A LEAP Forward in Wildlife Conservation: A Standardized Framework to Determine Mortality Causes in Large GPS-Tagged Birds
Status PubMed-not-MEDLINE Jazyk angličtina Země Anglie, Velká Británie Médium electronic-ecollection
Typ dokumentu časopisecké články
PubMed
40170813
PubMed Central
PMC11949540
DOI
10.1002/ece3.70975
PII: ECE370975
Knihovny.cz E-zdroje
- Klíčová slova
- GPS tracking, bird crime, cause of death, human‐wildlife conflict, population monitoring, survival analysis, wildlife conservation,
- Publikační typ
- časopisecké články MeSH
Anthropogenic activities threaten many wildlife populations by increasing mortality rates, making it crucial to identify the locations and causes of mortality to inform conservation actions. Technological advancements, such as GPS satellite tracking, enable precise recording of wildlife movements. High-resolution data from such devices can facilitate rapid carcass recovery and provide insights into the mortality causes of tagged individuals. Obtaining required information to determine these causes is complex, and standardized approaches can overcome these limitations. In this study, we introduce the LIFE EUROKITE Assessment Protocol (LEAP), a framework for determining the timing, locations, and causes of mortality in GPS-tagged birds. LEAP is a multifaceted approach that integrates: (1) GPS tracking data, (2) evidence from the mortality location (site investigation), and (3) necropsy results to derive the mortality cause and a corresponding certainty score. We supplement the detailed description of LEAP with case studies assessing its effectiveness. Using 329 deceased GPS-tagged red kites (Milvus milvus) we compared conditions of the carcasses processed using LEAP with 145 opportunistically collected raptor carcasses. We also show that LEAP improves carcass condition and therefore allows for higher quality necropsy results. Additionally, we assessed how availability among sources of information (tracking, site investigation and necropsy) influences the quality of mortality assessments. Applying LEAP with all data sources provided the highest quality assessments in 64% of cases. Some 35% of cases were of high quality without necropsy, instead drawing evidence only from tracking data and site investigations. Predation related mortality was less prevalent (11%) when relying on necropsy compared to cases without necropsy (36%), while poisoning showed the opposite trend. Furthermore, we provide guidelines and empirical examples of mortality assessments. Our standardized LEAP approach ensures the best use of all available information regarding mortality events in GPS-tagged birds and advances wildlife mortality research as a valuable tool for conservationists and wildlife managers.
Acción Por el Mundo Salvaje Villafranca Spain
ANITRA System s r o Praha Czech Republic
Arabako Foru Aldundia Diputación Foral de Álava Vitoria Gasteiz ES Spain
Asociación Hontza Salvatierra Agurain Spain
Biological Station Gütersloh Bielefeld Bielefeld Germany
Brandenburg State Agency for Environment Bird Conservation Centre Buckow Germany
CERM Endangered Raptors Centre Association Rocchette di Fazio Italy
Czech Society for Ornithology Praha Czech Republic
Deltamilieu Projecten Vlissingen the Netherlands
Département Études Natagora Namur Belgium
Department of Animal Behaviour Bielefeld University Bielefeld Germany
Department of Behavioural Ecology Bielefeld University Bielefeld Germany
Department of Biology Lund University Lund Sweden
Department of Biology University of Turku Turku Finland
Department of Ornithology Aranzadi Sciences Society San Sebastián Spain
Des op Záchranná Stanice živočichů Plzeň Plzeň Czech Republic
District of Lippe Lower Nature Conservation Authority Detmold Germany
Ecological and Forestry Applications Research Centre Bellaterra Catalonia Spain
Fertő Hanság Nemzeti Park Igazgatóság Sarród Hungary
Förderverein für Ökologie Und Monitoring von Greifvogel und Eulenarten e 5 Halle Germany
Förderverein Sächsische Vogelschutzwarte Neschwitz eV Neschwitz Germany
Gobierno de Aragon Edificio San Pedro Nolasco Zaragoza Spain
Independent Researcher Madrid Spain
Institute of Materials Chemistry TU Wien Vienna Austria
Instituto de Investigación en Recursos Cinegéticos Ciudad Real Spain
LEA LandesEnergieAgentur Hessen GmbH Wiesbaden Germany
Leibniz Institute for zoo and Wildlife Research Department Wildlife Diseases Berlin Germany
LIFE EUROKITE External Assistant Březolupy Czech Republic
LIFE EUROKITE External Assistant Bützow Germany
LIFE EUROKITE External Assistant Germany
LIFE EUROKITE External Assistant Gifhorn Germany
LIFE EUROKITE External Assistant Planá nad LužnicíLužnicí Czech Republic
LIFE EUROKITE External Assistant Praha Czech Republic
LIFE EUROKITE External Assistant Uelzen Germany
LIFE EUROKITE External Assistant Weimar Germany
LPO AURA Auvergne Clermont Ferrand France
LPO AURA Loire Saint Étienne France
LPO Champagne Ardenne Ferme Des Grands Parts Outines France
LPO France Direction Territoriale Aquitaine Avenue de la Gare Saint Jean pied de port France
LPO France Fonderies Royales Rochefort CS France
LPO Occitanie Palmas d'Aveyron Aveyron France
Max Planck Institute of Animal Behavior Radolfzell am Bodensee Germany
Mitteleuropäische Gesellschaft Zur Erhaltung der Greifvögel Deutschland Fulda Germany
Natur and ëmwelt ASBL Kockelscheuer Luxembourg
Naturschutzsyndikat Sicona Luxembourg Luxembourg
Navarra Environmental Management Pamplona Spain
Ochrana Dravcov Na Slovensku Raptor Protection of Slovakia Bratislava Slovakia
ÖKOTOP Büro für Angewandte Landschaftsökologie Halle Germany
Pro Vértes Természetvédelmi Közalapítvány Hungary
Research Institute of Wildlife Ecology Department for Interdisciplinary Life Sciences Vienna Austria
Rotmilanzentrum Am Heineanum Halberstadt Germany
RSPB Scotland Edinburgh Scotland UK
School of Applied Sciences Moulsecoomb Campus University of Brighton Brighton UK
School of Geography University Park Campus University of Nottingham Nottingham UK
Swiss Ornithological Institute Sempach Switzerland
TB Raab GmbH Deutsch Wagram Austria
Turku Collegium for Science Medicine and Technology University of Turku Turku Finland
Zobrazit více v PubMed
Baert, J. M. , Stienen E. W., Heylen B. C., et al. 2018. “High‐Resolution GPS Tracking Reveals Sex Differences in Migratory Behaviour and Stopover Habitat Use in the Lesser Black‐Backed Gull Larus Fuscus .” Scientific Reports 8: 5391. PubMed PMC
Balmori, A. 2019. “Endangered Bird Mortality by Gunshots: Still a Current Problem.” Biodiversity and Conservation 28: 2555–2564.
Bellan, S. E. , Gimenez O., Choquet R., and Getz W. M.. 2013. “A Hierarchical Distance Sampling Approach to Estimating Mortality Rates From Opportunistic Carcass Surveillance Data.” Methods in Ecology and Evolution 4: 361–369. PubMed PMC
Bergen, S. , Huso M. M., Duerr A. E., et al. 2022. “Classifying Behavior From Short‐Interval Biologging Data: An Example With GPS Tracking of Birds.” Ecology and Evolution 12: e08395. PubMed PMC
Brochet, A. L. , Van den Bossche W., Jbour S., et al. 2016. “Preliminary Assessment of the Scope and Scale of Illegal Killing and Taking of Birds in the Mediterranean.” Bird Conservation International 26: 1–28.
Brooks, T. M. , Mittermeier R. A., Da Fonseca G. A., et al. 2006. “Global Biodiversity Conservation Priorities.” Science 313: 58–61. PubMed
Brownlie, H. W. B. , and Munro R.. 2016. “The Veterinary Forensic Necropsy: A Review of Procedures and Protocols.” Veterinary Pathology 53: 919–928. PubMed
Ceballos, G. , Ehrlich P. R., and Dirzo R.. 2017. “Biological Annihilation via the Ongoing Sixth Mass Extinction Signaled by Vertebrate Population Losses and Declines.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 114: E6089–E6096. PubMed PMC
Christensen, T. K. , Lassen P., and Elmeros M.. 2012. “High Exposure Rates of Anticoagulant Rodenticides in Predatory Bird Species in Intensively Managed Landscapes in Denmark.” Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 63: 437–444. PubMed
Cioffi, W. R. , Quick N. J., Swaim Z. T., et al. 2023. “Trade‐Offs in Telemetry Tag Programming for Deep‐Diving Cetaceans: Data Longevity, Resolution, and Continuity.” Animal Biotelemetry 11: 23.
Cochran, W. W. 1980. “Wildlife Telemetry.” In Wildlife Management Techniques Manual, edited by Schemnitz S. D., 507–520. Wildlife Society.
Commission of the European Communities . 2007. “2007/416/EC: Commission Decision of 13 June 2007 Concerning the Non‐Inclusion of Carbofuran in Annex I to Council Directive 91/414/EEC and the Withdrawal of Authorisations for Plant Protection Products Containing that Substance.” https://eur‐lex.europa.eu/legal‐content/GA/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32007D0416.
Cooper, J. E. 2021. “Wildlife Forensic Pathology.” In Wildlife Biodiversity Conservation: Multidisciplinary and Forensic Approaches, edited by Underkoffler S. C. and Adams H. R., 211–286. Springer International Publishing.
Cristescu, B. , Elbroch L. M., Forrester T. D., et al. 2022. “Standardizing Protocols for Determining the Cause of Mortality in Wildlife Studies.” Ecology and Evolution 12: e9034. PubMed PMC
DeVault, T. L. , Olson Z. H., Beasley J. C., and Rhodes O. E.. 2011. “Mesopredators Dominate Competition for Carrion in an Agricultural Landscape.” Basic and Applied Ecology 12: 268–274.
Espín, S. , Andevski J., Duke G., et al. 2021. “A Schematic Sampling Protocol for Contaminant Monitoring in Raptors.” Ambio 50: 95–100. PubMed PMC
Ewing, S. R. , Thomas C. E., Butcher N., et al. 2023. “Illegal Killing Associated With Gamebird Management Accounts for up to Three‐Quarters of Annual Mortality in Hen Harriers Circus cyaneus .” Biological Conservation 283: 110072.
Fernández‐García, M. , López‐Bao J. V., Olea P., et al. 2024. “Strengths and Limitations of Official Sources of Wildlife Poisoning Data: A Case Study in Europe.” Biological Conservation 294: 110636.
Finn, C. , Grattarola F., and Pincheira‐Donoso D.. 2023. “More Losers Than Winners: Investigating Anthropocene Defaunation Through the Diversity of Population Trends.” Biological Reviews 98: 1732–1748. PubMed
Fuller, M. R. , Millspaugh J., Church J., and Kenward K. E.. 2005. “Wildlife Radio Telemetry.” In Techniques for Wildlife Investigations and Management, edited by Braun C. E., 377–417. Wildlife Society.
Green, R. E. , Pain D. J., and Krone O.. 2022. “The Impact of Lead Poisoning From Ammunition Sources on Raptor Populations in Europe.” Science of the Total Environment 823: 154017. PubMed
Hill, J. E. , DeVault T. L., and Belant J. L.. 2019. “Cause‐Specific Mortality of the world's Terrestrial Vertebrates.” Global Ecology and Biogeography 28: 680–689.
Kagan, R. A. 2016. “Electrocution of Raptors on Power Lines: A Review of Necropsy Methods and Finding.” Veterinary Pathology 53: 1030–1036. PubMed
Katzner, T. E. , Carlisle J. D., Poessel S. A., et al. 2020. “Illegal Killing of Nongame Wildlife and Recreational Shooting in Conservation Areas.” Conservation Science and Practice 2: e279.
Kays, R. , Davidson S. C., Berger M., et al. 2021. “The Movebank System for Studying Global Animal Movement and Demography.” Methods in Ecology and Evolution 13: 419–431.
Kenward, R. E. 1985. “Raptor Radio‐Tracking and Telemetry.” ICBP Technical Publication 5, e420.
Klaassen, R. H. , Hake M., Strandberg R., et al. 2014. “When and Where Does Mortality Occur in Migratory Birds? Direct Evidence From Long‐Term Satellite Tracking of Raptors.” Journal of Animal Ecology 83: 176–184. PubMed
LaDue, C. A. , Eranda I., Jayasinghe C., and Vandercone R. P.. 2021. “Mortality Patterns of Asian Elephants in a Region of Human–Elephant Conflict.” Journal of Wildlife Management 85: 794–802.
Langgemach, T. , Dürr T., Hein U., Herold S., Lippert J., and Sömmer P.. 2023. “Verlustursachen Beim Rotmilan Milvus milvus in Brandenburg im Laufe Der Letzten Drei Jahrzehnte.” Die Vogelwelt 141: 157–177.
Mateo‐Tomás, P. , Olea P. P., Sánchez‐Barbudo I. S., and Mateo R.. 2012. “Alleviating Human‐Wildlife Conflicts: Identifying the Causes and Mapping the Risk of Illegal Poisoning of Wild Fauna.” Journal of Applied Ecology 49: 376–385.
McClure, C. J. , Westrip J. R. S., Johnson J. A., et al. 2018. “State of the world's Raptors: Distributions, Threats, and Conservation Recommendations.” Biological Conservation 227: 390–402.
Molenaar, F. M. , Jaffe J. E., Carter I., et al. 2017. “Poisoning of Reintroduced Red Kites (Milvus milvus) in England.” European Journal of Wildlife Research 63: 94.
Molinari‐Jobin, A. , Kéry M., Marboutin E., et al. 2012. “Monitoring in the Presence of Species Misidentification: The Case of the Eurasian Lynx in the Alps.” Animal Conservation 15: 266–273.
Mullineaux, E. 2014. “Veterinary Treatment and Rehabilitation of Indigenous Wildlife.” Journal of Small Animal Practice 55: 293–300. PubMed
Mullineaux, E. , and Pawson C.. 2023. “Trends in Admissions and Outcomes at a British Wildlife Rehabilitation Centre Over a Ten‐Year Period.” Animals 14: 86. PubMed PMC
Munns, W. R. . 2006. “Assessing Risks to Wildlife Populations From Multiple Stressors: Overview of the Problem and Research Needs.” Ecology and Society 11, no. 1: 23.
Murgatroyd, M. , Redpath S. M., Murphy S. G., Douglas D. J. T., Saunders R., and Amar A.. 2019. “Patterns of Satellite Tagged Hen Harrier Disappearances Suggest Widespread Illegal Killing on British Grouse Moors.” Nature Communications 10: 1094. PubMed PMC
Naef‐Daenzer, B. , Korner‐Nievergelt F., Fiedler W., and Grüebler M. U.. 2017. “Bias in Ring‐Recovery Studies: Causes of Mortality of Little Owls Athene Noctua and Implications for Population Assessment.” Journal of Avian Biology 48: 266–274.
Nurse, A. 2015. “Prosecuting Wildlife Crime.” In Policing Wildlife. Palgrave Studies in Green Criminology. Palgrave Macmillan.
Ogada, D. L. 2014. “The Power of Poison: Pesticide Poisoning of Africa's Wildlife.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1322: 1–20. PubMed
Panter, C. T. , Allen S., Backhouse N., Mullineaux E., Rose C.‐A., and Amar A.. 2022. “Causes, Temporal Trends, and the Effects of Urbanization on Admissions of Wild Raptors to Rehabilitation Centers in England and Wales.” Ecology and Evolution 12: e8856. PubMed PMC
Pérez‐García, J. M. , Sebastián‐González E., Rodríguez‐Caro R., Sanz‐Aguilar A., and Botella F.. 2023. “Blind Shots: Non‐natural Mortality Counteracts Conservation Efforts of a Threatened Waterbird.” Animal Conservation 27: 1–14.
Prakash, S. , and Verma A. K.. 2022. “Anthropogenic Activities and Biodiversity Threats.” International Journal of Biological Innovations 4: 94–103.
R Core Team . 2023. “R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing.” R Foundation for Statistical Computing. https://www.R‐project.org.
Sergio, F. , Tanferna A., Blas J., Blanco G., and Hiraldo F.. 2018. “Reliable Methods for Identifying Animal Deaths in GPS‐and Satellite‐Tracking Data: Review, Testing, and Calibration.” Journal of Applied Ecology 56: 562–572.
Sergio, F. , Tavecchia G., Tanferna A., et al. 2015. “No Effect of Satellite Tagging on Survival, Recruitment, Longevity, Productivity and Social Dominance of a Raptor, and the Provisioning and Conditioning of Its Offspring.” Journal of Applied Ecology 52: 1665–1675.
Serratosa, J. , Oppel S., Rotics S., et al. 2024. “Tracking Data Highlight the Importance of Human‐Induced Mortality for Large Migratory Birds at a Flyway Scale.” Biological Conservation 293: 110525.
Silva, R. , Afán I., Gil J. A., and Bustamante J.. 2017. “Seasonal and Circadian Biases in Bird Tracking With Solar GPS‐Tags.” PLoS One 12: e0185344. PubMed PMC
Simancas‐Racines, A. , Cadena‐Ullauri S., Guevara‐Ramírez P., Zambrano A. K., and Simancas‐Racines D.. 2023. “Avian Influenza: Strategies to Manage an Outbreak.” Pathogens 12: 610. PubMed PMC
Stevens, B. S. , and Dennis B.. 2013. “Wildlife Mortality From Infrastructure Collisions: Statistical Modeling of Count Data From Carcass Surveys.” Ecology 94: 2087–2096. PubMed
Thomason, E. , Wallen K., and Katzner T.. 2023. “Social and Biological Perspectives to Investigate and Address Illegal Shooting of Raptors.” Global Ecology and Conservation 46: e02631.
Valverde, I. , Espín S., María‐Mojica P., and García‐Fernández A. J.. 2020. “Protocol to Classify the Stages of Carcass Decomposition and Estimate the Time of Death in Small‐Size Raptors.” European Journal of Wildlife Research 66: 93.
Venables, W. N. , and Ripley B. D.. 2002. Modern Applied Statistics With S. 4th ed. Springer.
Whitfield, D. P. , and Fielding A. H.. 2017. “Analyses of the Fates of Satellite Tracked Golden Eagles in Scotland. Scottish Natural Heritage Commissioned Report no 982.” Scottish Natural Heritage, Edinburgh.