of the oviparous cyprinodontiform fishes of the world, volume I. Mishawaka, Indiana: American Killifish Association. 311 p.

Wildekamp RH (2004) A world of killies: atlas of the oviparous cyprinodontiform fishes of the world, volume IV. Elyria: American Killifish Association. 398 p.

Doadrio I, Perdices A, Machordom A (1996) Allozymic variation of the endangered killifish

Oliva-Paterna FJ, Doadrio I, Fernández-Delgado C (2006) Threatened fishes of the world:

Esmaeili HR, Teimori A, Gholami Z, Zarei N, Reichenbacher B (2012) Re-validation and re-description of an endemic and threatened species,

Parker A, Kornfield I (1995) Molecular perspective on evolution and zoogeography of cyprinodontid killifishes (Teleostei; Atherinomorpha). Copeia 1995: 8–21.

Costa WJEM (1998) Phylogeny and classification of the Cyprinodontiformes (Euteleostei: Atherinomorpha): A reappraisal. In: Malabarba LR, Reis RE, Vari RP, Lucena ZM and Lucena CAS, editors. Phylogeny and classification of neotropical fishes. Porto Alegre, Brazil: EDIPUCRS. pp. 537–560.

Costa WJEM (2013) Historical biogeography of aplocheiloid killifishes (Teleostei: Cyprinodontiformes). Vertebrate Zoology 63: 139–154.

Esmaeili HR, Teimori A, Gholami Z, Reichenbacher B (2014) Two new species of the tooth-carp PubMed

Hrbek T, Meyer A (2003) Closing of the Tethys Sea and the phylogeny of Eurasian killifishes (Cyprinodontiformes: Cyprinodontidae). J Evol Biol 16: 17–36. PubMed

Horstkotte J, Strecker U (2005) Trophic differentiation in the phylogenetically young

Martin CH, Wainwright PC (2011) Trophic novelty is linked to exceptional rates of morphological diversification in two adaptive radiations of PubMed

Ferrito V, Pappalardo AM, Canapa A, Barucca M, Doadrio I, et al. (2013) Mitochondrial phylogeography of the killifish

Plath M, Strecker U (2008) Behavioral diversification in a young species flock of pupfish (

Reichard M, Polačik M (2010) Reproductive isolating barriers between colour-differentiated populations of an African annual killifish,

Polačik M, Reichard M (2011) Asymmetric reproductive isolation between two sympatric annual killifish with extremely short lifespans. PLoS One 6: e22684. PubMed PMC

Arratia G, Cione AL (1996) The record of fossil fishes of Southern South America. In: Arratia G, editor. Contributions of southern South America to vertebrate paleontology. Münchner Geowissenschaftliche Abhandlungen. Reihe A: Geologie und Paläontologie. pp. 9–72.

Altner M, Reichenbacher B (2014) Kenyaichthyidae fam. nov. and PubMed PMC

Reichenbacher B, Sienknecht U (2001) Allopatric divergence and genetic diversity of recent

Reichenbacher B, Feulner GR, Schulz-Mirbach T (2009) Geographic variation in otolith morphology among freshwater populations of PubMed

Reichenbacher B, Kamrani E, Esmaeili HR, Teimori A (2009) The endangered cyprinodont

Teimori A, Esmaeili HR, Gholami Z, Zarei N, Reichenbacher B (2012) PubMed PMC

Teimori A, Jawad LAJ, Al-Kharusi LH, Al-Mamry JM, Reichenbacher B (2012) Late Pleistocene to Holocene diversification and historical zoogeography of the Arabian killifish (

Teimori A, Schulz-Mirbach T, Esmaeili HR, Reichenbacher B (2012) Geographical differentiation of

Gholami Z, Esmaeili HR, Erpenbeck D, Reichenbacher B (2014) Phylogenetic analysis of

Schulz-Mirbach T, Scherb H, Reichenbacher B (2008) Are hybridization and polyploidization phenomena detectable in the fossil record? A case study on otoliths of a natural hybrid,

Schulz-Mirbach T, Stransky C, Schlickeisen J, Reichenbacher B (2008) Differences in otolith morphologies between surface- and cave-dwelling populations of

Reichenbacher B, Kowalke T (2009) Neogene and present-day zoogeography of killifishes (

Reichenbacher B, Gaudant J (2003) On

Rückert-Ülkümen N, Böhme M, Reichenbacher B, Heissig K, Witt W, Bassler B (2002) Die Fossilführung des kontinentalen Neogens (Ober-Miozän/Unter-Pliozän) von Develiköy (Mansa, Türkei). Mitt Bayer Staatsslg Paläont hist Geol 42: 51–74.

Brzobohatý R (1969) Die Fischfauna des südmährischen Untermiozäns. Folia Fac Sci Nat Univ Purkynianae Brunensis, Geol 10: 1–49.

Malz H (1978) Vergleichend-morphologische Untersuchungen an aquitanen Fisch-Otolithen aus dem Untergrund von Frankfurt am Main. Senckenbergiana lethaea 59: 441–481.

Schulz-Mirbach T, Reichenbacher B (2008) Fossil

Seegers L (1997) Killifishes of the world. Old world Killis II. Mörfelden-Walldorf: Verlag A. C. S.

Watters BR, Cooper BJ, Wildekamp RH (2007) Description of

Costa WJEM (2009) Species delimitation among populations of the eastern Tanzanian seasonal killifish

Reichard M (2010) PubMed

Reichard M, Polačik M, Sedláček O (2009) Distribution, colour polymorphism and habitat use of the African killifish PubMed

Watters BR (2009) The ecology and distribution of

Bartáková V, Reichard M, Janko K, Polačik M, Blažek R, et al. (2013) Strong population genetic structuring in an annual fish, PubMed PMC

Terzibasi Tozzini E, Dorn A, Ng'oma E, Polačik M, Blažek R, et al. (2013) Parallel evolution of senescence in annual fishes in response to extrinsic mortality. BMC evolutionary biology 13: 77. PubMed PMC

Levels PJ, Gubbels REMB, Denucé JM (1986) Oxygen consumption during embryonic development of the annual fish PubMed

Valdesalici S, Cellerino A (2003) Extremely short lifespan in the annual fish PubMed PMC

Blažek R, Polačik M, Reichard M (2013) Rapid growth, early maturation and short generation time in African annual fishes. EvoDevo 4: 24. PubMed PMC

Polačik M, Harrod C, Blažek R, Reichard M (2014) Trophic niche partitioning in communities of African annual fish: evidence from stable isotopes. Hydrobiologia 721: 99–106.

Skelton P (2001) A complete guide to freshwater fishes of southern Africa. Cape Town: Struik Publishers. 395 p.

Valdesalici S (2007) A new species of the genus

Valdesalici S, Hengstler H (2008)

Wildekamp RH, Shidlovskiy KM, Watters BR (2009) Systematics of the

Shidlovskiy KM, Watters BR, Wildekamp RH (2010) Notes on the annual killifish species

Valdesalici S, Kardashev K (2011)

Valdesalici S, Bills R, Dorn A, Reichwald K, Cellerino A (2012)

Terzibasi E, Valenzano DR, Benedetti M, Roncaglia P, Cattaneo A, et al. (2008) Large differences in aging phenotype between strains of the short-lived annual fish PubMed PMC

Dorn A, Ng'oma E, Janko K, Reichwald K, Polačik M, et al. (2011) Phylogeny, genetic variability and colour polymorphism of an emerging animal model: the short-lived annual PubMed

Haas R (1976) Sexual selection in PubMed

Polačik M, Reichard M (2009) Indirect fitness benefits are not related to male dominance in a killifish. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 63: 1427–1435.

Reichenbacher B, Sienknecht U, Küchenhoff H, Fenske N (2007) Combined otolith morphology and morphometry for assessing taxonomy and diversity in fossil and extant killifish ( PubMed

Cerling TE, Wynn JG, Andanje SA, Bird MI, Korir DK, et al. (2011) Woody cover and hominin environments in the past 6 million years. Nature 476: 51–56. PubMed

Dorn A, Musilová Z, Platzer M, Reichwald K, Cellerino A (2014) The strange case of East African annual fish: did aridification promote diversification of a savannah aquatic group? BMC Evolutionary Biology 14: 210. PubMed PMC

Vignon M, Morat F (2010) Environmental and genetic determinant of otolith shape revealed by a non-indigenous tropical fish. Mar Ecol-Prog Ser 411: 231–241.

Vignon M, Morat F, Galzin R, Sasal P (2008) Evidence for spatial limitation of the bluestripe snapper

Teimori A, Esmaeili HR, Erpenbeck D, Reichenbacher B (2014) A new and unique species of the genus

Lombarte A, Lleonart J (1993) Otolith size changes related with body growth, habitat depth and temperature. Environ Biol Fish 37: 297–306.

Aguirre H, Lombarte A (1999) Ecomorphological comparisons of sagittae in

Torres GJ, Lombarte A, Morales-Nin B (2000) Variability of the sulcus acusticus in the sagittal otolith of the genus

Gauldie RW, Crampton JS (2002) An eco-morphological explanation of individual variability in the shape of the fish otolith: comparison of the otolith of

Volpedo AV, Echeverría DD (2003) Ecomorphological patterns of the sagitta in fish on the continental shelf off Argentine. Fisheries Research 60: 551–560.

Lombarte A, Palmer M, Matallanas J, Gómez-Zurita J, Morales-Nin B (2010) Ecomorphological trends and phylogenetic inertia of otolith sagittae in Nototheniidae. Environ Biol Fish 89: 607–618.

Nolf D, Tyler JC (2006) Otolith evidence concerning interrelationships of caproid, zeiform and tetraodontiform fishes. Bulletin de l'Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique 76: 147–189.

Schwarzhans W, Scofield RP, Tennyson AJD, Worthy JP, Worthy TH (2012) Fish remains, mostly otoliths, from the non-marine early Miocene of Otago, New Zealand. Acta Palaeontol Pol 57: 319–350.

Gierl C, Reichenbacher B, Gaudant J, Erpenbeck D, Pharisat A (2013) An extraordinary gobioid fish fossil from southern France. PLoS One 8: e64117. PubMed PMC

Fekete DM (2003) Rocks that roll zebrafish. Science 302: 241–242. PubMed

Ramcharitar JU, Deng X, Ketten D, Popper AN (2004) Form and function in the unique inner ear of a teleost: The silver perch ( PubMed

Sadighzadeh Z, Otero-Ferrer JL, Lombarte A, Fatemi MR, Tuset VM (2014) An approach to unraveling the coexistence of snappers (Lutjanidae) using otolith morphology. Scientia Marina 78: 353–362.

Schulz-Mirbach T, Heß M, Plath M (2011) Inner ear morphology in the Atlantic molly PubMed PMC

Campana SE, Casselman JM (1993) Stock discrimination using otolith shape analysis. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 50: 1062–1083.

Stransky C, Murta AG, Schlickeisen J, Zimmermann C (2008) Otolith shape analysis as a tool for stock separation of horse mackerel (

Tuset VM, Azzurro E, Lombarte A (2012) Identification of Lessepsian fish species using the sagittal otolith. Scientia Marina 76: 289–299.

Avigliano E, Martinez CFR, Volpedo AV (2014) Combined use of otolith microchemistry and morphometry as indicators of the habitat of the silverside (

Annabi A, Said K, Reichenbacher B (2013) Inter-population differences in otolith morphology are genetically encoded in the killifish