This article addresses the sociological approach and political engagements of the early twentieth century sociologist, Herbert Adolphus Miller (1875-1951). He is now largely forgotten, but he had deep connections within the Chicago milieu of pragmatist sociology and social reform activities through both the Settlement movement and the Survey movement. In 1914 he wrote a volume in the Cleveland Survey on Immigrant children in the school system and in 1918 was appointed to head the division on Immigrant Contributions in the Carnegie Corporation's project on 'Methods of Americanization', in which Robert E. Park was head of the division on Immigrant Press and Theater (Park in The Immigrant Press, 1922). If Miller's name is recognized at all it is as author with Park of Old World Traits Transplanted (1921), a work subsequently attributed to W. I. Thomas. We examine the nature of Miller's research on immigrant populations from subject nationalities in Europe, undertaken in Cleveland and as part of the Carnegie project. He left the latter project mid-way through to become part of a small group that drafted the Czechoslovakian Declaration of Independence in November 1918. We show how Miller developed a distinctive approach to 'Americanization' through his idea of 'proportional patriotism' that challenged the dominant discourse of assimilation that became entrenched in the years after the end of the first world war and which was largely accepted by Park and by Thomas. He was dismissed in 1932 from Ohio State University because of his views on race mixing and his criticisms of the British and Japanese empires.

Centre for Science Technology and Society Studies Institute of Philosophy CAS Jilská 1 110 00 Praha 1 Czech Republic

See more in PubMed

Abbott A, Egloff R. The Polish peasant in Oberlin and Chicago: the intellectual trajectory of W I. Thomas. The American Sociologist. 2008;39(4):217–258. doi: 10.1007/s12108-008-9045-y. DOI

Abbott G. The immigrant in the community. The Century Company; 1917.

Ayers, L. (1917). The Cleveland school survey: Summary volume. Cleveland: The Survey Committee of the Cleveland Foundation.

Bernard L, Bernard J. Sociology and the study of international relations. Washington University Studies; 1934.

Blumer H. Critiques of research in the social sciences: an appraisal of Thomas and Znaniecki’s The Polish peasant in Europe and America. Transaction; 1939.

Bulmer M. The Social survey movement and early twentieth century sociological methodology. In: Anderson M, Greenwald MW, editors. Pittsburgh surveyed: Social science and social reform in the early twentieth century. University of Pittsburgh Press; 1996. pp. 15–34.

Burns AT. American Americanization. Educational Department of the Municipal Court; 1920.

Burns AT. Immigration, the matrix of American democracy. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 1921;93:144–149. doi: 10.1177/000271622109300129. DOI

Chambers CA. Paul U. Kellogg and the Survey: Voices for social welfare and social Justice. University of Minnesota Press; 1971.

Chapoulie, J. -M. (2020). Chicago sociology. New York: Columbia University Press.

Cohen SR. The Pittsburgh Survey and the Social Survey Movement: a road not taken. In: Bulmer M, Bales K, Sklar KK, editors. The social survey in historical perspective. Cambridge University Press; 1991. pp. 245–268.

Crawford Mitchell R. Alice Garrigue Masaryk, 1879–1966: Her life as recorded in her own words and by her friends. University Center for International Studies; 1980.

Diner SJ. Chicago social workers and blacks in the Progressive Era. Social Service Review. 1970;44(4):393–410. doi: 10.1086/642602. DOI

Du Bois, W. E. B. (1995[1940]). Propaganda and world war. In D. L. Lewis (ed.). W. E. B. Du Bois: A Reader (pp. 388–408). New York: Henry Holt and Company.

Fields K, Fields B. Racecraft: the soul of inequality in American life. Verso; 2012.

Fink C. Defending the rights of others: the great powers, the Jews, and international minority protection, 1878–1938. Cambridge University Press; 2004.

Friends and Relatives of Allen T. Burns. (1954). In Memoriam Allen T. Burns, 1876–1953. Cleveland: Privately Printed.

Furner MO. Seeing Pittsburgh: the social survey, the survey workers, and the historians. Journal of Policy History. 2000;12(3):405–412. doi: 10.1353/jph.2000.0021. DOI

Gelfand LE. The inquiry: American preparations for peace, 1917–19. Yale University Press; 1963.

Gordon MM. Review: the American immigrant revisited. Social Forces. 1975;54(2):470–474. doi: 10.2307/2576648. DOI

Gross N. Richard Rorty: the Making of an American Philosopher. University of Chicago Press; 2008.

Hartmann EG. The movement to Americanize the immigrant. Columbia University Press; 1948.

House F. The development of sociology. McGraw Hill; 1936.

Jones PA., Jr Cleveland’s multicultural librarian: Eleanor (Edwards) Ledbetter, 1870–1954. The Library Quarterly: Information, Community, Policy. 2013;83(3):249–270. doi: 10.1086/670700. DOI

Kellogg, P. U. (1918). The ‘Wilson Policies’. The Survey, October 19th, 250–251.

King DS. Making Americans: Immigration, race and the origins of the diverse democracy. Harvard University Press; 2000.

Kovtun, G. J. (1988). Masaryk & America: testimony of a relationship. Washington D.C.: Library of Congress.

Lagemann EC. The politics of knowledge: The Carnegie corporation, philanthropy and public policy. University of Chicago Press; 1989.

Lamon LC. The black community in Nashville and the Fisk University student strike of 1924–1925. The Journal of Southern History. 1974;40(2):225–244. doi: 10.2307/2206893. DOI

Ledbetter, E. (1918). The Jugoslavs of Cleveland, with a brief sketch of their historical and political backgrounds. Cleveland: Cleveland Americanization Committee.

Lissak, R. S. (1989). Pluralism and progressives: Hull House and the new immigrants, 1890–1919. University of Chicago Press.

Masaryk TG. The making of a state: Memories and observations 1914–1918. Allen and Unwin; 1927.

Matthews FH. Quest for an American sociology: Robert E. Park and the Chicago school. McGill-Queen’s University Press; 1977.

May, A. J. (1957). H. A. Miller and the Mid-European Union of 1918. The American Slavic and East European Review 16(4), 473–488.

Mead GH. The working hypothesis in social reform. American Journal of Sociology. 1899;5(3):367–371. doi: 10.1086/210897. DOI

Miggins EM. The search for the one best system: the Cleveland public schools and educational reform, 1836–1920. In: Van Tassel D, Grabowski J, editors. Cleveland: A tradition of reform. Kent State University Press; 1986. pp. 135–155.

Miggins EM. No crystal stair: the Cleveland public schools and the struggle for equality, 1900–1930. Journal of Urban History. 2014;40(4):671–698. doi: 10.1177/0096144214524340. DOI

Miller HA. Nationalism in Bohemia and Poland. The North American Review. 1914;200(709):879–886.

Miller HA. The psychological limits of eugenics. Popular Science Monthly. 1914;84:390–396.

Miller, H. A. (1916). The school and the immigrant. Cleveland: The Survey Committee of the Cleveland Foundation.

Miller, H. A. (1918a). The lost division. The Survey, June 15th, 307–309.

Miller, H. A. (1918b). Bulwark of freedom: Beginning a discussion of the cohesive forces at work among the subject nationalities of Central Europe: I Emergent democracies. The Survey, October 5th, 5–10.

Miller, H.A. (1918c). Bulwark of freedom II: The rebirth of a nation: the Czechoslovaks, The Survey, November 2nd, 117–20.

Miller, H. A. (1919). Treatment of immigrant heritages. Proceedings of the National Conference of Social Work, 730–738.

Miller HA. The oppression psychosis and the immigrant. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 1921;93(1):139–144. doi: 10.1177/000271622109300128. DOI

Miller HA. The group as an instinct. American Journal of Sociology. 1921;27(3):334–343. doi: 10.1086/213345. DOI

Miller, H. A. (1922). The myth of racial superiority. The World Tomorrow, V(3), 67–70.

Miller HA. Races, nations and classes: the psychology of domination and freedom. J.B. Lippincott and Company; 1924.

Miller, H. A. (1926). The book on Czechoslovakia. Unpublished manuscript. Temple University: Conwellana-Templana Collection.

Miller HA. The beginnings of tomorrow: a introduction to the sociology of the great society. D.C. Heath and Company; 1933.

Miller HA. What Woodrow Wilson and America meant to Czecho-Slovakia. In: Kerner RJ, editor. Czecho-Slovakia: Twenty years of independence. University of California Press; 1940. pp. 71–84.

Mills CW. The professional ideology of social pathologists. American Journal of Sociology. 1943;49(2):165–180. doi: 10.1086/219350. DOI

Mirel JE. Patriotic pluralism: Americanization, education and European immigrants. Harvard University Press; 2010.

Park RE, Miller HA. Old world traits transplanted. Harper and Brothers; 1921.

Park RE. The immigrant press. Harper and Brothers; 1922.

Raushenbush, W. (1979). Robert E. Park: Biography of a sociologist. Durham: Duke University Press.

Reynolds KCh. Visions and vanities: John Andrew Rice of Black Mountain College. Louisiana State University Press; 1998.

Sabine, G. (1931). Academic freedom and tenure at the Ohio State University: Report on the dismissal of professor Herbert A. Miller. Bulletin of the American Association of University Professors (1915–1955), 17(6), 443–473.

Schneiderhahn E. Pragmatism and empirical sociology: the case of Jane Addams and Hull House, 189–1895. Theory and Society. 2011;40(6):589–567. doi: 10.1007/s11186-011-9156-2. DOI

Smith WC. Americans in the making. D. Appleton-Century Co; 1939.

Smith CM. Reparation and reconciliation: the rise and fall of integrated higher education. University of North Carolina Press; 2016. p. 2016.

Švec, L. (2007). Herbert Adolphus Miller, psychóza útisku a středoevropská otázka. [Herbert Adolphus Miller, the psychosis of oppression and the Central European question]. Slovanský přehled [Review for Central, Eastern and Southeastern European History], 93(2), 289–320.

Taylor, A. A. (1952). Fisk University, 1866–1951: A constructive influence in American life. Alrutheus Ambush Taylor manuscript, 359. Amistad Research Center.

Throop, R. & Ward, L. G. (2007). Biography-ing Thomas: Some chapters in the life of William Isaac Thomas. Toronto: The Mead Project. Available at: https://brocku.ca/MeadProject/Scrapbooks/Circulation/Biographying.html. Accessed 9 Jun 2021.

Teeters N. Herbert Adolphus Miller, 1875–1951. American Sociological Review. 1951;16(4):563–564.

Teeters NK. Herbert Adolphus Miller and the dissolution of the Hapsburg empire. Hartwick Review. 1966;2(2):4–15.

The Survey. (1918). The bulwark of free peoples. The Survey for November 2: ix–x.

Thomas WI. Race psychology: Standpoint and questionnaire, with particular reference to the immigrant and the Negro. American Journal of Sociology. 1912;17(6):725–775. doi: 10.1086/212034. DOI

Thomas, W. I. & Znaniecki, F. (1996[1918–21]). The Polish peasant in Europe and America. Edited by Eli Zaretsky. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Thompson FV. Schooling the immigrant. Harper and Brothers; 1920.

Tittle D. Rebuilding Cleveland: the Cleveland Foundation and its evolving urban strategy. Ohio State University Press; 1992.

Turner S. The Pittsburgh survey and the survey movement: an episode in the history of expertise. In: Anderson M, Greenwald MW, editors. Pittsburgh surveyed: Social science and social reform in the early twentieth century. Pittsburgh; 1996. pp. 35–50.

Volkart, E. H. (1951). Social behavior and personality: Contributions of W. I. Thomas to theory and social research. New York: Social Science Research Council.

Waskow AI. From race riot to sit-in, 1919 and the 1960s: a Study in the connections between conflict and violence. Doubleday; 1966.

Wright E., II The tradition of sociology at Fisk University. Journal of African American Studies. 2010;14(1):44–60. doi: 10.1007/s12111-009-9103-8. DOI