Recently, the trend of circular economy innovation (CEI) drive SMEs to initiate more sustainable practices to attain market competitiveness but rare attention has been paid in emerging economies. Hence, this study plans to explore the impacts of CEI on the triple bottom lines (TBL) efficiencies in the light of market competitiveness among the production SMEs in emerging economies. The study complied data by using a survey-based technique in Pakistan, Malaysia, and China. With a sample of 306 for each segment, data were evaluated with PLS-SEM to clarify results. The findings reveal that CEI has positive significant effects on the market competitiveness and TBL efficiencies among the production SMEs in emerging economies. The findings also clarify that market competitiveness mediates the relationship between CEI and the TBL efficiencies. The findings elaborate the theoretical foundations for environmental-based production SMEs to formulate more sustainable strategies in the light of CEI to gain market competitiveness. It also clarifies the understandings of policy makers and environmental regulators by providing a novel precursor to frame the environment-based TBL guidelines for SMEs. It adds to the UN sustainability agenda by elevating the role of CEI as a novel domain among emerging economies grounded on the resource-based view theory.

College of Business Administration Al Yamamah University Riyadh Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

Faculty of Technology Management and Business Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia Batu Pahat Malaysia

Science and Research Centre Faculty of Economics and Administration University of Pardubice 53210 Pardubice Czech Republic

Zobrazit více v PubMed

Abad-Segura E, González-Zamar MD, Infante-Moro JC, Ruipérez García G. Sustainable management of digital transformation in higher education: global research trends. Sustainability. 2020;12(5):2107.

Anwar M. Business model innovation and SMEs performance—does competitive advantage mediate? Int J Innov Manag. 2018;22(07):1850057.

Anwar M, Khattak MS, Popp J, Meyer DF, Máté D. The nexus of government incentives and sustainable development goals: is the management of resources the solution to non-profit organisations? Technol Econ Dev Econ. 2020;26(6):1284–1310.

Anwar M, Khan SZ, Shah SZA. Big data capabilities and firm’s performance: a mediating role of competitive advantage. J Inf Knowl Manag. 2018;17(04):1850045.

Asgary A, Ozdemir AI, Ozyürek H. Small and medium enterprises and global risks: evidence from manufacturing SMEs in Turkey. Int J Dis Risk Sci. 2020;11:59–73.

Awan U, Sroufe R, Shahbaz M. Industry 4.0 and the circular economy: a literature review and recommendations for future research. Bus Strat Environ. 2021;30:2038–2060. doi: 10.1002/bse.2731. DOI

Bapat D, Mazumdar D. Assessment of business strategy: implication for Indianbanks. J Strateg Manag. 2015;8(4):306–325.

Barney J. Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. J Manage. 1991;17(1):99–120.

Barros MV, Salvador R, do Prado GF, de Francisco AC, Piekarski CM. Circular economy as a driver to sustainable businesses. Clean Environ Syst. 2021;2:100006.

Batista DS, de Oliveira Lisboa PCJV, Augusto MG, de Almeida FEB. Effectiveness of business strategies in Brazilian textile industry. Rev ADM. 2016;51(2):225–239.

Bleischwitz R, Yang M, Huang B, Xiaozhen XU, Zhou J, McDowall W, Yong G. The circular economy in China: achievements, challenges and potential implications for decarbonisation. Resour Conserv Recycl. 2022;183:106350.

Brown P, Bocken N, Balkenende R. Why do companies pursue collaborative circular Oriented Innovation? Sustainability. 2019;11:635.

Bucea-Manea-Țoniş R, Prokop V, Ilic D, Gurgu E, Bucea-Manea-Țoniş R, Braicu C, Moanță A. The relationship between Eco-innovation and smart working as support for sustainable management. Sustainability. 2021;13(3):1437.

Chaudhry NI, Rasool SF, Raza M, Mhelska H, Rehman FU (2023) Exploring the linkage between workplace precaution measures, Covid-19 fear and job performance: The moderating effect of academic competence. Curr Psychol 42:20239–20258. 10.1007/s12144-023-04728-5 PubMed PMC

Cronin JJ, Smith JS, Gleim MR, Ramirez E, Martinez JD. Green marketing strategies: an examination of stakeholders and the opportunities they present. J Acad Mark Sci. 2011;39(1):158–174.

Cracolici MF, Cuffaro M, Lacagnina V. Assessment of sustainable well-being in the Italian regions: an activity analysis model. Ecol Econ. 2018;143:105–110.

Dangelico RM, Vocalelli D. Green Marketing: An analysis of definitions, strategy steps, and tools through a systematic review of the literature. J Clean Prod. 2017;165:1263–1279.

DeCajas AU, Seguros BY. La Economía Circular enel Sector Agroalimentario. Adicae: Brussels, Belgium; 2013.

Deutz P. Circular Economy, International Encyclopedia of Human Geography (Second Edition) Elsevier; 2020. pp. 193–201.

Dey PK, Malesios C, De D, Chowdhury S, Abdelaziz FB. The impact of lean management practices and sustainably oriented innovation on sustainability performance of small and medium-sized enterprises: empirical evidence from the UK. Br J Manag. 2020;31:141–161.

Fornell CG, Larcker DF. Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error. J Market Res. 1981;18(1):39–50.

García-Sánchez IM, Somohano-Rodríguez FM, Amor-Esteban V, Frías-Aceituno JV. Which region and which sector leads the circular economy? CEBIX, a multivariant index based on business actions. J Environ Manage. 2021;297:113299. PubMed

Garetti M, Taisch M. Sustainable manufacturing: trends and research challenges Prod Plann. Control. 2012;23:83–104.

Ghisellini P, Cialani C, Ulgiati S. A review on circular economy: the expected transition to a balanced interplay of environmental and economic systems. J Clean Prod. 2016;114:11–32.

Giannetti BF, Agostinho F, Eras JC, Yang Z, Almeida CMVB. Cleaner production for achieving the sustainable development goals. J Clean Prod. 2020;271:122127.

Groening C, Sarkis J, Zhu Q. Green marketing consumer-level theory review: a compendium of applied theories and further research directions. J Clean Prod. 2018;172:1848–1866.

Hair JF, Hult GT M, Ringle C, Sarstedt M (2016) A primer on partial least squares structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM), 2nd edn, Sage Publications

Hart SL, Milstein MB. Creating sustainable value. Acad Manag Perspect. 2003;17(2):56–67.

Herrero-Luna S, Latorre-Martinez M, Ferrer-Serrano M (2022) Circular economy and innovation: a systematic literature review. Cent Eur Bus Revi 11(1). 10.18267/j.cebr.275

Horbach J, Prokop V, Stejskal J (2022) Determinants of firms' greenness towards sustainable development: a multi-country analysis. Bus Strategy Environ. 10.1002/bse.3275

Huang X. The roles of competition on innovation efficiency and firm performance: evidence from the Chinese manufacturing industry. Eur Res Manag Bus Econ. 2023;29(1):100201.

Hudecheck M, Sirén C, Grichnik D, Wincent J (2020) How companies can respond to the coronavirus. MIT Sloan Manag Rev. https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/how-companies-can-respondto-the-coronavirus/

Hurnyak I, Pardal P, Horak J, Machova V. Competitiveness of human and business in term of stock market analysis. Scientific Papers of the University of Pardubice, Series D: Faculty of Economics and Administration. 2022;30(2):1557.

Jakhar SK, Mangla SK, Luthra S, Kusi-Sarpong S. When stakeholder pressure drives the circular economy measuring the mediating role of innovation capabilities. Manag Decis. 2019;57(4):904–920.

Johnson MP, Schaltegger S. Two decades of sustainability management tools for SMEs: how far have we come? J Small Bus Manag. 2016;54:481–505.

Joyce P, Winch G (2004) A framework for codifying business models and process models in e-Business design. In: Value creation from e-business models. Butterworth-Heinemann, pp 35–64. 10.1016/B978-075066140-9/50005-9

Kabra AG, Akhtar RP, Dash MK. Understanding behavioural intention to use information technology: insights from humanitarian practitioners. Telemat Inform. 2017;34(7):1250–1261.

Kain VJ. Pilot study of an instrument to measure attitudes to palliative care practice in neonatal intensive care nursing. Collegian. 2007;14(4):16–20. PubMed

Karman A, Prokop V, Giglio C, Rehman FU (2023) Has the Covid-19 pandemic jeopardized firms' environmental behavior? Bridging green initiatives and firm value through the triple bottom line approach. Corp Soc Respon Environ Manag 1–21. 10.1002/csr.2575

Khajuria A. Integrated approach between DPSIR, planetary boundaries and sustainable development goals~ towards 3Rs and resource efficiency. World Environ. 2020;10:52–56.

Kinugasa T. The Schumpeterian hypothesis and technical change. Int J Soc Econ. 1998;25(6/7/8):1207–1216.

Kirchherr J, Reike D, Hekkert M. Conceptualizing the circular economy: an analysis of 114 definitions. Resour Conserv Recycl. 2017;127:221–232.

Klewitz J, Hansen EG. Sustainability-oriented innovation of SMEs: a systematic review. J Clean Prod. 2014;65:57–75.

Köhler J, Sönnichsen SD, Beske-Jansen P. Towards a collaboration framework for circular economy: the role of dynamic capabilities and open innovation. Bus Strategy Environ. 2022;31(6):2700–2713.

Korsakienė R, Raišienė AG. Sustainability drivers of small and medium sized firms: a review and research agenda. Scientific Papers of the University of Pardubice, Series D: Faculty of Economics and Administration. 2022;30(1):1380.

Kshetri, N. (2008). The rapidly transforming chinese high-technology industry and market: institutions, ingredients, mechanisms and modus operandi, 1st edn. Chandos Asian Studies Series

Lechner C, Gudmundsson SV. Entrepreneurial orientation, firm strategy andsmall firmperformance. Int Small Bus J. 2014;32(1):36–60.

Lewandowski M. Designing the business models for circular economy-towards the conceptual framework. Sustainability. 2016;8:43.

Lii P, Kuo FI. Innovation-oriented supply chain integration for combined competitiveness and firm performance. Int J Prod Econ. 2016;174:142–155.

Lopez-Perez ME, Melero I, Javier Sese F. Management for sustainable development and its impact on firm value in the SME context: does size matter? Bus Strat Environ. 2017;26:985–999.

Ly B. Competitive advantage and internationalization of a circular economy model in apparel multinationals. Cogent Bus Manag. 2021;8(1):1944012.

Mazzucchelli A, Chierici R, Del Giudice M, Bua I. Do circular economy practices affect corporate performance? Evidence from Italian large-sized manufacturing firms. Corp Soc Respon Environ Manag. 2022;29(6):2016–2029.

Miller K, Neubauer A, Varma A, Williams E (2011) First Assessment of the Environmental Compliance Assistance Programme for SMEs (ECAP). European Commission DG Environment and Climate Action and AEA Technology. London.  ENV.C.1/ETU/2010/0032r

Mir KA, Purohit P, Cail S, Kim S. Co-benefits of air pollution control and climate change mitigation strategies in Pakistan. Environ Sci Policy. 2022;133:31–43.

Moraga G, Huysveld S, De Meester S, Dewulf J. Development of circularity indicators based on the in-use occupation of materials. J Clean Prod. 2021;279:123889.

Mwangi GM, Despoudi S, Espindola OR, Spanaki K, Papadopoulos T (2021) A planetary boundaries perspective on the sustainability: resilience relationship in the Kenyan tea supply chain. Ann Oper Res. 10.1007/s10479-021-04096-y PubMed PMC

Mulkay B. How does competition affect innovation behaviour in french firms? Struct Chang Econ Dyn. 2019;51:237–251.

Ntsonde J, Aggeri F. Stimulating innovation and creating new markets–the potential of circular public procurement. J Clean Prod. 2021;308:127303.

Nussholz JL. A circular business model mapping tool for creating value from prolonged product lifetime and closed material loops. J Clean Prod. 2018;197:185–194.

OECD (2018a) Environmental policy toolkit for SME greening in EU Eastern Partnership Countries. OECD Green growth studies. OECD Publishing, Paris. 10.1787/9789264293199-en

OECD (2018b) SMEs: Key drivers of green and inclusive growth. In: GGKP6 2018 & forum annual conference, environment directorate. OECD, Paris

Ormazabal M, Prieto-Sandoval V, Puga-Leal R, Jaca C. Circular economy in Spanish SMEs: challenges and opportunities. J Clean Prod. 2018;185:157–167.

Papadas KK, Avlonitis GJ, Carrigan M, Piha L. The interplay of strategic and internal green marketing orientation on competitive advantage. J Bus Res. 2019;104:632–643.

Parker CM, Redmond J, Simpson M. A review of interventions to encourage SMEs to make. Environ Improv. 2009;27:279–301.

Peterková J, Czerná K, Zimmermannová J. Innovation ecosystem in selected regions of the Czech Republic and Poland: specifics of infrastructure supporting innovative entrepreneurship. Scientific papers of the University of Pardubice. Series D, Faculty of Economics and Administration. 2022;30(1):1550.

Pieroni MP, McAloone TC, Pigosso DC. Business model innovation for circular economy and sustainability: a review of approaches. J Clean Prod. 2019;215:198–216.

Porter M (1996) America’s Green Strategy. Business and the environment: A reader: 33:1072

Prieto-Sandoval V, Jaca C, Santos J, Baumgartner RJ, Ormazabal M. Key strategies, resources, and capabilities for implementing circular economy in industrial small and medium enterprises. Corp Soc Respon Environ Manag. 2019;26(6):1473–1484.

Prokop V, Gerstlberger W, Zapletal D, Striteska MK. The double-edged role of firm environmental behaviour in the creation of product innovation in Central and Eastern European countries. J Clean Prod. 2022;331:129989.

Prokop V, Stejskal J, Merickova BM, Odei SA. Revealing the importance of international and domestic cooperation by using artificial neural networks: case of European radical and incremental innovators. Eur J Innov Manag. 2023;26(2):531–563.

Pucci T, Nosi C, Zanni L. Firm capabilities, business model design and performance of SMEs. J Small Bus Enterp Dev. 2017;24(2):222–241.

Ranjbari M, Saidani M, Esfandabadi ZS, Peng W, Lam SS, Aghbashlo M, Tabatabaei M. Two decades of research on waste management in the circular economy: insights from bibliometric, text mining, and content analyses. J Clean Prod. 2021;314:128009.

Rasool SF, Samma M, Mohelska H, Rehman FU. Investigating the nexus between information technology capabilities, knowledge management, and green product innovation: evidence from SME industry. Environ Sci Pollut Res. 2023;1:1–14. PubMed

Razminiene K, Tvaronaviciene M. Detecting the linkagesbetween clusters and circular economy. Terra Econ. 2018;16(4):50–65.

Rehman FU (2023) Mapping the two-way relationship between management practices and firm innovation: the mediating role of business environment, degree of competition, and energy policies. Eur Bus Rev. 10.1108/EBR-10-2022-0212

Rehman FU, Zeb A (2023a) Translating the impacts of social advertising on Muslim consumers buying behavior: the moderating role of brand image. J Islam Mark 14(9):2207–2234

Rehman FU, Zeb A (2023b) Investigating the nexus between authentic leadership, employees’ green creativity, and psychological environment: evidence from emerging economy. Environ Sci Pollut Res 1–13 PubMed PMC

Rehman AU, Anwar M. Mediating role of enterprise risk management practices between business strategy and SME performance. Small Enterp Res. 2019;26(2):207–227.

Rehman FU, Al-Ghazali BM, Haddad AG, Qahwash EA, Sohail MS. Exploring the reverse relationship between circular economy innovation and digital sustainability – the dual mediation of government incentives. Sustainability. 2023;23(15):1–21.

Rehman FU, Ismail H, Al Ghazali BM, Asad MM, Shahbaz MS, Zeb A. Knowledge management process, knowledge based innovation: does academic researcher’s productivity mediate during the pandemic of covid-19? PloS One. 2021;16(12):1–20. PubMed PMC

Rehman FU, Al-Ghazali BM, Farook MRM. Interplay in circular economy innovation, business model innovation, SDGs, and government incentives: a comparative analysis of Pakistani, Malaysian, and Chinese SMEs. Sustainability. 2022;14(23):15586.

Rehman FU, Prokop V. Interplay in management practices, innovation, business environment, degree of competition and environmental policies: a comparative study. Bus Process Manag J. 2023;29(3):858–892.

Rehman FU, Sein YY, Dmytrenko D. Translating the impact of internal and external factors in achieving the sustainable market competitiveness: the mediating role of management practices. J Compet. 2023;15(1):68–86.

ur Rehman F, Yusoff RBM, Zabri SBM, Ismail FB. Impacts of psychological capital on the ethical behavior of teachers: a case of educational sector in Pakistan. MATEC Web of Conferences. 2018;150:05032.

Rehman FU (2019) Factors influencing buying behavior of fashion clothing brands in Johor and Wilayah Persekutuan (Doctoral dissertation). Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia

Rind AA, Asad MM, Marri SA, Sherwani F, Rehman FU. How integration of information and communication technologies impact academic achievement? An empirical study on Sindh education foundation. J Appl Res High Educ. 2022;14(4):1761–1772.

Ringle CM, Wende S, Becker JM (2015) SmartPLS 3. SmartPLS GmbH, Boenningstedt. http://www.smartpls.com

Rizwanullah, Ahmad H, Rehman FU, Fawad A (2021) Green innovation and sustainable development goals in SMEs: The moderating role of government incentives. J Econ Finance Adm Sci. 10.1108/JEAS-07-2021-0122

Rodríguez-Espíndola O, Cuevas-Romo A, Chowdhury S, Díaz-Acevedo N, Albores P, Despoudi S, Dey P. The role of circular economy principles and sustainable-oriented innovation to enhance social, economic and environmental performance: evidence from Mexican SMEs. Int J Prod Econ. 2022;248:108495.

Rodríguez-Espíndola O, Chowdhury S, Dey PK, Albores P, Emrouznejad A. Analysis of the adoption of emergent technologies for risk management in the era of digital manufacturing. Technol Forecast Soc Change. 2022;178:121562.

Rodríguez-Antón JM (2019) La Economía circular comomodeloimpulsor de los Objetivos de Desarrollo Sostenible. In: Alfaro M, Arias S, Gamba A (eds) Agenda 2030. Claves para la transformaciónsostenible. Los libros de la Catarata, pp 296–311

Rodríguez-Antón JM, Rubio-Andrada L, Celemín-Pedroche MS, Ruíz-Peñalver SM. From the circular economy to the sustainable development goals in the European Union: an empirical comparison. Int. Environ Agreem: Politics Law Econ. 2022;22(1):67–95. PubMed PMC

Rodríguez-Antón JM, Alonso-Almeida MM (2018) La estrategiaespañola de Economía circular y suadecuación al plan de acción de la Unión Europea para la Economía circular. In: Paper presented at 25th APDR Congress, Proceedings. Lisboa, pp 183–190

Rua O, França A, Ortiz R F (2018) Key drivers of SMEs export performance: the mediating effect of competitive advantage. J Knowl Manag 2(2):257–279. 10.1108/JKM-07-2017-0267

Saeidi SP, Sofian P, Saeidi P, Saeidi SP, Saeidi SA. How does corporate social responsibility contribute to firm financial performance? The mediating role ofcompetitive advantage, reputation, and customer satisfaction. J Bus Res. 2015;68(2):341–350.

Salvador R, Barros MV, da Luz LM, Piekarski CM, de Francisco AC. Circular business models: current aspects that influence implementation and unaddressed subjects. J Clean Prod. 2020;250:119555.

Salvador R, Barros MV, Freire F, Halog A, Piekarski CM, Antonio C. Circular economy strategies on business modelling: identifying the greatest influences. J Clean Prod. 2021;299:126918.

Sarkis J, Dhavale DG. Supplier selection for sustainable operations: a triple-bottom-line approach using a Bayesian framework. Int J Prod Econ. 2015;166:177–191.

Schulz SA, Flanigan RL. Developing competitive advantage using the triple bottom line: a conceptual framework. J Bus Ind Mark. 2016;31(4):449–458.

Sehnem S, Jabbour CJC, Pereira SCF, de Sousa JABL. Improving sustainable supply chains performance through operational excellence: circular economy approach. Resour Conserv Recycl. 2019;149:236–248.

Soh KL, Wong WP. Circular economy transition: exploiting innovative eco-design capabilities and customer involvement. J Clean Prod. 2021;320:128858.

Spring M, Araujo L. Product biographies in servitisation and the circular economy. Ind Mark Manag. 2017;60:126–137.

Stål HI, Corvellec H. A decoupling perspective on circular business model implementation: illustrations from Swedish apparel. J Clean Prod. 2018;171:630–643.

Suárez-Eiroa B, Fernández E, Méndez-Martínez G, Soto-Oñate D. Operational principles of circular economy for sustainable development: linking theory and practice. J Clean Prod. 2019;214:952–961.

Suchek N, Fernandes CI, Kraus S, Filser M, Sjögrén H. Innovation and the circular economy: a systematic literature review. Bus Strategy Environ. 2021;30(8):3686–3702.

Sullivan-Taylor B, Branicki L. Creating resilient SMEs: why one size might not fit all. Int J Prod Res. 2011;49:5565–5579.

Svensson G, Ferro C, Høgevold N, Padin C, Varela JCS, Sarstedt M. Framing the triple bottom line approach: direct and mediation effects between economic, social and environmental elements. J Clean Prod. 2018;197:972–991.

Syromyatnikov D, Konev P, Popov M, Sultanova N (2021) Practical strategies to improve national competitiveness. In: Scientific papers of the University of Pardubice, Series D: Faculty of Economics and Administration 29(2):1315

Tang KHD. Climate change in Malaysia: trends, contributors, impacts, mitigation and adaptations. Sci Total Environ. 2019;650:1858–1871. PubMed

Teece DJ. Business models, business strategy and innovation. Long Range Planning. 2010;43(2):172–194.

Ting LS, Zailani S, Sidek NZM, Shaharudin MR (2023) Motivators and barriers of circular economy business model adoption and its impact on sustainable production in Malaysia. Environ Dev Sustain: 1–28.10.1007/s10668-023-03350-6 PubMed PMC

Uddin A, Ali Y, Sabir M, Petrillo A, De Felice F. Circular economy and its implementation in cement industry: a case point in Pakistan. Sci Total Environ. 2023;898:165605. PubMed

Udriyah U, Tham J, Azam S. The effects of market orientation and innovation on competitive advantage and business performance of textile SMEs. Manag Sci Lett. 2019;9(9):1419–1428.

UN (2015) Resolution adopted by the general assembly on 25 September 2015. Retrieved from: A/RES/70/1 Transforming our world: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (un.org). Accessed 11 Nov 2023

Valverde JM, Avilés-Palacios C. Circular economy as a catalyst for progress towards the sustainable development goals: a positive relationship between two self-sufficient variables. Sustainability. 2021;13(22):12652.

Wang N, Lee JCK, Zhang J, Chen H, Li H. Evaluation of urban circular economy development: an empiricalresearch of 40 cities in China. J Clean Prod. 2018;180:876–887.

White K, Habib R, Hardisty DJ. How to SHIFT consumer behaviors to be more sustainable: a literature review and guiding framework. J Mark. 2019;83(3):22–49.

Wiebe KS, Norstebø VS, Aponte FR, Simas MS, Andersen T, Perez-Valdes GA. Circular Economy and the triple bottom line in Norway. Circ Econ Sust. 2023;3(1):1–33.

Yasa N, Giantari IGAK, Setini M, Rahmayanti PJMSL. The role of competitive advantage in mediating the effect of promotional strategy on marketing performance. Manag Sci Lett. 2020;10(12):2845–2848.

Ye K, Zhu W, Shan Y, Li S. Effects of market competition on the sustainability performance of the construction industry: China case. J Constr Eng Manag. 2015;141(9):04015025.

Yee RW, Yeung AC, Cheng TE, Lee PK. Market competitiveness and quality performance in high-contact service industries. Ind Manag Data Syst. 2013;113(4):573–588.

Zeb A, Rehman FU, Imran M, Ali M, Almansoori RG. Authentic leadership traits, high-performance human resource practices and job performance in Pakistan. Int J Public Leadersh. 2020;16(3):299–317.

Zeb A, Ur Rehman F, Arsalan Y, Usman Khan M. Does organizational justice enhance job performance through high-performance human resource practices? WPOM-Working Papers Oper Manag. 2021;12(2):16–40.