OBJECTIVES: This systematic review seeks to present and compare data from studies evaluating the success of medium-term inpatient treatment of alcohol-dependent patients in the Czech Republic. Another aim was to identify the problems that make such comparisons difficult. No previous review comparing the efficiency of various therapeutic programmes has been published in the Czech Republic. METHODS: Bibliographia medica Čechoslovaca and PubMed were used to find studies published in professional medical journals since 1970 evaluating the abstinence of patients who voluntarily completed medium-term inpatient treatment of alcohol dependence. RESULTS: Medium-term inpatient treatment of alcohol addiction leads to one year of abstinence in 34% to 76% of patients. Such variance in value is largely caused by selection bias, differences in the definition of abstinence, and differences in data collection methods. CONCLUSION: The comparison of studies presented many challenges. Further steps should be taken to help compare treatment programmes in the future, as the programmes provide different therapeutic interventions of different intensities and lengths to different patients. Adequate demographic and other pretreatment characteristics data collection, detailed descriptions of therapeutic interventions, and identification of effective components of the therapeutic programme could support further research in this area, optimize existing programmes, and increase the overall treatment efficiency.

Department of Addictology 1st Faculty of Medicine Charles University and General University Hospital Prague Prague Czech Republic

Department of Psychiatry Faculty of Medicine in Pilsen Charles University and University Hospital in Pilsen Pilsen Czech Republic

Department of Psychiatry Institute for Postgraduate Medical Education Prague Prague Czech Republic

Zobrazit více v PubMed

Kagstrom A, Alexova A, Tuskova E, Csajbók Z, Schomerus G, Formanek T, et al. The treatment gap for mental disorders and associated factors in the Czech Republic. Eur Psychiatry. 2019;59:37-43. PubMed DOI

Csémy L, Dvořáková Z, Fialová A, Kodl M, Malý M, Skývová M. [National survey of tobacco and alcohol use in the Czech Republic 2020]. Prague: NIPH; 2021. Czech.

Mlčoch T, Chadimová K, Doležal T, Dolejší D, Hájíčková B, Mazalová M, et al. [Social costs of alcohol consumption in the Czech Republic]. [Internet]. Prague: iHETA; 2019 [cited 2022 Sep 4]. Available from: http://www.iheta.org/ext/publication/files/Report_merged_grant_alkohol_2019-04-10%20-%20final.pdf. Czech.

Šejvl J, Gavurová B, Barták M, Mašlániová M, Miovský M. First alcohol treatment institutions in today>s Czech Republic and Slovak Republic. Cent Eur J Public Health. 2019;27(Supplement):S55-65. PubMed DOI

Kubička L, Skála J. [Collection of studies on the abuse of alcohol and other addictive substances]. Prague: Výzkumný ústav psychiatrický; 1982. Czech.

Štěpánek L, Čapáková L. [Catamnetic evaluation of inpatient anti-alcohol treatment after 1 year and after 3 years]. Moravskoslezský referátový výběr z psychiatrie. 1976;8(1):48-54. Czech.

Škopková H. [Treatment results from the years 1973-1975 of patients of the anti-alcohol department after one and two years of treatment]. Protialkoholický obzor. 1978;13(5):303-14. Czech.

Drtil J. [The Liberec system of treatment for alcohol addicts and its treatment results]. Protialkoholický obzor. 1984;19(3):155-60. Czech

Drtil J. [Three-year results of the Liberec treatment system for alcohol and other drug addicts]. Protialkoholický obzor. 1986;21(3):173-8. Czech.

Drtil J. [Five-year results of the Liberec treatment system for the treatment of alcohol and other drug addicts]. Protialkoholický obzor. 1987;22(5):301-6. Czech.

Mareček P, Maťová A. [Addiction in doctors, their therapy and possibilities of professional success]. Protialkoholický obzor. 1984;19(3):151-4. Czech.

Šťastný V, Kostroňová T. [Results of treatment in a group of motivated and unmotivated patients treated at the anti-alcoholic department of Psychiatric Hospital Brno]. Protialkoholický obzor. 1987;22(4):235-40. Czech.

Šťastný V, Kostroňová T, Pokora J, Zahradník P. [Results of treatment in a group of motivated and unmotivated patients treated at the anti-alcoholic department of Psychiatric Hospital Brno-Černovice for 7,5 years and 1 year]. Protialkoholický obzor. 1991;26(6):355-64. Czech.

Šťastný V, Zahradník P, Kostroňová T, Pokora J. [Effectiveness of anti-alcohol treatment at the anti-alcohol department of the Psychiatric Hospital in Brno-Černovice]. Protialkoholický obzor. 1995;30(3):123-5. Czech.

Skála J, Kubíček V, Šperlingová A. [Effectiveness of treatment in the specialized, differentiated treatment center Červený dvůr]. Protialkoholický obzor. 1991;26(3-4):209-16. Czech.

Csémy L, Pecinovská O, Heller J, Přikrylová L, Popov P. [A comprehensive program for the treatment of alcohol dependence among women in Apolinář: analysis of treatment results after 12 months and three years]. Protialkoholický obzor. 2012;47(4):195-205. Czech.

Tibenská A, Čížek J, Martinek C, Libiger J. [Catamnestic monitoring of the effectiveness of addiction treatment]. Ceska Slov Psychiatr. 2008;104(5):230-5. Czech.

Tibenská A, Martinek C, Libiger J. [Catamnestic follow-up of patients with addiction 5 years after the end of drug addiction treatment]. Ceska Slov Psychiatr. 2016;112(4):159-64. Czech.

Miller WR, Walters ST, Bennett ME. How effective is alcoholism treatment in the United States? J Stud Alcohol. 2001;62(2):211-20. PubMed DOI

Monahan SC, Finney JW. Explaining abstinence rates following treatment for alcohol abuse: a quantitative synthesis of patient, research design and treatment effects. Addiction. 1996;91(6):787-806. PubMed DOI

Miovský M, Vondrová A, Peters R, Kathungu B, Lososová A. National Addiction-specific Institutional Infrastructure - fundamental prerequisite for successful implementation of specialized academic degree study programmes: a case study in historical perspective. Cent Eur J Public Health. 2019;27 Suppl:S83-91. PubMed DOI

Rojíček M, Boušková M, Elischer D, Ernest J, Holý D, Hronza M, et al. Statistical yearbook of the Czech Republic 2021. Prague: Czech Statistical Office; 2021.

Nešpor K. [The organization is an effective help for the addicted]. Ceska Slov Psychiatr. 2002;98(8):452-6. Czech.