Concern that European forest biodiversity is depleted and declining has provoked widespread efforts to improve management practices. To gauge the success of these actions, appropriate monitoring of forest ecosystems is paramount. Multi-species indicators are frequently used to assess the state of biodiversity and its response to implemented management, but generally applicable and objective methodologies for species' selection are lacking. Here we use a niche-based approach, underpinned by coarse quantification of species' resource use, to objectively select species for inclusion in a pan-European forest bird indicator. We identify both the minimum number of species required to deliver full resource coverage and the most sensitive species' combination, and explore the trade-off between two key characteristics, sensitivity and redundancy, associated with indicators comprising different numbers of species. We compare our indicator to an existing forest bird indicator selected on the basis of expert opinion and show it is more representative of the wider community. We also present alternative indicators for regional and forest type specific monitoring and show that species' choice can have a significant impact on the indicator and consequent projections about the state of the biodiversity it represents. Furthermore, by comparing indicator sets drawn from currently monitored species and the full forest bird community, we identify gaps in the coverage of the current monitoring scheme. We believe that adopting this niche-based framework for species' selection supports the objective development of multi-species indicators and that it has good potential to be extended to a range of habitats and taxa.

BirdLife Europe Brussels Belgium

BirdLife International Cambridge United Kingdom

Centre for Agri Environmental Research School of Agriculture Policy and Development University of Reading Reading United Kingdom

Czech Society for Ornithology Prague Czech Republic; Department of Zoology and Laboratory of Ornithology Faculty of Science Palacký University Olomouc Czech Republic

School of Biological Sciences University of East Anglia Norwich Research Park Norwich United Kingdom

School of Computing Sciences University of East Anglia Norwich Research Park Norwich United Kingdom

The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds The Lodge Sandy Bedfordshire United Kingdom

See more in PubMed

Bengtsson J, Nilsson SG, Franc A, Menozzi P (2000) Biodiversity, disturbances, ecosystem function and management of European forests. Forest Ecology and Management 132: 39–50.

Forest Europe, UNECE FAO (2011) State of Europe's forests. Status and trends in sustainable forest management in Europe. Oslo: Forest Europe Liaison Unit.

Paillet Y, Berges L, Hjalten J, Odor P, Avon C, et al. (2010) Biodiversity Differences between Managed and Unmanaged Forests: Meta-Analysis of Species Richness in Europe. Conservation Biology 24: 101–112. PubMed

Gregory RD, Vorisek P, Van Strien A, Meyling AWG, Jiguet F, et al. (2007) Population trends of widespread woodland birds in Europe. Ibis 149: 78–97.

Auld G, Gulbrandsen LH, McDermott CL (2008) Certification schemes and the impacts on forests and forestry. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 33: 187–211.

Pullin AS, Báldi A, CAN OE, Dieterich M, Kati V, et al. (2009) Conservation focus on Europe: major conservation policy issues that need to be informed by conservation science. Conservation Biology 23: 818–824. PubMed

Gregory RD, Vořišek P, Noble DG, Van Strien A, Klvaňová A, et al. (2008) The generation and use of bird population indicators in Europe. Bird Conservation International 18: S223–S244.

Niemi GJ, McDonald ME (2004) Application of ecological indicators. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 35: 89–111.

Dale VH, Beyeler SC (2001) Challenges in the development and use of ecological indicators. Ecological Indicators 1: 3–10.

Sætersdal M, Gjerde I, Blom HH (2005) Indicator species and the problem of spatial inconsistency in nestedness patterns. Biological Conservation 122: 305–316.

Roberge J-M, Angelstam P (2006) Indicator species among resident forest birds - A cross-regional evaluation in northern Europe. Biological Conservation 130: 134–147.

Butler SJ, Freckleton RP, Renwick AR, Norris K (2012) An objective, niche-based approach to indicator species selection. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 3: 317–326.

Gregory RD, van Strien A (2010) Wild Bird Indicators: Using Composite Population Trends of Birds as Measures of Environmental Health. Ornithological Science 9: 3–22.

Bradbury RB, Stoate C, Tallowin JRB (2010) Lowland farmland bird conservation in the context of wider ecosystem service delivery. Journal of Applied Ecology 47: 986–993.

Bryce SA, Hughes RM, Kaufmann PR (2002) Development of a bird integrity index: using bird assemblages as indicators of riparian condition. Environmental Management 30: 294–310. PubMed

Norris K, Harper N (2004) Extinction processes in hot spots of avian biodiversity and the targeting of pre-emptive conservation action. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 271: 123–130. PubMed PMC

Owens IPF, Bennett PM (2000) Ecological basis of extinction risk in birds: habitat loss versus human persecution and introduced predators. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 97: 12144–12148. PubMed PMC

Butler SJ, Vickery JA, Norris K (2007) Farmland biodiversity and the footprint of agriculture. Science 315: 381–384. PubMed

Tucker GM, Evans MI (1997) Habitats for Birds in Europe: A Conservation Strategy for the Wider Environment. Cambridge, UK: Birdlife International.

Snow DW, Perrins CM (1998) The birds of the Western Palearctic. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

Gregory RD, Van Strien A, Vorisek P, Gmelig Meyling AW, Noble DG, et al. (2005) Developing indicators for European birds. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 360: 269–288. PubMed PMC

Fuller RJ, Smith KW, Grice PV, Currie FA, Quine CP (2007) Habitat change and woodland birds in Britain: implications for management and future research. Ibis 149: 261–268.

Tellería JL, Baquero R, Santos T (2003) Effects of forest fragmentation on European birds: implications of regional differences in species richness. Journal of Biogeography 30: 621–628.

Angelstam P, Roberge JM, Lohmus A, Bergmanis M, Brazaitis G, et al. (2004) Habitat modelling as a tool for landscape-scale conservation–a review of parameters for focal forest birds. Ecological Bulletins 51: 427–453.

Mikusiński G, Gromadzki M, Chylarecki P (2001) Woodpeckers as Indicators of Forest Bird Diversity. Conservation Biology 15: 208–217.

Thaxter CB, Joys AC, Gregory RD, Baillie SR, Noble DG (2010) Hypotheses to explain patterns of population change among breeding bird species in England. Biological Conservation 143: 2006–2019.

Gil-Tena A, Brotons L, Saura S (2009) Mediterranean forest dynamics and forest bird distribution changes in the late 20th century. Global Change Biology 15: 474–485.

Fomin FV, Grandoni F, Pyatkin AV, Stepanov AA (2008) Combinatorial bounds via measure and conquer: Bounding minimal dominating sets and applications. ACM Trans Algorithms 5: 1–17.

Couturier J-F, Heggernes P, Hof P, Kratsch D (2012) Minimal Dominating Sets in Graph Classes: Combinatorial Bounds and Enumeration. In: Bieliková M, Friedrich G, Gottlob G, Katzenbeisser S, Turán G, editors. SOFSEM 2012: Theory and Practice of Computer Science: Springer Berlin Heidelberg. pp. 202–213.

Gregory RD, Noble D, Field RH, Marchant JH, Raven M, et al. (2003) Using birds as indicators of biodiversity. Ornis Hungarica 12–13: 11–24.

Legendre P (2008) lmodel2: Model II Regression. Available: http://www.cran.r-project.org

Legendre P, Legendre L (1998) Numerical Ecology. Amsterdam: Elsevier.

Wade ASI, Barov B, Burfield IJ, Gregory RD, Norris K, et al. (2013) Quantifying the detrimental impacts of land-use and management change on European forest bird populations. PLoS One 8: e64552. PubMed PMC

Butler SJ, Brooks D, Feber RE, Storkey J, Vickery JA, et al. (2009) A cross-taxonomic index for quantifying the health of farmland biodiversity. Journal of Applied Ecology 46: 1154–1162.

Butler SJ, Boccaccio L, Gregory RD, Vorisek P, Norris K (2010) Quantifying the impact of land-use change to European farmland bird populations. Agriculture Ecosystems & Environment 137: 348–357.

Kovaács A, Mammen UCC, Wernham CV (2008) European Monitoring for Raptors and Owls: State of the Art and Future Needs. AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment 37: 408–412. PubMed

Carignan V, Villard MA (2002) Selecting indicator species to monitor ecological integrity: a review. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 78: 45–61. PubMed

Norris K, Harper N (2004) Extinction processes in hot spots of avian biodiversity and the targeting of pre–emptive conservation action. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B: Biological Sciences 271: 123–130. PubMed PMC

Bladt J, Larsen FW, Rahbek C (2008) Does taxonomic diversity in indicator groups influence their effectiveness in identifying priority areas for species conservation? Animal Conservation 11: 546–554.

Lewandowski AS, Noss RF, Parsons DR (2010) The effectiveness of surrogate taxa for the representation of biodiversity. Conservation Biology 24: 1367–1377. PubMed

Niemeijer D, de Groot RS (2008) A conceptual framework for selecting environmental indicator sets. Ecological Indicators 8: 14–25.