The alkaline comet assay, or single cell gel electrophoresis, is one of the most popular methods for assessing DNA damage in human population. One of the open issues concerning this assay is the identification of those factors that can explain the large inter-individual and inter-laboratory variation. International collaborative initiatives such as the hCOMET project - a COST Action launched in 2016 - represent a valuable tool to meet this challenge. The aims of hCOMET were to establish reference values for the level of DNA damage in humans, to investigate the effect of host factors, lifestyle and exposure to genotoxic agents, and to compare different sources of assay variability. A database of 19,320 subjects was generated, pooling data from 105 studies run by 44 laboratories in 26 countries between 1999 and 2019. A mixed random effect log-linear model, in parallel with a classic meta-analysis, was applied to take into account the extensive heterogeneity of data, due to descriptor, specimen and protocol variability. As a result of this analysis interquartile intervals of DNA strand breaks (which includes alkali-labile sites) were reported for tail intensity, tail length, and tail moment (comet assay descriptors). A small variation by age was reported in some datasets, suggesting higher DNA damage in oldest age-classes, while no effect could be shown for sex or smoking habit, although the lack of data on heavy smokers has still to be considered. Finally, highly significant differences in DNA damage were found for most exposures investigated in specific studies. In conclusion, these data, which confirm that DNA damage measured by the comet assay is an excellent biomarker of exposure in several conditions, may contribute to improving the quality of study design and to the standardization of results of the comet assay in human populations.

ANTICIPE Unit INSERM and University of Caen Normandie Centre François Baclesse Avenue du Général Harris 14076 Caen Cedex 05 France

Biomedical Sciences Department University of Bradford Richmond Road Bradford Bradford West Yorkshire BD7 1DP UK

Biostatistics Unit San Martino Policlinic Hospital Genoa Italy

Cancer Research Institute Biomedical Research Center of the Slovak Academy of Sciences Dubravska cesta 9 845 05 Bratislava Slovakia

Center for Radiation Safety Technology and Metrology National Nuclear Energy Agency of Indonesia Jl LebakBulus Raya No 49 Kotak Pos 7043 JKSKL JakartaSelatan 12440 Jakarta Indonesia

Center for RadiationProtection and Hygiene Calle 20 No 4113 e 41 y 47 Playa C P 11300 La Habana A P 6195 C P 10600 Habana Cuba

Center of Biological Research Faculty of Pharmacy University of Belgrade VojvodeStepe 450 Belgrade Serbia

Centre for Molecular and Translational Oncology University of Parma Parco Area delle Scienze 11A 43124 Parma Italy

Department NEUROFARBA University of Florence Viale G Pieraccini 6 50139 Florence Italy

Department of Biochemistry Instituto de Ciencias Básicas y Preclínicas Victoria de Giron 146 St and 31 Ave No 3102 Playa Habana Cuba

Department of Biology Faculty of Veterinary Medicine University of Belgrade Oslobodjenja Blvd 18 11000 Belgrade Serbia

Department of Biology University of Prishtina George Bush N N 10000 Prishtina Kosovo

Department of Chemistry Life Sciences and Environmental Sustainability University of Parma Parco Area delle Scienze 11A 43124 Parma Italy

Department of Environment and Health Istituto Superiore di Sanità Viale Regina Elena 299 Rome Italy

Department of Environmental Health Section of Molecular Toxicology Norwegian Institute of Public Health Lovisenberggt 6 0456 Oslo Norway

Department of Food Environmental and Nutritional Sciences University of Milan Via Celoria 2 20133 Milan Italy

Department of Genetics and Microbiology Faculty of Biosciences Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona 08193 Cerdanyola del Vallès Carlos 3 Institute of Health 28029 Madrid Spain

Department of Health Sciences University of Florence Division of Dermatology Palagi Hospital Viale Michelangelo 41 Florence Italy

Department of Nanotoxicolgy and Molecular Epidemiology Institute of Experimental Medicine of the Czech Academy of Sciences Videnska 1083 Prague Czech Republic

Department of Non ionizing Radiation National Public Health Center Anna Street 5 1221 Budapest Hungary

Department of Nutrition Food Science and Physiology Centre for Nutrition Research University of Navarra Irunlarrea 1 31008 Pamplona Navarra Spain

Department of Nutrition Institute of Basic Medical Sciences University of Oslo Sognsvannsveien 9 0372 Oslo Norway

Department of Nutritional Sciences University of Vienna Althanstrasse 14 1090 Vienna Austria

Department of Occupational and Environmental Medicine Epidemiology and Hygiene Italy

Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences University of Perugia Via del Giochetto 06122 Perugia Italy

Department of Pharmaceutical Toxicology Faculty of Pharmacy Hacettepe University Ankara Turkey

Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology University of Navarra C Irunlarrea 1 31008 Pamplona Spain; IdiSNA Navarra Institute for Health Research C Irunlarrea 3 31008 Pamplona Spain

Department of Public Health Section of Environmental Health University of Copenhagen Oster Farimagsgade 5A DK 1014 Copenhagen Denmark

Department of Radiation Hygiene and Radiobiology National Institute of Public Health National Institute of Hygiene 24 Chocimska Street 00 791 Warsaw Poland

Department of Toxicology and Military Pharmacy Faculty of Military Health Sciences University of Defence Trebesska 1575 500 01 Hradec Kralove Czech Republic

Environmental Health Department National Institute of Health Dr Ricardo Jorge Rua Alexandre Herculano 321 4000 055 Porto Portugal; EPIUnit Instituto de Saúde Pública Universidade do Porto Rua das Taipas no 135 4050 600 Porto Portugal

Experimental Medicine Molecular Biology of Cancer IEM AVCR Videnska 1083 Prague 4 Prague Czech Republic

Faculty of Medicine Clinic for Endocrinology Diabetes and Metabolic Disease University of Belgrade Dr Subotića 13 Belgrade Serbia

Flemish Institute of Technological Research Environmental Risk and Health unit VITO BIOMo Belgium

Genomic Medicine and EnvironmentalToxicology Instituto de Investigaciones Biomédicas Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México CU Mexico

Grupo DICOMOSA Centro de Investigaciones Científicas Avanzadas Departamento de Biología Facultad de Ciencias Universidade da Coruña Campus A Zapateira s n 15071 A Coruña Spain

Grupo DICOMOSA Centro de Investigaciones Científicas Avanzadas Departamento de Psicología Facultad de Ciencias de la Educación Universidade da Coruña Campus Elviña s n 15071 A Coruña Spain

H and TRC Health and Technology Research Center ESTeSL Escola Superior de Tecnologia da Saúde Instituto Politécnico de Lisboa 1990 096 Lisbon Portugal; NOVA National School of Public Health Public Health Research Centre Universidade NOVA de Lisboa Lisbon Portugal

Human Genetics Department National Institute of Health Doutor Ricardo Jorge Av Padre Cruz 1649 016 Lisbon Portugal; ToxOmics NMS NOVA University of Lisbon Lisbon Portugal

Institute for Medical Chemistry Biochemistry and Clinical Biochemistry Faculty of Medicine Comenius University Sasinkova 2 Bratislava Slovakia

Institute of Biology Medical Faculty Slovak Medical University Limbova 12 83303 Bratislava Slovakia

Institute of Pharmacology and Toxicology University of Wuerzburg VersbacherStrasse 9 97078 Wuerzburg Germany

Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Biophysics Russian Academy of Sciences 142290 Institutskaya 3 Pushchino Moscow Region Russia

IRCCS San Raffaele Pisana Unit of Clinical and Molecular Epidemiology Department of Human Sciences and Quality of Life Promotion San Raffaele University Via di Val Cannuta 247 00161 Rome Italy

Laboratory for the Study of the Pathogenesis of Malignant Tumors National Medical Research Center for Oncology 14 line 63 344037 Rostov on Don Russia

Laboratory of Genetic Toxicology Lutheran University of Brazil Av Farroupilha 8001 Prédio 22 Sala 22 92425 900 Canoas RS Brazil

Laboratory of Translational Biomedicine University of Southern Santa Catarina UNESC Criciúma SC Brazil

Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center Epidemiology and Biostatistics New York New York 10065 USA

Mutagenesis Unit Institute for Medical Research and Occupational Health Ksaverska cesta 2 10000 Zagreb Croatia

NILU Health Effects Laboratory Kjeller Norway

School of Nutrition and Translational Research in Metabolism Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology University of Maastricht Universiteitssingel 50 6200 MD Maastricht the Netherlands

Toxalim Université de Toulouse INRAE ENVT INP Purpan UPS Toulouse France

Toxicology Department Faculty of Pharmacy Gazi University Ankara Turkey

Toxicology Department Faculty of Pharmacy Istinye University Istanbul Turkey

Univ Paris Saclay CESP Villejuif France

Zobrazit více v PubMed

Collins AR, The comet assay for DNA damage and repair: principles, applications, and limitations, Mol. Biotechnol 26 (2004) 249–261 PubMed

Azqueta A, Collins AR, The essential comet assay: a comprehensive guide to measuring DNA damage and repair, Arch. Toxicol 87 (2013) 949–968. PubMed

Møller P, The comet assay: ready for 30 more years, Mutagenesis 33 (2018) 1–7. PubMed

Neri M, Milazzo D, Ugolini D, Milic M, Campolongo A, Pasqualetti P, Bonassi S, Worldwide interest in the comet assay: a bibliometric study, Mutagenesis 30 (2015) 155–163. PubMed

Azqueta A, Ladeira C, Giovannelli L, Boutet-Robinet E, Bonassi S, Neri M, Gajskii G, Duthie S, Del Bo C, Riso P, Koppen G, Basaran N, Collins A, Møller P, Application of the comet assay in human biomonitoring:an hCOMET, Mutat. Res 783 (2020) 82–88. PubMed

Collins A, Koppen G, Valdiglesias V, Dusinska M, Kruszewski M, Møller P, Rojas E, Dhawan A, Benzie I, Coskun E, Moretti M, Speit G, Bonassi S for the ComNet project, The comet assay as a tool for human biomonitoring studies: the ComNet project, Rev. Mutat. Res 759 (2014) 27–39. PubMed

Milic M, Frustaci A, Del Bufalo A, Sánchez-Alarcón J, Valencia-Quintana R, Russo P, Bonassi S, DNA damage in non-communicable diseases: a clinical and epidemiological perspective, Mutat. Res 776 (2015) 118–127. PubMed

Taioli E, Bonassi S, Pooled analysis of epidemiological studies involving biological markers, Int. J. Hyg. Environ. Health 206 (2003) 109–115. PubMed

Møller P, Assessment of reference values for DNA damage detected by the comet assay in human blood cell DNA, Mutat. Res 612 (2006) 84–104. PubMed

Møller P, Mőller L, Godschalk RWL, Jones GDD, Assessment and reduction of comet assay variation in relation to DNA damage: studies from the European Comet Assay Validation Group, Mutagenesis 25 (2010) 109–111. PubMed

Johansson C, Møller P, Forchhammer L, Loft S, Godschalk RWL, Langie SAS, Lumeij S, Jones GDD, Kwok RWL, Azqueta A, Phillips DH, Sozeri O, Routledge MN, Charlton AJ, Riso P, Porrini M, Allione A, Matullo G, Palus J, Stepnik M, Collins AR, Möller L, An ECVAG trial on assessment of oxidative damage to DNA measured by the comet assay, Mutagenesis 25 (2010) 125–132. PubMed PMC

Forchhammer L, Johansson C, Loft S, Möller L, Godschalk RWL, Langie SAS, Jones GDD, Kwok RWL, Collins AR, Azqueta A, Phillips DH, Sozeri O, Stepnik M, Palus J, Vogel U, Wallin H, Routledge MN, Handforth C, Allione A, Matullo G, Teixeira JP, Costa S, Riso P, Porrini M, Møller P, Variation in the measurement of DNA damage by comet assay measured by the ECVAG inter-laboratory validation trial, Mutagenesis 25 (2010) 113–123. PubMed

Forchhammer L, Ersson C, Loft S, Möller L, Godschalk RWL, van Schooten FJ, Jones GDD, Higgins JA, Cooke M, Mistry V, Karbaschi M, Collins AR, Azqueta A, Phillips DH, Sozeri O, Routledge MN, Nelson-Smith K, Riso P, Porrini M, Matullo G, Allione A, Stepnik M, Komorowska M, Teixeira JP, Costa S, Corcuera LA, López de Cerain A, Laffon B, Valdiglesias V, Møller P, Inter-laboratory variation in DNA damage using a standard comet assay protocol, Mutagenesis 27 (2012) 665–672. PubMed

Ersson C, Møller P, Forchhammer L, Loft S, Azqueta A, Godschalk RWL, van Schooten FJ, Jones GDD, Higgins JA, Cooke MS, Mistry V, Karbaschi M, Phillips DH, Sozeri O, Routledge MN, Nelson-Smith K, Riso P, Porrini M, Matullo G, Allione A, Stepnik M, Ferlińska M, Teixeira JP, Costa S, Corcuera LA, López A, Laffon de Cerain B, Valdiglesias V, Collins AR, Möller L, An ECVAG inter-laboratory validation study of the comet assay: inter-laboratory and intra-laboratory variations of DNA strand breaks and FPG-sensitive sites in human mononuclear cells, Mutagenesis 28 (2013) 279–286. PubMed

Godschalk RWL, Ersson C, Stepnik M, Ferlińska M, Palus J, Teixeira JP, Costa S, Jones GDD, Higgins JA, Kain J, Möller L, Forchhammer L, Loft S, Lorenzo Y, Collins AR, van Schooten FJ, Laffon B, Valdiglesias V, Cooke M, Mistry V, Karbaschi M, Phillips DH, Sozeri O, Routledge MN, Nelson-Smith K, Riso P, Porrini M, López A, de Cerain A, Azqueta A, Matullo G, Allione A, Møller P, Variation of DNA damage levels in peripheral blood mononuclear cells isolated in different laboratories, Mutagenesis 29 (2014) 241–249. PubMed

Zainol M, Stoute J, Almeida GM, Rapp A, Bowman KJ, Jones GDD, ECVAG. Introducing a true internal standard for the Comet assay to minimize intra- and inter-experiment variability in measures of DNA damage and repair, Nucleic Acids Res 37 (2009) e150. PubMed PMC

Collins AR, Anderson D, Coskun E, Dhawan A, Dusinska M, Koppen G, Kruszewski M, Moretti M, Rojas E, Speit G, Valverde M, Bonassi S, Launch of the ComNet (comet network) project on the comet assay in human population studies during the International Comet Assay Workshop meeting in Kusadasi, Turkey (September 13–16, 2011), Mutagenesis 27 (2012) 385–866. PubMed

Lovell DP, Omori T, Statistical issues in the use of the comet assay, Mutagenesis 23 (2008) 171–182. PubMed

Goldstein H, Multilevel Statistical Models, third ed., Oxford University Press Inc., New York, 2003.

Harrell FE Jr., Regression Modeling Strategies: with Application to Linear Model, Logistic Regression, and Survival Analysis, Springer, New York, 2001.

Merlo J, Chaix B, Ohlsson H, Beckman A, Johnell K, Hjerpe P, Råstam L, Larsen K, A brief conceptual tutorial of multilevel analysis in social epidemiology: using measures of clustering in multilevel logistic regression to investigate contextual phenomena, J. Epidemiol. Community Health 60 (2006) 290–297. PubMed PMC

Der Simonian R, Laird N, Meta-analysis in clinical trials, Control. Clin. Trials 7 (1986) 177–188. PubMed

Brøgger A, Hagmar L, Hansteen IL, Heim S, Högstedt B, Knudsen L, Lambert B, Linnainmaa K, Mitelman F, Nordenson I, et al., An inter-Nordic prospective study on cytogenetic endpoints and cancer risk. Nordic Study Group on the Health Risk of Chromosome Damage, Cancer Genet. Cytogenet 45 (1990) 85–92. PubMed

Bolognesi C, Abbondandolo A, Barale R, Casalone R, Dalpra L, De Ferrari M, Degrassi F, Forni A, Lamberti L, Lando C, Migliore L, Padovani P, Pasquini R, Puntoni R, Sbrana I, Stella M, Bonassi S, Age-related increase of baseline frequencies of sister chromatid exchanges, chromosome aberrations, and micronuclei in human lymphocytes, Cancer Epidemiol. Biomarkers Prev 6 (1997) 249–256. PubMed

Bonassi S, Fenech M, Lando C, Lin YP, Ceppi M, Chang WP, Holland N, Kirsch-Volders M, Zeiger E, Ban S, Barale R, Bigatti MP, Bolognesi C, Jia C, Di Giorgio M, Ferguson LR, Fucic A, Lima OG, Hrelia P, Krishnaja AP, Lee TK, Migliore L, Mikhalevich L, Mirkova E, Mosesso P, Müller WU, Odagiri Y, Scarfi MR, Szabova E, Vorobtsova I, Vral A, Zijno A, HUman MicroNucleus project: international database comparison for results with the cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay in human lymphocytes: I. effect of laboratory protocol, scoring criteria, and host factors on the frequency of micronuclei, Environ. Mol. Mutagen 37 (2001) 31–45. PubMed

Bonassi S, Coskun E, Ceppi M, Lando C, Bolognesi C, Burgaz S, Holland N, Kirsh-Volders M, Knasmueller S, Zeiger E, Carnesoltas D, Cavallo D, da Silva J, de Andrade VM, Demircigil GC, Domínguez Odio A, Donmez-Altuntas H, Gattas G, Giri A, Giri S, Gómez-Meda B, Gómez-Arroyo S, Hadjidekova V, Haveric A, Kamboj M, Kurteshi K, Martino-Roth MG, Montero Montoya R, Nersesyan A, Pastor-Benito S, Favero Salvadori DM, Shaposhnikova A, Stopper H, Thomas P, Torres-Bugarín O, Yadav AS, Zúñiga González G, Fenech M, The HUman MicroNucleus project on eXfoLiated buccal cells (HUMN (XL)): the role of lifestyle, host factors, occupational exposures, health status, and assay protocol, Mutat. Res 728 (2011) 88–97. PubMed

Azqueta A, Muruzabal D, Boutet-Robinet E, Milic M, Dusinska M, Brunborg G, Møller P, Collins AR, Technical recommendations to perform the alkaline standard and enzyme-modified comet assay in human biomonitoring studies, Mutat. Res 843 (2019) 24–32. PubMed

Møller P, Loft S, Ersson C, Koppen G, Dusinska M, Collins A, On the search for an intelligible comet assay descriptor, Front. Genet 5 (2014) 217. PubMed PMC

Møller P, Cooke MS, Collins A, Olinski R, Rozalski R, Loft S, Harmonising measurements of 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2’-deoxyguanosine in cellular DNA and urine, Free Radic. Res 46 (2012) 541–553. PubMed

ESCODD (European Standards Committee on Oxidative DNA Damage), Comparative analysis of baseline 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine in mammalian cell DNA, by different methods in different laboratories: an approach to consensus, Carcinogenesis 23 (2002) 2129–2133. PubMed

European Standards Committee on Oxidative DNA Damage (ESCODD), Measurement of DNA oxidation in human cells by chromatographic and enzymic methods, Free Radic. Biol. Med 34 (2003) 1089–1099. PubMed

ESCODD (European Standards Committee on Oxidative DNA Damage), Gedik CM, Collins A, Establishing the background level of base oxidation in human lymphocyte DNA: results of an interlaboratory validation study, FASEB J 19 (2005) 82–84. PubMed

Ricceri F, Godschalk RW, Peluso M, Phillips DH, Agudo A, Georgiadis P, Loft S, Tjonneland A, Raaschou-Nielsen O, Palli D, Perera F, Vermeulen R, Taioli E, Sram RJ, Munnia A, Rosa F, Allione A, Matullo G, Vineis P, Bulky DNA adducts in white blood cells: a pooled analysis of 3,600 subjects, Cancer Epidemiol. Biomarkers Prev 19 (2010) 3174–3181. PubMed PMC

Møller P, Effect of age and sex on the level of DNA strand breaks and oxidatively damaged DNA in human blood cells, Mutat. Res 838 (2019) 16–21. PubMed

Hoffmann H, Högel J, Speit G, The effect of smoking on DNA effects in the comet assay: a meta-analysis, Mutagenesis 20 (2005) 455–466. PubMed

Bonassi S, Neri M, Lando C, Ceppi M, Lin YP, Chang WP, Holland N, Kirsch-Volders M, Zeiger E, Fenech M, For the HUMN collaborative group, effect of smoking habit on the frequency of micronuclei in human lymphocytes: results from the Human Micro Nucleus project, Mutat. Res 543 (2003) 155–166. PubMed

Key TJ, Appleby PN, Allen NE, Reeves GK, Pooling biomarker data from different studies of disease risk, with a focus on endogenous hormones, Cancer Epidemiol. Biomarkers Prev 19 (2010) 960–965. PubMed PMC

A pooled analysis of host factors that affect nucleotide excision repair in humans

Measuring DNA modifications with the comet assay: a compendium of protocols

Zobrazit více v PubMed

ClinicalTrials.gov
NCT02231736