Most cited article - PubMed ID 38347141
Metrics reloaded: recommendations for image analysis validation
The preservation of morphological features, such as protrusions and concavities, and of the topology of input shapes is important when establishing reference data for benchmarking segmentation algorithms or when constructing a mean or median shape. We present a contourwise topology-preserving fusion method, called shape-aware topology-preserving means (SATM), for merging complex simply connected shapes. The method is based on key point matching and piecewise contour averaging. Unlike existing pixelwise and contourwise fusion methods, SATM preserves topology and does not smooth morphological features. We also present a detailed comparison of SATM with state-of-the-art fusion techniques for the purpose of benchmarking and median shape construction. Our experiments show that SATM outperforms these techniques in terms of shape-related measures that reflect shape complexity, manifesting itself as a reliable method for both establishing a consensus of segmentation annotations and for computing mean shapes.
- Keywords
- Average shape, Mean shape, Median shape, Segmentation mask fusion, Shape analysis,
- Publication type
- Journal Article MeSH
Single-molecule localization microscopy (SMLM) allows imaging beyond the diffraction limit. Detection of molecules is a crucial initial step in SMLM. False positive detections, which are not quantitatively controlled in current methods, are a source of artifacts that affect the entire SMLM analysis pipeline. Furthermore, current methods lack standardization, which hinders reproducibility. Here, we present an optimized molecule detection method which combines probabilistic thresholding with theoretically optimal filtering. The probabilistic thresholding enables control over false positive detections while optimal filtering minimizes false negatives. A theoretically optimal Poisson matched filter is used as a performance benchmark to evaluate existing filtering methods. Overall, our approach allows the detection of molecules in a robust, single-parameter and user-unbiased manner. This will minimize artifacts and enable data reproducibility in SMLM.
- Publication type
- Journal Article MeSH