Pharmaceutical solid forms, like salts and cocrystals, play a crucial role in drug formulation. Despite differing mainly by a single hydrogen atom, the regulatory requirements set by the US Food and Drug Administration for these forms vary significantly. We previously developed a DFT-based computational method to distinguish salts from cocrystals. This method, validated on 95 structures, performed well for systems where hydrogen bonds were longer than 2.613 (16) Å. Here, benefits of the rSCAN functional over the PBE functional are discussed. We expand the dataset to 404 cocrystal models. Analysis confirms that 301 of these forms are indeed cocrystals. Additionally, 87 salt-cocrystal continuum forms are identified and 16 cocrystals are classified as possible salts. These 16 problematic structures are further investigated and for seven of them, single crystals were grown and their structure determined using single-crystal X-ray diffraction. Among the phases exhibiting salt-like behaviour, five of them are identified as salts. In some cases, rSCAN alone gives unreliable results for strong hydrogen bonds, but these discrepancies are often corrected using better-renormalized or hybrid functionals (i.e. r2SCAN, PBE0 and PBE50). For future calculations, we recommend using the r2SCAN functional for salt-cocrystal differentiation, as it provides reliable results for O-H...N bonds longer than 2.554 (5) Å. The r2SCAN functional offers a good balance between accuracy and computational efficiency for systems with longer O-H...N bonds.

Department of Chemical Physics and Optics Faculty of Mathematics and Physics Charles University Ke Karlovu 3 Praha 2 121 16 Czechia

Department of Solid State Chemistry University of Chemistry and Technology Prague Technicka 5 Prague 166 28 Czechia

See more in PubMed

Aakeröy, C. B. & Salmon, D. J. (2005). CrystEngComm, 7, 439. PubMed PMC

Aitipamula, S., Banerjee, R., Bansal, A. K., Biradha, K., Cheney, M. L., Choudhury, A. R., Desiraju, G. R., Dikundwar, A. G., Dubey, R., Duggirala, N., Ghogale, P. P., Ghosh, S., Goswami, P. K., Goud, N. R., Jetti, R. R. K. R., Karpinski, P., Kaushik, P., Kumar, D., Kumar, V., Moulton, B., Mukherjee, A., Mukherjee, G., Myerson, A. S., Puri, V., Ramanan, A., Rajamannar, T., Reddy, C. M., Rodriguez-Hornedo, N., Rogers, R. D., Row, T. N. G., Sanphui, P., Shan, N., Shete, G., Singh, A., Sun, C. C., Swift, J. A., Thaimattam, R., Thakur, T. S., Kumar Thaper, R., Thomas, S. P., Tothadi, S., Vangala, V. R., Variankaval, N., Vishweshwar, P., Weyna, D. R. & Zaworotko, M. J. (2012). Cryst. Growth Des.12, 2147–2152.

Akutagawa, T., Uchimaru, T., Sakai, K., Hasegawa, T. & Nakamura, T. (2003). J. Phys. Chem. B, 107, 6248–6251.

Arora, K. K. & Pedireddi, V. R. (2003). J. Org. Chem.68, 9177–9185. PubMed

Bal, K. M. & Collas, A. (2024). CrystEngComm, 26, 6765–6773.

Bartók, A. P. & Yates, J. R. (2019). J. Chem. Phys.150, 161101.

Bowes, K. F., Ferguson, G., Lough, A. J. & Glidewell, C. (2003). Acta Cryst. B59, 100–117. PubMed

Bu, T.-J., Li, B. & Wu, L.-X. (2007). Acta Cryst. E63, 3466–3466.

Bursch, M., Mewes, J., Hansen, A. & Grimme, S. (2022). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.61, e202205735. PubMed PMC

Capelli, S. C., Bürgi, H.-B., Dittrich, B., Grabowsky, S. & Jayatilaka, D. (2014). IUCrJ, 1, 361–379. PubMed PMC

Chatterjee, S., Pedireddi, V. & Rao, C. (1998). Tetrahedron Lett.39, 2843–2846.

Clark, S. J., Segall, M. D., Pickard, C. J., Hasnip, P. J., Probert, M. I. J., Refson, K. & Payne, M. C. (2005). Z. Kristallogr. Cryst. Mater.220, 567–570.

Cruz-Cabeza, A. J. (2012). CrystEngComm, 14, 6362.

Czugler, M., Angyan, J. G., Naray-Szabo, G. & Weber, E. (1986). J. Am. Chem. Soc.108, 1275–1281.

FDA (2018). Regulatory Classification of Pharmaceutical Co-Crystals Guidance for Industry. US Department of Health and Human Services Food and Drug Administration Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER), February 2018 Pharmaceutical Quality/CMC Revision 1.

Fňukal, F. (2022). MSc Thesis. University of Chemistry and Technology in Prague, Czechia.

Furness, J. W., Kaplan, A. D., Ning, J., Perdew, J. P. & Sun, J. (2020). J. Phys. Chem. Lett.11, 8208–8215. PubMed

Gardiennet-Doucet, C., Henry, B. & Tekely, P. (2006). Prog. Nucl. Magn. Reson. Spectrosc.49, 129–149.

Groom, C. R., Bruno, I. J., Lightfoot, M. P. & Ward, S. C. (2016). Acta Cryst. B72, 171–179. PubMed PMC

Gupta, D., Bhatia, D., Dave, V., Sutariya, V. & Varghese Gupta, S. (2018). Molecules, 23, 1719. PubMed PMC

Hermann, J. & Tkatchenko, A. (2018). J. Chem. Theory Comput.14, 1361–1369. PubMed

Hušák, M., Šajbanová, S., Klimeš, J. & Jegorov, A. (2022). Acta Cryst. B78, 781–788.

Jayatilaka, D. & Dittrich, B. (2008). Acta Cryst. A64, 383–393. PubMed

Jeffrey, G. A. (1997). An Introduction to Hydrogen Bonding. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Kleemiss, F., Dolomanov, O. V., Bodensteiner, M., Peyerimhoff, N., Midgley, L., Bourhis, L. J., Genoni, A., Malaspina, L. A., Jayatilaka, D., Spencer, J. L., White, F., Grundkötter-Stock, B., Steinhauer, S., Lentz, D., Puschmann, H. & Grabowsky, S. (2021). Chem. Sci.12, 1675–1692. PubMed PMC

Li, W., Zhang, J., Tong, M. & Chen, X. (2001). Aust. J. Chem.54, 213.

Lombard, J., Haynes, D. A. & le Roex, T. (2020). Cryst. Growth Des.20, 7840–7849.

López, C., Claramunt, R. M., García, M. Á., Pinilla, E., Torres, M. R., Alkorta, I. & Elguero, J. (2007). Cryst. Growth Des.7, 1176–1184.

Lynch, D., Smith, G., Freney, D., Byriel, K. & Kennard, C. (1994). Aust. J. Chem.47, 1097.

Lynch, D. E., Hayer, R., Beddows, S., Howdle, J. & Thake, C. D. (2006). J. Heterocycl. Chem.43, 191–197.

Midgley, L., Bourhis, L. J., Dolomanov, O. V., Grabowsky, S., Kleemiss, F., Puschmann, H. & Peyerimhoff, N. (2021). Acta Cryst. A77, 519–533. PubMed

Neese, F. (2022). WIREs Comput. Mol. Sci.12, e1606.

Nygren, C. L., Wilson, C. C. & Turner, J. F. C. (2005). J. Phys. Chem. A, 109, 1911–1919. PubMed

Qin, J.-H., Hao, E.-J. & Wang, J.-G. (2008). Acta Cryst. E64, 2398–2398.

Qiu, L., Li, W., Fan, X., Ju, X., Cao, G. & Luo, S. (2008). Inorg. Chem. Commun.11, 727–729.

Reddy, L. S., Basavoju, S., Vangala, V. R. & Nangia, A. (2006). Cryst. Growth Des.6, 161–173.

Schmidtmann, M., Farrugia, L. J., Middlemiss, D. S., Gutmann, M. J., McIntyre, G. J. & Wilson, C. C. (2009). J. Phys. Chem. A, 113, 13985–13997. PubMed

Schmidtmann, M., Gutmann, M. J., Middlemiss, D. S. & Wilson, C. C. (2007). CrystEngComm, 9, 743.

Steiner, T., Majerz, I. & Wilson, C. C. (2001). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.40, 2651–2654. PubMed

Stevens, J. S., Byard, S. J. & Schroeder, S. L. (2010). J. Pharm. Sci.99, 4453–4457. PubMed

Štoček, J. R., Blahut, J., Chalupná, S., Čejka, J., Štěpánová, S., Kašička, V., Hušák, M. & Dracinsky, M. (2024). Chem. Eur. J.30, e202402946. PubMed

Štoček, J. R., Socha, O., Císařová, I., Slanina, T. & Dračínský, M. (2022). J. Am. Chem. Soc.144, 7111–7116. PubMed

Varughese, S. & Pedireddi, V. (2005). Tetrahedron Lett.46, 2411–2415.

Wang, W., Xi, P., Su, X., Lan, J., Mao, Z., You, J. & Xie, R. (2007). Cryst. Growth Des.7, 741–746.