Introductions of insect predators and parasitoids for biological control are a key method for pest management. Yet in recent decades, biological control has become more strictly regulated and less frequent. Conversely, the rate of unintentional insect introductions through human activities is rising. While accidental introductions of insect natural enemies can potentially have serious ecological consequences, they are challenging to quantify as their movements go largely unobserved. We used historical border interception records collected by the US Department of Agriculture from 1913 to 2018 to describe the diversity of entomophagous insects transported unintentionally, their main introduction pathways, and trends in host specificity. There were 35,312 interceptions of insect predators and parasitoids during this period, representing 93 families from 11 orders, and 196 species from these families. Commodity associations varied, but imported plants and plant products were the main introduction pathway. Most interceptions originated with commodities imported from the Neotropical, Panamaian, and Western Palearctic regions. Among the intercepted species, 27% were found in material originating from more than one country. Two thirds of species were polyphagous host generalists. Furthermore, 25% of species had already been introduced intentionally as biological control agents internationally, and 4.6% have documented negative impacts on native biodiversity or human society. Most of the intercepted species that have not established in the United States are host generalists or have at least one known host species available. The unintentional transport of diverse natural enemy insects has the potential to cause substantial ecological impacts, both in terms of controlling pests through accidental biocontrol and disrupting native communities. Characterizing the insects being transported and their introduction pathways can inform biosecurity practices and management.

Department of Ecology and Evolution University of Lausanne Lausanne Switzerland

Faculty of Forestry and Wood Sciences Czech University of Life Sciences Prague Prague Czech Republic

USDA Agricultural Research Service Invasive Insect Biocontrol and Behavior Laboratory Beltsville Maryland USA

USDA Forest Service Northern Research Station Morgantown West Virginia USA

See more in PubMed

Arca, M. , Mougel F., Guillemaud T., Dupas S., Rome Q., Perrard A., Muller F., et al. 2015. “Reconstructing the Invasion and the Demographic History of the Yellow‐Legged Hornet, Vespa velutina, in Europe.” Biological Invasions 17(8): 2357–2371.

Aukema, J. E. , Leung B., Kovacs K., Chivers C., Britton K. O., Englin J., Frankel S. J., et al. 2011. “Economic Impacts of Non‐Native Forest Insects in the Continental United States.” PLoS One 6(9): e24587. PubMed PMC

Barron, M. C. 2007. “Retrospective Modelling Indicates Minimal Impact of Non‐Target Parasitism by Pteromalus puparum on Red Admiral Butterfly (Bassaris gonerilla) Abundance.” Biological Control 41(1): 53–63.

Barron, M. C. , Wratten S. D., and Barlow N. D.. 2004. “Phenology and Parasitism of the Red Admiral Butterfly Bassaris gonerilla (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae).” New Zealand Journal of Ecology 28(1): 105–111.

Beggs, J. 2001. “The Ecological Consequences of Social Wasps (Vespula spp.) Invading an Ecosystem that Has an Abundant Carbohydrate Resource.” Biological Conservation 99(1): 17–28.

Blackburn, T. M. , Pyšek P., Bacher S., Carlton J. T., Duncan R. P., Jarošík V., Wilson J. R. U., and Richardson D. M.. 2011. “A Proposed Unified Framework for Biological Invasions.” Trends in Ecology & Evolution 26(7): 333–339. PubMed

Blüthgen, N. , Menzel F., and Blüthgen N.. 2006. “Measuring Specialization in Species Interaction Networks.” BMC Ecology 6(9): 9. PubMed PMC

Bradshaw, C. J. A. , Leroy B., Bellard C., Roiz D., Albert C., Fournier A., Barbet‐Massin M., Salles J. M., Simard F., and Courchamp F.. 2016. “Massive Yet Grossly Underestimated Global Costs of Invasive Insects.” Nature Communications 7(1): 12986. PubMed PMC

Castrillo, L. A. , Ugine T. A., Filotas M. J., Sanderson J. P., Vandenberg J. D., and Wraight S. P.. 2008. “Molecular Characterization and Comparative Virulence of Beauveria bassiana Isolates (Ascomycota: Hypocreales) Associated with the Greenhouse Shore Fly, Scatella tenuicosta (Diptera: Ephydridae).” Biological Control 45(1): 154–162.

Chapple, D. G. , Simmonds S. M., and Wong B. B. M.. 2012. “Can Behavioral and Personality Traits Influence the Success of Unintentional Species Introductions?” Trends in Ecology & Evolution 27(1): 57–64. PubMed

Charles, J. G. 1998. “The Settlement of Fruit Crop Arthropod Pests and Their Natural Enemies in New Zealand: An Historical Guide to the Future.” Biocontrol News and Information 19(2): 47–58.

Chen, C. , Epanchin‐Niell R. S., and Haight R. G.. 2018. “Optimal Inspection of Imports to Prevent Invasive Pest Introduction.” Risk Analysis 38(3): 603–619. PubMed

Cock, M. J. W. , Murphy S. T., Kairo M. T. K., Thompson E., Murphy R. J., and Francis A. W.. 2016. “Trends in the Classical Biological Control of Insect Pests by Insects: An Update of the BIOCAT Database.” BioControl 61(4): 349–363.

Crowder, D. W. , and Snyder W. E.. 2010. “Eating Their Way to the Top? Mechanisms Underlying the Success of Invasive Insect Generalist Predators.” Biological Invasions 12(9): 2857–2876.

DeBach, P. , and Rosen D.. 1991. Biological Control by Natural Enemies, 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Diamond, J. C. , Carney V. A., Murphy G. D., and Allen W. R.. 2001. “First Canadian Record of Hexacola neoscatellae Beardsley (Hymenoptera: Figitidae: Eucoilinae), a Parasitoid of Shoreflies (Scatella stagnalis Fallen).” Great Lakes Entomologist 34(2): 51–53.

Dormann, C. F. , Gruber B., and Fründ J.. 2008. “The R Journal: Introducing the Bipartite Package: Analysing Ecological Networks.” R News 8(2): 8–11.

Dowell, R. V. , Gill R. J., Jeske D. R., and Hoddle M. S.. 2016. “Exotic Terrestrial Macro‐Invertebrate Invaders in California from 1700 to 2015: An Analysis of Records.” Proceedings of the California Academy of Sciences 63(4): 63–157.

Dray, S. , and Dufour A. B.. 2007. “The ade4 package: implementing the duality diagram for ecologists.” Journal of statistical software 22: 1–20.

Ewel, J. J. , O'Dowd D. J., Bergelson J., Daehler C. C., D'Antonio C. M., Gómez L. D., Gordon D. R., et al. 1999. “Deliberate Introductions of Species: Research Needs: Benefits Can Be Reaped, but Risks Are High.” BioScience 49(8): 619–630.

FAO . 2005. Guidelines for the Export, Shipment, Import and Release of Biological Control Agents and Other Beneficial Organisms (International Standard for Phytosanitary Measures No. 3). Rome: FAO.

Fenn‐Moltu, G. 2024a. “Pathways for Accidental Biocontrol: The Human‐Mediated Dispersal of Insect Predators and Parasitoids [Dataset].” Dryad. 10.5061/dryad.rjdfn2zjj. PubMed DOI PMC

Fenn‐Moltu, G. 2024b. “Pathways for Accidental Biocontrol: The Human‐Mediated Dispersal of Insect Predators and Parasitoids.” Zenodo. 10.5281/zenodo.8367788. PubMed DOI PMC

Fenn‐Moltu, G. , Ollier S., Caton B., Liebhold A. M., Nahrung H., Pureswaran D. S., Turner R. M., Yamanaka T., and Bertelsmeier C.. 2022. “Alien Insect Dispersal Mediated by the Global Movement of Commodities.” Ecological Applications 33(2): e2721. PubMed PMC

Forbes, A. A. , Bagley R. K., Beer M. A., Hippee A. C., and Widmayer H. A.. 2018. “Quantifying the Unquantifiable: Why Hymenoptera, Not Coleoptera, Is the Most Speciose Animal Order.” BMC Ecology 18(1): 21. PubMed PMC

Frank, J. H. , and J. L. Gillett‐Kaufman. 2006. “Glossary of Expressions in Biological Control: IPM‐143/IN673, 8/2006.” EDIS 2006: 15. 10.32473/edis-in673-2006 DOI

Franks, S. J. , Pratt P. D., and Tsutsui N. D.. 2011. “The Genetic Consequences of a Demographic Bottleneck in an Introduced Biological Control Insect.” Conservation Genetics 12(1): 201–211.

Garnas, J. R. , Auger‐Rozenberg M. A., Roques A., Bertelsmeier C., Wingfield M. J., Saccaggi D. L., Roy H. E., and Slippers B.. 2016. “Complex Patterns of Global Spread in Invasive Insects: Eco‐Evolutionary and Management Consequences.” Biological Invasions 18(4): 935–952.

Gaudeul, M. , Auger‐Rozenberg M. A., Roques A., Bertelsmeier C., Wingfield M. J., Saccaggi D. L., Roy H. E., and Slippers B.. 2011. “Nuclear and Chloroplast Microsatellites Show Multiple Introductions in the Worldwide Invasion History of Common Ragweed, Ambrosia artemisiifolia .” PLoS One 6(3): e17658. PubMed PMC

Gippet, J. M. , Liebhold A. M., Fenn‐Moltu G., and Bertelsmeier C.. 2019. “Human‐Mediated Dispersal in Insects.” Current Opinion in Insect Science 35: 96–102. PubMed

Haack, R. A. 2011. “Exotic Bark‐ and Wood‐Boring Coleoptera in the United States: Recent Establishments and Interceptions.” Canadian Journal of Forest Research 36: 269–288.

Hajek, A. E. , and Eilenberg J.. 2018. Natural Enemies: An Introduction to Biological Control. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Hajek, A. E. , Hurley B. P., Kenis M., Garnas J. R., Bush S. J., Wingfield M. J., van Lenteren J. C., and Cock M. J. W.. 2016. “Exotic Biological Control Agents: A Solution or Contribution to Arthropod Invasions?” Biological Invasions 18(4): 953–969.

He, J. , and Deem M. W.. 2010. “Structure and Response in the World Trade Network.” Physical Review Letters 105(19): 198701. PubMed

Heimpel, G. E. , and Mills N. J.. 2017. Biological Control. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Hill, M. P. , Clusella‐Trullas S., Terblanche J. S., and Richardson D. M.. 2016. “Drivers, Impacts, Mechanisms and Adaptation in Insect Invasions.” Biological Invasions 18(4): 883–891.

Holmes, T. P. , Aukema J. E., von Holle B., Liebhold A., and Sills E.. 2009. “Economic Impacts of Invasive Species in Forests.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1162(1): 18–38. PubMed

Holt, B. G. , Lessard J. P., Borregaard M. K., Fritz S. A., Araújo M. B., Dimitrov D., Fabre P. H., et al. 2013. “An Update of Wallace's Zoogeographic Regions of the World.” Science 339(6115): 74–78. PubMed

Hörren, T. , Sorg M., Hallmann C. A., Zizka V. M. A., Ssymank A., Noll N. W., Schäffler L., and Scherber C.. 2022. “A Universal Insect Trait Tool (ITT, v1.0) for Statistical Analysis and Evaluation of Biodiversity Research Data.” [Preprint] bioRxiv.

Howarth, F. G. 1983. “Classical Biocontrol: Panacea or Pandora's Box.” Proceedings, Hawaiian Entomological Society 24: 239–244.

Hulme, P. E. 2006. “Beyond Control: Wider Implications for the Management of Biological Invasions.” Journal of Applied Ecology 43(5): 835–847.

Hunt, E. J. , Kuhlmann U., Sheppard A., Qin T. K., Barratt B. I. P., Harrison L., Mason P. G., Parker D., Flanders R. V., and Goolsby J.. 2008. “Review of Invertebrate Biological Control Agent Regulation in Australia, New Zealand, Canada and the USA: Recommendations for a Harmonized European System.” Journal of Applied Entomology 132(2): 89–123.

Hurd, L. E. 2008. “Predation: The Role of Generalist Predators in Biodiversity and Biological Control.” In Encyclopedia of Entomology, edited by Capinera J. L., 3038–3042. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands.

IUCN . 2000. IUCN Guidelines for the Prevention of Biodiversity Loss Caused by Alien Invasive Species. Gland: IUCN.

Kasper, M. L. , Reeson A. F., Cooper S. J. B., Perry K. D., and Austin A. D.. 2004. “Assessment of Prey Overlap between a Native (Polistes humilis) and an Introduced (Vespula germanica) Social Wasp Using Morphology and Phylogenetic Analyses of 16S rDNA.” Molecular Ecology 13(7): 2037–2048. PubMed

Kenis, M. , Auger‐Rozenberg M. A., Roques A., Timms L., Péré C., Cock M. J. W., Settele J., Augustin S., and Lopez‐Vaamonde C.. 2009. “Ecological Effects of Invasive Alien Insects.” Biological Invasions 11(1): 21–45.

Kolbe, J. J. , Larson A., Losos J. B., and de Queiroz K.. 2008. “Admixture Determines Genetic Diversity and Population Differentiation in the Biological Invasion of a Lizard Species.” Biology Letters 4(4): 434–437. PubMed PMC

Kolde, R. 2019. “pheatmap: Pretty Heatmaps.” https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=pheatmap.

Leung, B. , Lodge D. M., Finnoff D., Shogren J. F., Lewis M. A., and Lamberti G.. 2002. “An Ounce of Prevention or a Pound of Cure: Bioeconomic Risk Analysis of Invasive Species.” Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences 269(1508): 2407–2413. PubMed PMC

Leung, B. , Springborn M. R., Turner J. A., and Brockerhoff E. G.. 2014. “Pathway‐Level Risk Analysis: The Net Present Value of an Invasive Species Policy in the US.” Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 12(5): 273–279.

Liebhold, A. M. , Brockerhoff E. G., Garrett L. J., Parke J. L., and Britton K. O.. 2012. “Live Plant Imports: The Major Pathway for Forest Insect and Pathogen Invasions of the US.” Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 10(3): 135–143.

Liebhold, A. M. , Turner R. M., Blake R. E., Bertelsmeier C., Brockerhoff E. G., Nahrung H. F., Pureswaran D. S., Roques A., Seebens H., and Yamanaka T.. 2021. “Invasion Disharmony in the Global Biogeography of Native and Non‐Native Beetle Species.” Diversity and Distributions 27(11): 2050–2062.

Liebhold, A. M. , Yamanaka T., Roques A., Augustin S., Chown S. L., Brockerhoff E. G., and Pyšek P.. 2016. “Global Compositional Variation among Native and Non‐Native Regional Insect Assemblages Emphasizes the Importance of Pathways.” Biological Invasions 18(4): 893–905.

Louda, S. M. , Pemberton R. W., Johnson M. T., and Follett P. A.. 2003. “‘Non‐Target Effects – The Achilles’ Heel of Biological Control? Retrospective Analyses to Reduce Risk Associated with Biocontrol Introductions.” Annual Review of Entomology 48(1): 365–396. PubMed

MacLachlan, M. J. , Liebhold A. M., Yamanaka T., and Springborn M. R.. 2021. “Hidden Patterns of Insect Establishment Risk Revealed from Two Centuries of Alien Species Discoveries.” Science Advances 7(44): eabj1012. PubMed PMC

Magarey, R. D. , Colunga‐Garcia M., and Fieselmann D. A.. 2009. “Plant Biosecurity in the United States: Roles, Responsibilities, and Information Needs.” BioScience 59(10): 875–884.

Mally, R. , Turner R. M., Blake R. E., Fenn‐Moltu G., Bertelsmeier C., Brockerhoff E. G., Hoare R. J. B., et al. 2022. “Moths and Butterflies on Alien Shores: Global Biogeography of Non‐Native Lepidoptera.” Journal of Biogeography 49(8): 1455–1468.

Mas, H. , Santoiemma G., Lencina J. L., Gallego D., Pérez‐Laorga E., Ruzzier E., and Rassati D.. 2023. “Investigating Beetle Communities in and around Entry Points Can Improve Surveillance at National and International Scale.” NeoBiota 85: 145–165.

McCullough, D. G. , Work T. T., Cavey J. F., Liebhold A. M., and Marshall D.. 2006. “Interceptions of Nonindigenous Plant Pests at US Ports of Entry and Border Crossings over a 17‐Year Period.” Biological Invasions 8(4): 611–630.

Meurisse, N. , Rassati D., Hurley B. P., Brockerhoff E. G., and Haack R. A.. 2019. “Common Pathways by Which Non‐Native Forest Insects Move Internationally and Domestically.” Journal of Pest Science 92(1): 13–27.

Müller‐Schärer, H. , and Schaffner U.. 2008. “Classical Biological Control: Exploiting Enemy Escape to Manage Plant Invasions.” Biological Invasions 10(6): 859–874.

Müller‐Schärer, H. , Sun Y., and Schaffner U.. 2023. “When a Plant Invader Meets Its Old Enemy Abroad: What Can Be Learnt from Accidental Introductions of Biological Control Agents.” Pest Management Science [Preprint] 80: 19–27. PubMed

Nahrung, H. F. , Liebhold A. M., Brockerhoff E. G., and Rassati D.. 2023. “Forest Insect Biosecurity: Processes, Patterns, Predictions, Pitfalls.” Annual Review of Entomology 68: 211–229. PubMed

Ogle, D. , Doll J. C., Wheeler A. P., and Dinno A.. 2023. “FSA: Simple Fisheries Stock Assessment Methods.” https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=FSA.

Pagad, S. , Bisset S., Genovesi P., Groom Q., Hirsch T., Jetz W., Ranipeta A., Schigel D., Sica Y. V., and McGeoch M. A.. 2022. “Country Compendium of the Global Register of Introduced and Invasive Species.” Scientific Data 9(1): 391. PubMed PMC

Paini, D. R. , Sheppard A. W., Cook D. C., de Barro P. J., Worner S. P., and Thomas M. B.. 2016. “Global Threat to Agriculture from Invasive Species.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 113(27): 7575–7579. PubMed PMC

Parry, D. 2009. “Beyond Pandora's Box: Quantitatively Evaluating Non‐Target Effects of Parasitoids in Classical Biological Control.” In Ecological Impacts of Non‐Native Invertebrates and Fungi on Terrestrial Ecosystems, edited by Langor D. W. and Sweeney J., 47–58. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands. PubMed PMC

Peters, R. S. 2011. “Two Ways of Finding a Host: A Specialist and a Generalist Parasitoid Species (Hymenoptera: Chalcidoidea: Pteromalidae).” European Journal of Entomology 108(4): 565–573.

Pimentel, D. 2005. “Environmental Consequences and Economic Costs of Alien Species.” In Invasive Plants: Ecological and Agricultural Aspects, edited by Inderjit, 269–276. Switzerland: Birkhauser Verlag.

Poelen, J. H. , Simons J. D., and Mungall C. J.. 2014. “Global Biotic Interactions: An Open Infrastructure to Share and Analyze Species‐Interaction Datasets.” Ecological Informatics 24: 148–159.

Polis, G. A. , and Strong D. R.. 1996. “Food Web Complexity and Community Dynamics.” The American Naturalist 147(5): 813–846.

R Core Team . 2023. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing. https://www.R-project.org/.

Roy, H. E. , Roy D. B., and Roques A.. 2011. “Inventory of Terrestrial Alien Arthropod Predators and Parasites Established in Europe.” BioControl 56(4): 477–504.

Saccaggi, D. L. , Karsten M., Robertson M. P., Kumschick S., Somers M. J., Wilson J. R. U., and Terblanche J. S.. 2016. “Methods and Approaches for the Management of Arthropod Border Incursions.” Biological Invasions 18(4): 1057–1075.

Schulz, A. N. , Lucardi R. D., and Marsico T. D.. 2021. “Strengthening the Ties that Bind: An Evaluation of Cross‐Disciplinary Communication between Invasion Ecologists and Biological Control Researchers in Entomology.” Annals of the Entomological Society of America 114(2): 163–174.

Seebens, H. , Blackburn T. M., Dyer E. E., Genovesi P., Hulme P. E., Jeschke J. M., Pagad S., et al. 2017. “No Saturation in the Accumulation of Alien Species Worldwide.” Nature Communications 8(1): 14435. PubMed PMC

Simberloff, D. , and Stiling P.. 1996. “How Risky Is Biological Control?” Ecology 77(7): 1965–1974.

Simpson, A. , Fuller P., Faccenda K., Evenhuis N., Matsunaga J., and Bowser M.. 2022. “United States Register of Introduced and Invasive Species (US‐RIIS) (ver. 2.0, November 2022).” U.S. Geological Survey Data Release.

Snyder, W. E. , and Evans E. W.. 2006. “Ecological Effects of Invasive Arthropod Generalist Predators.” Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 37(1): 95–122.

Stork, N. E. 2018. “How Many Species of Insects and Other Terrestrial Arthropods Are There on Earth?” Annual Review of Entomology 63(1): 31–45. PubMed

Szűcs, M. , Eigenbrode S. D., Schwarzländer M., and Schaffner U.. 2012. “Hybrid Vigor in the Biological Control Agent, Longitarsus jacobaeae .” Evolutionary Applications 5(5): 489–497. PubMed PMC

Thompson, B. M. , and Reddy G. V. P.. 2016. “Status of Sitodiplosis mosellana (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) and Its Parasitoid, Macroglenes penetrans (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae), in Montana.” Crop Protection 84: 125–131.

Tonnang, H. E. , Sokame B. M., Abdel‐Rahman E. M., and Dubois T.. 2022. “Measuring and Modelling Crop Yield Losses Due to Invasive Insect Pests under Climate Change.” Current Opinion in Insect Science 50: 100873. PubMed

Turner, R. M. , Brockerhoff E. G., Bertelsmeier C., Blake R. E., Caton B., James A., MacLeod A., et al. 2021. “Worldwide Border Interceptions Provide a Window into Human‐Mediated Global Insect Movement.” Ecological Applications 31(7): e02412. PubMed

Venette, R. C. , Gordon D. R., Juzwik J., Koch F. H., Liebhold A. M., Peterson R. K. D., Sing S. E., and Yemshanov D.. 2021. “Early Intervention Strategies for Invasive Species Management: Connections between Risk Assessment, Prevention Efforts, Eradication, and Other Rapid Responses.” In Invasive Species in Forests and Rangelands of the United States: A Comprehensive Science Synthesis for the United States Forest Sector, edited by Poland T. M., et al., 111–131. Cham: Springer International Publishing.

Weber, D. C. , Hajek A. E., Hoelmer K. A., Schaffner U., Mason P., Stouthamer P., Talamas E. J., et al. 2021. “Unintentional Biological Control.” In Biological Control – Global Impacts, Challenges and Future Directions of Pest Management, edited by P. G. Mason, 110–140. Collingwood: CSIRO Publishing.

Woodworth, L. M. , Montgomery M. E., Briscoe D. A., and Frankham R.. 2002. “Rapid Genetic Deterioration in Captive Populations: Causes and Conservation Implications.” Conservation Genetics 3(3): 277–288.

Work, T. T. , McCullough D. G., Cavey J. F., and Komsa R.. 2005. “Arrival Rate of Nonindigenous Insect Species into the United States through Foreign Trade.” Biological Invasions 7(2): 323–332.

World Customs Organization . 2021. “What is the Harmonized System (HS)?” http://www.wcoomd.org/en/topics/nomenclature/overview/what-is-the-harmonized-system.aspx.

Zemenick, A. T. , Kula R. R., Russo L., and Tooker J.. 2019. “A Network Approach Reveals Parasitoid Wasps to Be Generalized Nectar Foragers.” Arthropod‐Plant Interactions 13: 239–251.

Pathways for accidental biocontrol: The human-mediated dispersal of insect predators and parasitoids