The antiquity of the wolf/dog domestication has been recently pushed back in time from the Late Upper Paleolithic (~14,000 years ago) to the Early Upper Paleolithic (EUP; ~36,000 years ago). Some authors questioned this early dog domestication claiming that the putative (EUP) Paleolithic dogs fall within the morphological range of recent wolves. In this study, we reanalyzed a data set of large canid skulls using unbalanced- and balanced-randomized discriminant analyses to assess whether the putative Paleolithic dogs are morphologically unique or whether they represent a subsample of the wolf morpho-population. We evaluated morphological differences between 96 specimens of the 4 a priori reference groups (8 putative Paleolithic dogs, 41 recent northern dogs, 7 Pleistocene wolves, and 40 recent northern wolves) using discriminant analysis based on 5 ln-transformed raw and allometrically size-adjusted cranial measurements. Putative Paleolithic dogs are classified with high accuracies (87.5 and 100.0%, cross-validated) and randomization experiment suggests that these classification rates cannot be exclusively explained by the small and uneven sample sizes of reference groups. It indicates that putative Upper Paleolithic dogs may represent a discrete canid group with morphological signs of domestication (a relatively shorter skull and wider palate and braincase) that distinguish them from sympatric Pleistocene wolves. The present results add evidence to the view that these specimens could represent incipient Paleolithic dogs that were involved in daily activities of European Upper Paleolithic forager groups.

Department of Anthropology University of West Bohemia Pilsen Czech Republic

Operational Direction Earth and History of Life Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences Brussels Belgium

The Moravian Museum Brno Czech Republic

Zoological Institute Russian Academy of Sciences Saint Petersburg Russia

Zobrazit více v PubMed

Adams, D. C., Rohlf, F. J., & Slice, D. E. (2004). Geometric morphometrics: Ten years of progress following the “revolution”. The Italian Journal of Zoology, 71, 5-16.

Adams, D. C., Rohlf, F. J., & Slice, D. E. (2013). A field comes of age: Geometric morphometrics in the 21st century. Hystrix, 24, 7-14.

Aiello, L. C. (1992). Allometry and the analysis of size and shape in human evolution. Journal of Human Evolution, 22, 127-147.

Benecke, N. (1987). Studies on early dog remains from Northern Europe. Journal of Archaeological Science, 14, 31-49.

Benecke, N. (1994). Archäozoologische Studien zur Entwicklung der Haustierhaltung. Berlin: Akademie Verlag.

Bocherens, H., Drucker, D. G., Germonpré, M., Lázničková-Galetová, M., Naito, Y. I., Wissing, C., … Oliva, M. (2015). Reconstruction of the Gravettian food-web at Předmostí I using multi-isotopic tracking (13 C, 15 N, 34 S) of bone collagen. Quaternary International, 359, 211-228.

Bookstein, F. L. (2019). Pathologies of between-groups principal components analysis in geometric morphometrics. Evolutionary Biology, 46, 271-302.

Botigué, L. R., Song, S., Scheu, A., Gopalan, S., Pendleton, A. L., Oetjens, M., … Veeramah, K. R. (2017). Ancient European dog genomes reveal continuity since the Early Neolithic. Nature Communications, 8, 16082.

Boudadi-Maligne, M., & Escarguel, G. (2014). A biometric re-evaluation of recent claims for Early Upper Palaeolithic wolf domestication in Eurasia. Journal of Archaeological Science, 45, 80-89.

Breno, M., Leirs, H., & Van Dongen, S. (2011). Traditional and geometric morphometrics for studying skull morphology during growth in Mastomys natalensis (Rodentia: Muridae). Journal of Mammalogy, 92, 1395-1406.

Brewster, C., Meiklejohn, C., von Cramon-Taubadel, N., & Pinhasi, R. (2014). Craniometric analysis of European Upper Palaeolithic and Mesolithic samples supports discontinuity at the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature Communications, 5, 4094.

Brown, S. K., Darwent, C. M., & Sacks, B. N. (2013). Ancient DNA evidence for genetic continuity in arctic dogs. Journal of Archaeological Science, 40, 1279-1288.

Cardini, A., & Elton, S. (2007). Sample size and sampling error in geometric morphometric studies of size and shape. Zoomorphology, 126, 121-134.

Cardini, A., & Elton, S. (2011). GeMBiD, a geometric morphometric approach to the study of biological diversity: An example study of the red colobus (Procolobus [Piliocolobus]) species complex. International Journal of Primatology, 32, 377-389.

Cardini, A., O'Higgins, P., & Rohlf, F. J. (2019). Seeing distinct groups where there are none: Spurious patterns from between-group PCA. Evolutionary Biology, 46, 303-316.

Cardini, A., Seetah, K., & Barker, G. (2015). How many specimens do I need? Sampling error in geometric morphometrics: Testing the sensitivity of means and variances in simple randomized selection experiments. Zoomorphology, 134, 149-163.

Clutton-Brock, J. (1995). Origins of the dog: Domestication and early history. In J. Serpell (Ed.), The domestic dog: Its evolution, behaviour and interactions with people (pp. 7-20). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Colledge, S., Conolly, J., Dobney, K., Manning, K., & Shennan, S. (2013). Origins and spread of domestic animals in Southwest Asia and Europe. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press.

Crockford, S. J., & Kuzmin, Y. V. (2012). Comments on Germonpré et al., Journal of Archaeological Science 36, 2009 “Fossil dogs and wolves from Palaeolithic sites in Belgium, the Ukraine and Russia: Osteometry, ancient DNA and stable isotopes”, and Germonpré, Lázničková-Galetová, and Sablin, Journal of Archaeological Science 39, 2012 “Palaeolithic dog skulls at the Gravettian Předmostí site, The Czech Republic”. Journal of Archaeological Science, 39, 2797-2801.

Crowley, P. H. (1992). Resampling methods for computation-intensive data analysis in ecology and evolution. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 23, 405-447.

Curto, J. D., & Pinto, J. C. (2011). The corrected VIF (CVIF). Journal of Applied Statistics, 38, 1499-1507.

DiGangi, E., & Hefner, J. T. (2013). Ancestry estimation. In E. DiGangi & M. K. Moore (Eds.), Research methods in human skeletal biology (1st ed., pp. 117-150). Boston, MA: Elsevier.

Drake, A. G., Coquerelle, M., & Colombeau, G. (2015). 3D morphometric analysis of fossil canid skulls contradicts the suggested domestication of dogs during the late Paleolithic. Scientific Reports, 5, 1-8.

Dryden, I. L., & Mardia, K. V. (1998). Statistical shape analysis. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.

Evin, A., Cucchi, T., Cardini, A., Strand Vidarsdottir, U., Larson, G., & Dobney, K. (2013). The long and winding road: Identifying pig domestication through molar size and shape. Journal of Archaeological Science, 40, 735-743.

Evin, A., Girdland Flink, L., Krause-Kyora, B., Makarewicz, C., Hartz, S., Schreiber, S., … Dobney, K. (2014). Exploring the complexity of domestication: A response to Rowley-Conwy and Zeder. World Archaeology, 46, 825-834.

Fan, Z., Silva, P., Gronau, I., Wang, S., Armero, A. S., Schweizer, R. M., … Wayne, R. K. (2016). Worldwide patterns of genomic variation and admixture in gray wolves. Genome Research, 26, 163-173.

Franklin, D., Cardini, A., Flavel, A., & Kuliukas, A. (2012). The application of traditional and geometric morphometric analyses for forensic quantification of sexual dimorphism: Preliminary investigations in a Western Australian population. International Journal of Legal Medicine, 126, 549-558.

Frantz, L. A. F., Mullin, V. E., Pionnier-Capitan, M., Lebrasseur, O., Ollivier, M., Perri, A., … Larson, G. (2016). Genomic and archaeological evidence suggest a dual origin of domestic dogs. Science, 252, 1228-1231.

Galeta, P., Bruzek, J., & Lázničková-Galetová, M. (2014). Is sex estimation from handprints in prehistoric cave art reliable? A view from biological and forensic anthropology. Journal of Archaeological Science, 45, 141-149.

Germonpré, M., Bocherens, H., Lázničková-Galetová, M., & Sablin, M. V. (2020). Could incipient dogs have enhanced differential access to resources among Upper Palaeolithic hunter-gatherers in Europe? In L. Moreau (Ed.), Social inequality before farming. Multidisciplinary approaches to the study of social organisation in prehistoric and extant hunter-gatherer societies. Cambridge: McDonald Institute Conversations.

Germonpré, M., Fedorov, S., Danilov, P., Galeta, P., Jimenez, E.-L., Sablin, M., & Losey, R. J. (2017). Palaeolithic and prehistoric dogs and Pleistocene wolves from Yakutia: Identification of isolated skulls. Journal of Archaeological Science, 78, 1-19.

Germonpré, M., Lázničková-Galetová, M., Losey, R. J., Räikkönen, J., & Sablin, M. V. (2015). Large canids at the Gravettian Předmostí site, The Czech Republic: The mandible. Quaternary International, 359-360, 261-279.

Germonpré, M., Laznickova-Galetova, M., & Sablin, M. V. (2012). Palaeolithic dog skulls at the Gravettian Predmosti site, The Czech Republic. Journal of Archaeological Science, 39, 184-202.

Germonpré, M., Lázničková-Galetová, M., Sablin, M. V., & Bocherens, H. (2018). Self-domestication or human control? The upper Palaeolithic domestication of the wolf. In C. Stépanoff & J.-D. Vigne (Eds.), Hybrid communities: Biosocial approaches to domestication and other trans-species relationships (pp. 39-64). New York: Routledge.

Germonpré, M., Sablin, M. V., Després, V., Hofreiter, M., Lázničková-Galetová, M., Stevens, R. E., & Stiller, M. (2013). Palaeolithic dogs and the early domestication of the wolf: A reply to the comments of Crockford and Kuzmin (2012). Journal of Archaeological Science, 40, 786-792.

Germonpré, M., Sablin, M. V., Lázničková-Galetová, M., Després, V., Stevens, R. E., Stiller, M., & Hofreiter, M. (2015). Palaeolithic dogs and Pleistocene wolves revisited: A reply to Morey (2014). Journal of Archaeological Science, 54, 210-216.

Germonpré, M., Sablin, M. V., Stevens, R. E., Hedges, R. E., Hofreiter, M., Stiller, M., & Després, V. R. (2009). Fossil dogs and wolves from Palaeolithic sites in Belgium, the Ukraine and Russia: Osteometry, ancient DNA and stable isotopes. Journal of Archaeological Science, 36, 473-490.

Grimm, D. (2015). Dawn of the dog. Science, 348, 274-279.

Holt, B. M. (2003). Mobility in Upper Paleolithic and Mesolithic Europe: Evidence from lower limb. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 122, 200-215.

Hongo, H., Pearson, J., Öksüz, B., & Ilgezdi, G. (2009). The process of ungulate domestication at Cayönü, Southeastern Turkey: A multidisciplinary approach focusing on Bos sp. and Cervus elaphus. Anthropozoologica, 44, 63-78.

Janssens, L., Perri, A., Crombé, P., Van Dongen, S., & Lawler, D. (2019). An evaluation of classical morphologic and morphometric parameters reported to distinguish wolves and dogs. J Archaeol Sci Rep, 23, 501-533.

Jungers, W. L., Falsetti, A. B., & Wall, C. E. (1995). Shape, relative size, and size-adjustments in morphometrics. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 38, 137-161.

Klingenberg, C. P. (1996). Multivariate allometry. In L. F. Marcus, M. Corti, A. Loy, G. J. P. Naylor, & D. E. Slice (Eds.), Advances in morphometrics (pp. 23-49). New York: Plenum.

Klingenberg, C. P. (2013). Cranial integration and modularity: Insights into evolution and development from morphometric data. Hystrix, 24, 43-58.

Kocovsky, P. M., Adams, J. V., & Bronte, C. R. (2009). The effect of sample size on the stability of principal components analysis of truss-based fish morphometrics. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, 138, 487-496.

Konietschke, F., Bathke, A. C., Harrar, S. W., & Pauly, M. (2015). Parametric and nonparametric bootstrap methods for general MANOVA. Journal of Multivariate Analysis, 140, 291-301.

Kovarovic, K., Aiello, L. C., Cardini, A., & Lockwood, C. A. (2011). Discriminant function analyses in archaeology: Are classification rates too good to be true? Journal of Archaeological Science, 38, 3006-3018.

Krause-Kyora, B., Makarewicz, C., Evin, A., Flink, L. G., Dobney, K., Larson, G., … von Wurmb-Schwark, N. (2013). Use of domesticated pigs by Mesolithic hunter-gatherers in northwestern Europe. Nature Communications, 4, 2348.

Larson, G., Karlsson, E. K., Perri, A., Webster, M. T., Ho, S. Y., Peters, J., … Fredholm, M. (2012). Rethinking dog domestication by integrating genetics, archeology, and biogeography. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109, 8878-8883.

Lawrence, B. (1967). Early domestic dogs. Zeitschrift für Säugetierkunde, 32, 44-59.

Macholán, M., Mikula, O., & Vohralík, V. (2008). Geographic phenetic variation of two eastern-Mediterranean non-commensal mouse species, Mus macedonicus and M. cypriacus (Rodentia: Muridae) based on traditional and geometric approaches to morphometrics. Zoologischer Anzeiger, 247, 67-80.

Marcus, L. F. (1990). Traditional morphometrics. In F. J. Rohlf & F. L. Bookstein (Eds.), Proceedings of the Michigan morphometrics workshop (pp. 77-122). Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Museum of Zoology.

Mardia, K. V. (1970). Measures of multivariate skewness and kurtosis with applications. Biometrika, 57, 519-530.

Marom, N., & Bar-Oz, G. (2013). The prey pathway: A regional history of cattle (Bos taurus) and pig (Sus scrofa) domestication in the northern Jordan Valley, Israel. PLoS One, 8, e55958.

Mitteroecker, P., & Bookstein, F. (2011). Linear discrimination, ordination, and the visualization of selection gradients in modern morphometrics. Evolutionary Biology, 38, 100-114.

Montgomery, D. C., Peck, E. A., & Vining, G. G. (2012). Introduction to linear regression analysis. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

Morell, V. (2015). How wolf became dog. Scientific American, 313, 48-55.

Morey, D. F. (1992). Size, shape and development in the evolution of the domestic dog. Journal of Archaeological Science, 19, 181-204.

Morey, D. F. (2014). In search of Paleolithic dogs: A quest with mixed results. Journal of Archaeological Science, 52, 300-307.

Morey, D. F., & Jeger, R. (2015). Paleolithic dogs: Why sustained domestication then? J Archaeol Sci Rep, 3, 420-428.

Morris, J. S., & Brandt, E. K. (2014). Specialization for aggression in sexually dimorphic skeletal morphology in grey wolves (Canis lupus). Journal of Anatomy, 225, 1-11.

Mosimann, J. E., & James, F. C. (1979). New statistical methods for allometry with applications to Florida red-winged blackbirds. Evolution, 33, 444-459.

Mundry, R., & Sommer, C. (2007). Discriminant function analysis with nonindependent data: Consequences and an alternative. Animal Behaviour, 74, 965-976.

Mutanen, M., & Pretorius, E. (2007). Subjective visual evaluation vs. traditional and geometric morphometrics in species delimitation: A comparison of moth genitalia. Systematic Entomology, 32, 371-386.

Napierala, H., & Uerpmann, H. P. (2012). A “new” Palaeolithic dog from Central Europe. International Journal of Osteoarchaeology, 22, 127-137.

Nobis, G. (1986). Die Wildsäugetiere in der Umwelt des Menschen von Oberkassel bei Bonn und das Domestikationsproblem von Wölfen im Jungpaläolithikum. Bonner Jahresbücher, 186, 367-376.

Okumura, M., & Araujo, A. G. M. (2014). Long-term cultural stability in hunter-gatherers: A case study using traditional and geometric morphometric analysis of lithic stemmed bifacial points from Southern Brazil. Journal of Archaeological Science, 45, 59-71.

Olsen, S. J. (1985). Origins of the domestic dog: The fossil record. Tucson, AZ: University of Arizona Press.

Ousley, S. D., & Jantz, R. L. (2012). Fordisc 3 and statistical methods for estimating sex and ancestry. In D. Dirkmaat (Ed.), A companion to forensic anthropology (pp. 311-329). Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.

Parr, W. C. H., Wilson, L. A. B., Wroe, S., Colman, N. J., Crowther, M. S., & Letnic, M. (2016). Cranial shape and the modularity of hybridization in dingoes and dogs; hybridization does not spell the end for native morphology. Evolutionary Biology, 43, 171-187.

Pendleton, A. L., Shen, F., Taravella, A. M., Emery, S., Veeramah, K. R., Boyko, A. R., & Kidd, J. M. (2018). Comparison of village dog and wolf genomes highlights the role of the neural crest in dog domestication. BMC Biology, 16, 1-21.

Perri, A. (2016). A wolf in dog's clothing: Initial dog domestication and Pleistocene wolf variation. Journal of Archaeological Science, 68, 1-4.

Pidoplichko, I. H. (1998). Upper Palaeolithic dwellings of mammoth bones in the Ukraine: Kiev-Kirillovskii, Gontsy, Dobranichevka, Mezin and Mezhirich. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports Limited Series 712.

Pilot, M., Moura, A. E., Okhlopkov, I. M., Mamaev, N. V., Alagaili, A. N., Mohammed, O. B., … Kopaliani, N. (2019). Global phylogeographic and admixture patterns in grey wolves and genetic legacy of an ancient Siberian lineage. Scientific Reports, 9, 1-13.

Prassack, K. A., DuBois, J., Lázničková-Galetová, M., Germonpré, M., & Ungar, P. S. (2020). Dental microwear as a behavioral proxy for distinguishing between canids at the Upper Paleolithic (Gravettian) site of Předmostí, Czech Republic. Journal of Archaeological Science, 115, 1-10.

R Core Team. (2019). R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.

Renaud, S., Dufour, A.-B., Hardouin, E. A., Ledevin, R., & Auffray, J.-C. (2015). Once upon multivariate analyses: When they tell several stories about biological evolution. PLoS One, 10, e0132801.

Rowley-Conwy, P., & Zeder, M. (2014). Mesolithic domestic pigs at Rosenhof-or wild boar? A critical re-appraisal of ancient DNA and geometric morphometrics. World Archaeology, 46, 813-824.

Ruff, C. B., Holt, B., Niskanen, M., Sladek, V., Berner, M., Garofalo, E., … Schuplerova, E. (2015). Gradual decline in mobility with the adoption of food production in Europe. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 112, 7147-7152.

Sablin, M., & Khlopachev, G. (2002). The earliest ice age dogs: Evidence from Eliseevichi 11. Current Anthropology, 43, 795-799.

Sánchez-Villagra, M. R., Geiger, M., & Schneider, R. A. (2016). The taming of the neural crest: A developmental perspective on the origins of morphological covariation in domesticated mammals. Royal Society Open Science, 3, 160107.

Santos, E., Gómez-Olivencia, A., Arlegi, M., & Arsuaga, J. L. (2017). Cranial morphological differences within U. deningeri-U. spelaeus lineage: A double traditional and geometric morphometrics approach. Quaternary International, 433(Part A), 347-362.

Schmitt, E., & Wallace, S. (2014). Shape change and variation in the cranial morphology of wild canids (Canis lupus, Canis latrans, Canis rufus) compared to domestic dogs (Canis familiaris) using geometric morphometrics. International Journal of Osteoarchaeology, 24, 42-50.

Schumacker, R. E. (2015). Using R with multivariate statistics. Tuscaloosa, AL: SAGE Publications.

Seetah, T. K., Cardini, A., & Miracle, P. T. (2012). Can morphospace shed light on cave bear spatial-temporal variation? Population dynamics of Ursus spelaeus from Romualdova pećina and Vindija (Croatia). Journal of Archaeological Science, 39, 500-510.

Shaw, C. N., & Stock, J. T. (2013). Extreme mobility in the Late Pleistocene? Comparing limb biomechanics among fossil Homo, varsity athletes and Holocene foragers. Journal of Human Evolution, 64, 242-249.

Sládek, V., Ruff, C. B., Berner, M., Holt, B., Niskanen, M., Schuplerová, E., & Hora, M. (2016). The impact of subsistence changes on humeral bilateral asymmetry in terminal Pleistocene and Holocene Europe. Journal of Human Evolution, 92, 37-49.

Smeds, L., Kojola, I., & Ellegren, H. (2019). The evolutionary history of grey wolf Y chromosomes. Molecular Ecology, 28, 2173-2191.

Smith, R. J. (2009). Use and misuse of the reduced major axis for line-fitting. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 140, 476-486.

Stevens, J. P. (2012). Applied multivariate statistics for the social sciences. New York: Routledge.

Street, M., Napierala, H., & Janssens, L. (2015). The late Paleolithic dog from Bonn-Oberkassel in context. In L. Giemsch & R. W. Schmitz (Eds.), The Late Glacial burial from Oberkassel revisited. Rheinische Ausgrabungen, Band (Vol. 72, pp. 253-273). Darmstadt: Philipp von Zabern Verlag.

Tabachnick, B. G., & Fidell, L. S. (2013). Using multivariate statistics (6th ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson Education.

Tchernov, E., & Horwitz, L. K. (1991). Body size diminution under domestication: Unconscious selection in primeval domesticates. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology, 10, 54-75.

Thalmann, O., Shapiro, B., Cui, P., Schuenemann, V. J., Sawyer, S. K., Greenfield, D. L., … Wayne, R. K. (2013). Complete mitochondrial genomes of ancient canids suggest a European origin of domestic dogs. Science, 342, 871-874.

Thorpe, R. S., & Leamy, L. (1983). Morphometric studies in inbred and hybrid house mice (Mus sp.): Multivariate analysis of size and shape. Journal of Zoology, 199, 421-432.

van Asch, B., A-b, Z., Oskarsson, M. C. R., Klütsch, C. F. C., Amorim, A., & Savolainen, P. (2013). Pre-Columbian origins of Native American dog breeds, with only limited replacement by European dogs, confirmed by mtDNA analysis. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences, 280, 1-9.

Van Valkenburgh, B., & Sacco, T. (2002). Sexual dimorphism, social behavior, and intrasexual competition in large Pleistocene carnivorans. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 22, 164-169.

Viscosi, V., Lepais, O., Gerber, S., & Fortini, P. (2009). Leaf morphological analyses in four European oak species (Quercus) and their hybrids: A comparison of traditional and geometric morphometric methods. Plant Biosystems, 143, 564-574.

von den Driesch, A. (1976). A guide to the measurement of animal bones from archaeological sites. Cambridge, MA: Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology.

Warton, D. I., Wright, I. J., Falster, D. S., & Westoby, M. (2006). Bivariate line-fitting methods for allometry. Biological Reviews, 81, 259-291.

Wayne, R. K. (1986). Cranial morphology of domestic and wild canids: The influence of development on morphological change. Evolution, 40, 243-261.

Westfall, P. H. (1997). Multiple testing of general contrasts using logical constraints and correlations. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 92, 299-306.

Wilkins, A. S., Wrangham, R. W., & Fitch, W. T. (2014). The “domestication syndrome” in mammals: A unified explanation based on neural crest cell behavior and genetics. Genetics, 197, 795-808.

Wißing, C., Rougier, H., Baumann, C., Comeyne, A., Crevecoeur, I., Drucker, D. G., … Bocherens, H. (2019). Stable isotopes reveal patterns of diet and mobility in the last Neandertals and first modern humans in Europe. Scientific Reports, 9, 4433.