Local adaptation is used as a criterion to select plant materials that will display high fitness in new environments. A large body of research has explored local adaptation in plants, however, to what extent findings can inform management decisions has not been formally evaluated. We assessed local adaptation literature for six key experimental methodologies that have the greatest effect on the application of research to selecting plant materials for natural resource management: experimental environment, response variables, maternal effects, intraspecific variation, selective agents, and spatial and temporal variability. We found that less than half of experiments used reciprocal transplants or natural field conditions, which are both informative for revegetation and restoration. Population growth rate was rarely (5%) assessed, and most studies measured only single generations (96%) and ran for less than a year. Emergence and establishment are limiting factors in successful revegetation and restoration, but the majority of studies measured later life-history stages (66%). Additionally, most studies included limited replication at the population and habitat levels and tested response to single abiotic selective factors (66%). Local adaptation research should be cautiously applied to management; future research could use alternative methodologies to allow managers to directly apply findings.

College of Forestry and Conservation University of Montana Missoula MT USA

College of Forestry and Conservation University of Montana Missoula MT USA; Present address Department of Botany and Zoology Masaryk University Kotlářská 2CZ 611 37 Brno Czech Republic

Pest Management Research Unit USDA ARS NPARL Sidney MT USA

Zobrazit více v PubMed

Aavik, T. , Edwards P. J., Holderegger R., Graf R., and Billeter R. 2012. Genetic consequences of using seed mixtures in restoration: a case study of a wetland plant Lychnis flos‐cuculi . Biological Conservation 145:195–204.

Adams, V. M. , Marsh D. M., and Knox J. S. 2005. Importance of the seed bank for population viability and population monitoring in a threatened wetland herb. Biological Conservation 124:425–436.

Agrawal, A. A. 2001. Transgenerational consequences of plant responses to herbivory: an adaptive maternal effect? The American Naturalist 157:555–569. PubMed

Agrawal, A. A. 2002. Herbivory and maternal effects: mechanisms and consequences of transgenerational induced plant resistance. Ecology 83:3408–3415.

Barrett, S. C. H. , Colautti R. I., and Eckert C. G. 2008. Plant reproductive systems and evolution during biological invasion. Molecular Ecology 17:373–383. PubMed

Becker, U. , Colling G., Dostal P., Jakobsson A., and Matthies D. 2006. Local adaptation in the monocarpic perennial Carlina vulgaris at different spatial scales across Europe. Oecologia 150:506–518. PubMed

Bell, D. L. , and Galloway L. F. 2008. Population differentiation for plasticity to light in an annual herb: adaptation and cost. American Journal of Botany 95:59–65. PubMed

Bennington, C. C. , Fetcher N., Vavrek M. C., Shaver G. R., Cummings K. J., and McGraw J. B. 2012. Home site advantage in two long‐lived arctic plant species: results from two 30‐year reciprocal transplant studies. Journal of Ecology 100:841–851.

Bischoff, A. , and Muller‐Scharer H. 2010. Testing population differentiation in plant species ‐ how important are environmental maternal effects. Oikos 119:445–454.

Bischoff, A. , Cremieux L., Smilauerova M., Lawson C. S., Mortimer S. R., Dolezal J., Lanta V. et al. 2006. Detecting local adaptation in widespread grassland species – the importance of scale and local plant community. Journal of Ecology 94:1130–1142.

Blanquart, F. , Kaltz O., Nuismer S. L., and Gandon S. 2013. A practical guide to measuring local adaptation. Ecology Letters 16:1195–1205. PubMed

Bozorgipour, R. , and Snape J. W. 1997. An assessment of somaclonal variation as a breeding tool for generating herbicide tolerant genotypes in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Euphytica 94:335–340.

Broadhurst, L. M. , North T., and Young A. G. 2006. Should we be more critical of remnant seed sources being used for revegetation? Ecological Management & Restoration 7:211–217.

Broadhurst, L. M. , Lowe A., Coates D. J., Cunningham S. A., McDonald M., Vesk P. A., and Yates C. 2008. Seed supply for broadscale restoration: maximizing evolutionary potential. Evolutionary Applications 1:587–597. PubMed PMC

Che‐Castaldo, J. P. , and Inouye D. W. 2011. The effects of dataset length and mast seeding on the demography of Frasera speciosa, a long‐lived monocarpic plant. Ecosphere 2:18.

Donohue, K. , and Schmitt J. 1999. The genetic architecture of plasticity to density in Impatiens capensis . Evolution 53:1377–1386. PubMed

Donovan, L. A. , and Ehleringer J. R. 1992. Contrasting water‐use patterns among size and life‐history classes of a semiarid shrub. Functional Ecology 6:482–488.

Ehlers, B. K. , Grondahl E., Ronfort J., and Bataillon T. 2012. “Menage a trois”: the presence/absence of thyme shapes the mutualistic interaction between the host plant Medicago truncatula (Fabaceae) and its symbiotic bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti . Ecology and Evolution 2:1676–1681. PubMed PMC

Espeland, E. K. , and Rice K. J. 2012. Within‐ and trans‐generational plasticity affects the opportunity for selection in barbed goatgrass (Aegilops triuncials). American Journal of Botany 99:2058–2062. PubMed

Etterson, J. R. 2004. Evolutionary potential of Chamaecrista fasciculata in relation to climate change. 1. Clinal patterns of selection along an environmental gradient in the great plains. Evolution 58:1446–1458. PubMed

Fant, J. B. , Holmstrom R. M., Sirkin E., Etterson J. R., and Masi S. 2008. Genetic structure of threatened native populations and propagules used for restoration in a clonal species, American beachgrass (Ammophila breviligulata Fern.). Restoration Ecology 16:594–603.

Freville, H. , and Silvertown J. 2005. Analysis of interspecific competition in perennial plants using life table response experiments. Plant Ecology 176:69–78.

Galloway, L. F. , and Etterson J. R. 2007. Transgenerational plasticity is adaptive in the wild. Science 318:1134–1136. PubMed

Geber, M. A. , and Griffen L. R. 2003. Inheritance and natural selection on functional traits. International Journal of Plant Sciences 164:S21–S42.

Gomory, D. , Longauer R., Hlasny T., Pacalaj M., Strmen S., and Krajmerova D. 2012. Adaptation to common optimum in different populations of Norway spruce (Picea abies Karst.). European Journal of Forest Research 131:401–411.

Goransson, P. , Andersson S., and Falkengren‐Grerup U. 2009. Genetic adaptation to soil acidification: experimental evidence from four grass species. Evolutionary Ecology 23:963–978.

Haubensak, K. A. , and Parker I. M. 2004. Soil changes accompanying invasion of the exotic shrub Cytisus scoparius in glacial outwash prairies of western Washington USA. Plant Ecology 175:71–79.

Hereford, J. 2009. A quantitative survey of local adaptation and fitness trade‐offs. The American Naturalist 173:579–588. PubMed

Hereford, J. 2010. Does selfing or outcrossing promote local adaptation? American Journal of Botany 97:298–302. PubMed

Hereford, J. , and Winn A. A. 2008. Limits to local adaptation in six populations of the annual plant Diodia teres . New Phytologist 178:888–896. PubMed

Hoffmann, A. A. , and Sgro C. M. 2011. Climate change and evolutionary adaptation. Nature 470:479–485. PubMed

Horvitz, C. C. , and Schemske D. W. 1995. Spatiotemporal variation in demographic transitions of a tropical understory herb – projection matrix analysis. Ecological Monographs 65:155–192.

Hufford, K. M. , and Mazer S. J. 2003. Plant ecotypes: genetic differentiation in the age of ecological restoration. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 18:147–155.

Hufford, K. M. , Mazer S. J., and Camara M. D. 2008. Local adaptation and effects of grazing among seedlings of two native california bunchgrass species: implications for restoration. Restoration Ecology 16:59–69.

Johnson, N. C. , Wilson G. W. T., Bowker M. A., Wilson J. A., and Miller R. M. 2010a. Resource limitation is a driver of local adaptation in mycorrhizal symbioses. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 107:2093–2098. PubMed PMC

Johnson, R. C. , Erickson V. J., Mandel N. L., St Clair J. B., and Vance‐Borland K. W. 2010b. Mapping genetic variation and seed zones for Bromus carinatus in the Blue Mountains of eastern Oregon, USA. Botany‐Botanique 88:725–736.

Jordan, D. S. 1905. The origin of species through isolation. Science 22:545–562. PubMed

Joshi, J. , Schmid B., Caldeira M. C., Dimitrakopoulos P. G., Good J., Harris R., Hector A. et al. 2001. Local adaptation enhances performance of common plant species. Ecology Letters 4:536–544.

Kawecki, T. J. , and Ebert D. 2004. Conceptual issues in local adaptation. Ecology Letters 7:1225–1241.

Kawecki, T. J. , Lenski R. E., Ebert D., Hollis B., Olivieri I., and Whitlock M. C. 2012. Experimental evolution. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 27:547–560. PubMed

Kelly, C. A. 1992. Spatial and temporal variation in selection on correlated life‐history traits and plant size in Chamaecrista fasciculata . Evolution 46:1658–1673. PubMed

Khurana, E. , and Singh J. S. 2001. Ecology of seed and seedling growth for conservation and restoration of tropical dry forest: a review. Environmental Conservation 28:39–52.

Knight, T. M. , and Miller T. E. 2004. Local adaptation within a population of Hydrocotyle bonariensis . Evolutionary Ecology Research 6:103–114.

Koch, J. M. 2007. Restoring a Jarrah forest understorey vegetation after bauxite mining in Western Australia. Restoration Ecology 15:S26–S39.

Lau, J. A. 2006. Evolutionary responses of native plants to novel community members. Evolution 60:56–63. PubMed

Lau, J. A. , McCall A. C., Davies K. F., McKay J. K., and Wright J. W. 2008. Herbivores and edaphic factors constrain the realized niche of a native plant. Ecology 89:754–762. PubMed

Leger, E. A. , and Espeland E. K. 2010. Coevolution between native and invasive plant competitors: implications for invasive species management. Evolutionary Applications 3:169–178. PubMed PMC

Leimu, R. , and Fischer M. 2008. A meta‐analysis of local adaptation in plants. PLoS ONE 3:e4010. PubMed PMC

Macel, M. , Lawson C. S., Mortimer S. R., Smilauerova M., Bischoff A., Cremieux L., Dolezal J. et al. 2007. Climate vs. soil factors in local adaptation of two common plant species. Ecology 88:424–433. PubMed

Manel, S. , Schwartz M. K., Luikart G., and Taberlet P. 2003. Landscape genetics: combining landscape ecology and population genetics. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 18:189–197.

McCarragher, S. R. , Goldblum D., and Rigg L. S. 2011. Geographic variation of germination, growth, and mortality in sugar maple (Acer saccharum): common garden and reciprocal dispersal experiments. Physical Geography 32:1–21.

McKay, J. K. , Christian C. E., Harrison S., and Rice K. J. 2005. “How local is local?” – a review of practical and conceptual issues in the genetics of restoration. Restoration Ecology 13:432–440.

Menges, E. S. 1990. Population viability analysis for an endangered plant. Conservation Biology 4:52–62.

Merritt, D. J. , and Dixon K. W. 2011. Restoration seed banks – a matter of scale. Science 332:424–425. PubMed

Miao, S. L. , Bazzaz F. A., and Primack R. B. 1991. Persistence of maternal nutrient effects in Plantago major – the 3rd generation. Ecology 72:1634–1642.

Millar, C. , and Libby W. 1989. Restoration: Disneyland or native ecosystem? A question of genetics. Restoration and Management Notes 7:18–23.

Miller, M. T. , Antos J. A., and Allen G. A. 2012. Demography of a dormancy‐prone geophyte: influence of spatial scale on interpretation of dynamics. Plant Ecology 213:569–579.

Morrissey, M. B. , and Hadfield J. D. 2012. Directional selection in temporally replicated studies is remarkably consistent. Evolution 66:435–442. PubMed

Nault, A. , and Gagnon D. 1993. Ramet demography of Allium tricoccum, a spring ephemeral, perennial forest herb. Journal of Ecology 81:101–119.

Nuismer, S. L. , and Gandon S. 2008. Moving beyond common‐garden and transplant designs: insight into the causes of local adaptation in species interactions. The American Naturalist 171:658–668. PubMed

Pankova, H. , Raabova J., and Munzbergova Z. 2014. Mycorrhizal symbiosis and local adaptation in Aster amellus: a field transplant experiment. PLoS ONE 9:7. PubMed PMC

Pywell, R. F. , Bullock J. M., Roy D. B., Warman L. I. Z., Walker K. J., and Rothery P. 2003. Plant traits as predictors of performance in ecological restoration. Journal of Applied Ecology 40:65–77.

Raabova, J. , Muenzbergova Z., and Fischer M. 2007. Ecological rather than geographic or genetic distance affects local adaptation of the rare perennial herb, Aster amellus . Biological Conservation 139:348–357.

Raabova, J. , Munzbergova Z., and Fischer M. 2011. The role of spatial scale and soil for local adaptation in Inula hirta . Basic and Applied Ecology 12:152–160.

Rice, K. J. , and Emery N. C. 2003. Managing microevolution: restoration in the face of global change. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 1:469–478.

Rice, K. J. , and Knapp E. E. 2008. Effects of competition and life history stage on the expression of local adaptation in two native bunchgrasses. Restoration Ecology 16:12–23.

Rice, K. J. , and Mack R. N. 1991. Ecological genetics of Bromus tectorum. 3. The demography of reciprocally sown populations. Oecologia 88:91–101. PubMed

Roach, D. A. , and Wulff R. D. 1987. Maternal effects in plants. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 18:209–235.

Siepielski, A. M. , DiBattista J. D., and Carlson S. M. 2009. It's about time: the temporal dynamics of phenotypic selection in the wild. Ecology Letters 12:1261–1276. PubMed

St Clair, J. B. , Kilkenny F. F., Johnson R. C., Shaw N. L., and Weaver G. 2013. Genetic variation in adaptive traits and seed transfer zones for Pseudoroegneria spicata (bluebunch wheatgrass) in the northwestern United States. Evolutionary Applications 6:933–948. PubMed PMC

Streisfeld, M. A. , and Kohn J. R. 2007. Environment and pollinator‐mediated selection on parapatric floral races of Mimulus aurantiacus . Journal of Evolutionary Biology 20:122–132. PubMed

Sultan, S. E. , Barton K., and Wilczek A. M. 2009. Contrasting patterns of transgenerational plasticity in ecologically distinct congeners. Ecology 90:1831–1839. PubMed

Svenning, M. M. , Junttila O., and Solheim B. 1991. Symbiotic growth of indigenous white clover (Trifolium repens) with local rhizobium Leguminosarum biovar trifolii . Physiologia Plantarum 83:381–389.

Thompson, J. N. , Nuismer S. L., and Gomulkiewicz R. 2002. Coevolution and maladaptation. Integrative and Comparative Biology 42:381–387. PubMed

Thompson, J. D. , Gauthier P., Amiot J., Ehlers B. K., Collin C., Fossat J., Barrios V. et al. 2007. Ongoing adaptation to mediterranean climate extremes in a chemically polymorphic plant. Ecological Monographs 77:421–439.

Thrall, P. H. , Burdon J. J., and Bever J. D. 2002. Local adaptation in the Linum marginale‐Melampsora lini host–pathogen interaction. Evolution 56:1340–1351. PubMed

USDI and USDA 2002. Report to the Congress: Interagency Program to Supply and Manage Native Plant Materials for Restoration and Rehabilitation on Federal Lands. USDI and USDA, Washington, DC, USA.

Vander Mijnsbrugge, K. , Bischoff A., and Smith B. 2010a. A question of origin: where and how to collect seed for ecological restoration. Basic and Applied Ecology 11:300–311.

Vander Mijnsbrugge, K. , De Cock K., Cox K., and Breyne P. 2010b. Conservation measures for Rosa arvensis Huds. in Flanders (Belgium) based on congruent genetic and phenotypic population differentiation. Conservation Genetics 11:2243–2253.

Vitt, P. , Havens K., Kramer A. T., Sollenberger D., and Yates E. 2010. Assisted migration of plants: changes in latitudes, changes in attitudes. Biological Conservation 143:18–27.

Williams, S. L. 2001. Reduced genetic diversity in eelgrass transplantations affects both population growth and individual fitness. Ecological Applications 11:1472–1488.

Non-native populations of an invasive tree outperform their native conspecifics