We use survey data to study how trust in government and consensus for the pandemic policy response vary with the propensity for altruistic punishment in Italy, the early epicenter of the pandemic. Approval for the management of the crisis decreases with the size of the penalties that individuals would like to see enforced for lockdown violations. People supporting stronger punishment are more likely to consider the government's reaction to the pandemic as insufficient. However, after the establishment of tougher sanctions for risky behaviors, we observe a sudden flip in support for the government. Higher amounts of the desired fines become associated with a higher probability of considering the COVID policy response as too extreme, lower trust in government, and lower confidence in the truthfulness of the officially provided information. These results suggest that lockdowns entail a political cost that helps explain why democracies may adopt epidemiologically suboptimal policies.

Cardiff University Cardiff Business School Cardiff United Kingdom; Masaryk University MUEEL Lab Brno Czech Republic; IZA Bonn Germany

Sapienza University of Rome Italy; IZA Bonn Germany

University of Pavia Department of Political and Social Sciences Italy

Zobrazit více v PubMed

Buonanno P., Puca M. Using newspaper obituaries to “nowcast” daily mortality: evidence from the Italian COVID-19 hot-spots. Health Policy. 2021;125(4):535–540. PubMed PMC

Amuedo-Dorantes C., Borra C., Rivera Garrido N., Sevilla A.. Timing is everything when fighting a pandemic: COVID-19 mortality in Spain; 2020. IZA Discussion Paper No. 13316.

Dehning J., Zierenberg J., Spitzner F.P., Wibral M., Pinheiro Neto J., Wilczek M., Priesemann V. Inferring change points in the spread of COVID-19 reveals the effectiveness of interventions. Science. 2020;369(6500) PubMed PMC

Flaxman S., Mishra S., Gandy A., Unwin J.T., Mellan T.A., Coupland H., Whittaker C., Zhu H., Berah T., Eaton J.W., Monod M., Team I.C.C.-.R., Ghani A.C., Donnelly C.A., Riley S., Vollmer M.A.C., Ferguson N.M., Okell L.C., Bhatt S. Estimating the effects of non-pharmaceutical interventions on COVID-19 in Europe. Nature. 2020;584:257–261. PubMed

Megna R. Inferring a cause-effect relationship between lockdown restrictions and COVID-19 pandemic trend during the first wave. Health Policy. 2021;125(11):1441–1447. PubMed PMC

Pelagatti M., Maranzano P. Assessing the effectiveness of the Italian risk-zones policy during the second wave of COVID-19. Health Policy. 2021;125(9):1188–1199. PubMed PMC

Juranek S., Paetzold J., Winner H., Zoutman F. Labor market effects of COVID-19 in Sweden and its neighbors: evidence from administrative data. Kyklos. 2021;74(4):512–526. PubMed PMC

Eichenberger R., Hegselmann R., Savage D.A., Stadelmann D., Torgler B. Certified coronavirus immunity as a resource and strategy to cope with pandemic costs. Kyklos. 2020;73(3):464–474.

Coibion O., Gorodnichenko Y., Weber M. The cost of the COVID-19 crisis: lockdowns, macroeconomic expectations, and consumer spending. COVID Econ. 2020;20:1–51.

Amat F., Falcó-Gimeno A., Arenas A., Muñoz J.. Pandemics meet democracy. Experimental evidence from the COVID-19 crisis in Spain; 2020. SocArxiv preprint. doi:10.31235/osf.io/dkusw. DOI

Koyama M. Epidemic disease and the state: is there a tradeoff between public health and liberty? Public Choice. 2021:1–23. PubMed PMC

Chae S.H., Park H.J. Effectiveness of penalties for lockdown violations during the COVID-19 pandemic in Germany. Am J Public Health. 2020;110(12):1844–1849. PubMed PMC

Molldrem S., Hussain M.I., McClelland A. Alternatives to sharing COVID-19 data with law enforcement: recommendations for stakeholders. Health Policy. 2021;125(2):135–140. PubMed PMC

Pulejo M., Querubín P. Electoral concerns reduce restrictive measures during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Public Econ. 2021;184(104387) PubMed PMC

Sabat I., Neuman-Böhme S., Varghese N.E., Barros P.P., Brouwer W., van Exel J., et al. United but divided: policy responses and people’s perceptions in the EU during the COVID-19 outbreak. Health Policy. 2020;124(9):909–918. PubMed PMC

Hensel L., Witte M., Caria S., Fetzer T., Fiorin S., Goetz F.M., et al. Global behaviors, perceptions, and the emergence of social norms at the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. J Econc Behav Organ. 2021 doi: 10.1016/j.jebo.2021.11.015. PubMed DOI PMC

Fehr E., Gächter S. Altruistic punishment in humans. Nature. 2002;415:137–140. PubMed

Takahashi R., Tanaka K. Social punishment for breaching restrictions during the COVID-19 pandemic. Econ Inq. 2021;59(4):1467–1482. PubMed PMC

Schunk D., Wagner V. What determines the willingness to sanction violations of newly introduced social norms: personality traits or economic preferences? evidence from the COVID-19 crisis. J Behav Exp Econ. 2021:101716.

Betchel M.M., Hainmueller J. How lasting is voter gratitude? an analysis of the short-and long-term electoral returns to beneficial policy. Am Political Sci Rev. 2011;55(4):852–868.

Levi E., Mariani R.D., Patriarca F. Hate at first sight? dynamic aspects of the electoral impact of migration: the case of ukip. J Popul Econ. 2020;33(1):1–32.

Ashworth S., Bueno de Mesquita E., Friedenberg A. Learning about voter rationality. Am J Pol Sci. 2018;62(1):37–54.

Bol D., Giani M., Blais A., Loewen P.J. The effect of COVID-19 lockdowns on political support: some good news for democracy? Eur J Polit Res. 2020;DOI: 10.1111/1475-6765.12401

Daniele G., Martinangeli A.F.M., Passarelli F., Sas W., Windsteiger L.. Wind of change? Experimental survey evidence on the Covid-19 shock and socio-political attitudes in Europe; 2020. Max Planck Institute for Tax Law and Public Finance Working Paper No. 2020-10.

De Vries C.E., Bakker B.N., Hobolt S., Arceneaux K. Crisis signaling: how Italy’s coronavirus lockdown affected incumbent support in other european countries. Political Science Research and Methods. 2021;9(3):451–467.

Hargreaves Heap S., Koop C., Matakos K., Unan A., Weber N. Covid-19 and people’s health-wealth preferences: information effects and policy implications. COVID Econ. 2020;22:59–116.

Koppl R. Public health and expert failure. Public Choice. 2021:1–24. PubMed PMC

Baccini L., Brodeur A., Weymouth S. The COVID-19 pandemic and the 2020 US presidential election. J Popul Econ. 2021;34(2):739–767. PubMed PMC

Aksoy C.G., Eichengreen B., Saka O.. The political scar of epidemics; 2020. IZA Discussion Paper No. 13351.

Abel M., Byker T., Carpenter J.P. Socially optimal mistakes? Debiasing COVID-19 mortality risk perceptions and prosocial behavior. J Econ Behav Organ. 2021;183:456–480.

Barrios J.M., Benmelech E., Hochberg Y.V., Sapienza P., Zingales L. Civic capital and social distancing during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Public Econ. 2020 doi: 10.1016/j.jpubeco.2020.104310. PubMed DOI PMC

Brodeur A., Clark A.E., Fleche S., Powdthavee N. COVID-19, Lockdowns and well-being: evidence from google trends. J Public Econ. 2021;193 doi: 10.1016/j.jpubeco.2020.104346. PubMed DOI PMC

Congleton R.D. Federalism and pandemic policies: variety as the spice of life. Public Choice. 2021:1–28. PubMed PMC

Fetzer T., Hensel L., Hermle J., Roth C. Coronavirus perceptions and economic anxiety. Rev Econ Stat. 2021;103(5):968–978.

Bargain O., Aminjonov U. Trust and compliance to public health policies in times of COVID-19. J Public Econ. 2020 doi: 10.1016/j.jpubeco.2020.104316. PubMed DOI PMC

Briscese G., Lacetera N., Macis M., Tonin M.. Compliance with COVID-19 social-distancing measures in Italy: the role of expectations and duration; 2020. NBER Working Paper No. 26916.

De Rosis S., Lopreite M., Puliga M., Vainieri M. The early weeks of the italian covid-19 outbreak: sentiment insights from a twitter analysis. Health Policy. 2021;125(8):987–994. PubMed PMC

Iacono S.L., Przepiorka W., Buskens V., Corten R., van de Rijt A. COVID-19 Vulnerability and perceived norm violations predict loss of social trust: a pre-post study. Soc Sci Med. 2021;291:114513. PubMed PMC

Mendolia S., Stavrunova O., Yerohkin O. Determinants of the community mobility during the COVID-19 epidemic: the role of government regulations and information. J Econ Behav Organ. 2021;184:199–231. PubMed PMC

Nivette A., Ribeaud D., Murray A., Steinhoff A., Bechtiger L., Hepp U., et al. Non-compliance with COVID-19-related public health measures among young adults in switzerland: insights from a longitudinal cohort study. Soc Sci Med. 2021;268:113370. PubMed PMC

Shao W., Hao F. Confidence in political leaders can slant risk perceptions of COVID-19 in a highly polarized environment. Soc Sci Med. 2020;261:113235. PubMed PMC

Deiana C., Geraci A., Mazzarella G., Sabatini F. COVID-19 Relief programs and compliance with confinement measures. IZA Discussion Paper No 14064. 2021

Bassi V., Rasul I. Persuasion: a case study of papal influences on fertility-related beliefs and behavior. Am Econ J Appl Econ. 2017;9(4):250–302.

Ajzenman N., Cavalcanti T., Da Mata D.. More than words: Leaders’ speech and risky behavior during a pandemic; 2020. Available at SSRN: 10.2139/ssrn.3582908. DOI

Allcott H., Boxell L., Conway J.C., Gentzkow M., Thaler M., Yang D.Y. Polarization and public health: partisan differences in social distancing during the coronavirus pandemic. J Public Econ. 2020 doi: 10.1016/j.jpubeco.2020.104254. PubMed DOI PMC

Simonov A., Sacher S.K., Dubé J.-P.H., Biswas S. The persuasive effect of fox news: non-compliance with social distancing during the covid-19 pandemic. Marketing Science. 2021;https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2021.1328

Fetzer T.R., Witte M., Hensel L., Jachimowicz J., Haushofer J., Ivchenko A., Caria S., Reutskaja E., Roth C.P., Fiorin S., Gomez M., Kraft-Todd G., Goetz F.M., Yoeli E. Tech. Rep. National Bureau of Economic Research; 2020. Global behaviors and perceptions at the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. PubMed PMC

John O.P., Srivastava S., et al. The big five trait taxonomy: history, measurement, and theoretical perspectives. Handbook of personality: theory and research. 1999;2(1999):102–138.

Jagelka T.. Are economists’ preferences psychologists’ personality traits? A structural approach; 2020. IZA Discussion Paper 13303.

Chiapello M. Tech. Rep. Statistical Software Components S458424 - Boston College Department of Economics; 2018. Balancetable: Stata module to build a balance table.

Falk A., Fehr E., Fischbacher U. Driving forces behind informal sanctions. Econometrica. 2005;73(6):2017–2030.

Fowler J.H., Johnson T., Smirnov O. Egalitarian motive and altruistic punishment. Nature. 2005;433(7021) PubMed

Sun L., Tan P., Cheng Y., Chen J., Qu C. The effect of altruistic tendency on fairness in third-party punishment. Front Psychol. 2015;6:820. PubMed PMC

Boyd R., Gintis H., Bowles S., Richerson P.J. The evolution of altruistic punishment. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2003;100(6):3531–3535. PubMed PMC

Spitzer M., Fischbacher U., Herrnberger B., Grön G., Fehr E. The neural signature of social norm compliance. Neuron. 2007;56(1):185–196. PubMed

Coricelli G., Joffily M., Montmarquette C., Villeval M.C. Cheating, emotions, and rationality: an experiment on tax evasion. Exp Econ. 2010;13(2):226–247.

Gordon D.S., Lea S.E. Who punishes? the status of the punishers affects the perceived success of, and indirect benefits from, moralistic punishment. Evolutionary Psychology. 2016;14(3)

Balafoutas L., Nikiforakis N., Rockenbach B. Altruistic punishment does not increase with the severity of norm violations in the field. Nat Commun. 2016;7(13327) doi: 10.1038/ncomms13327. PubMed DOI PMC

Rothstein B., Stolle D. In: Generating social capital. Rothstein B., Stolle D., editors. Palgrave Macmillan; New York: 2003. Social capital, impartiality and the welfare state: an institutional approach; pp. 191–209.

Kumlin S., Rothstein B. Making and breaking social capital: the impact of welfare-state institutions. Comp Political Stud. 2005;38(4):339–365.

Di Maggio M., Perrone M. The political culture of the movimento cinque stelle, from foundation to the reins of government. J Mod Ital Stud. 2019;24(3):468–482.

Feld L., Frey B.S. Tax compliance as the result of a psychological tax contract: the role of incentives and responsive regulation. Law Policy. 2007;29(1):102–120.

Francetic I. Bad law or implementation flaws? lessons from the implementation of the new law on epidemics during the response to the first wave of COVID-19 in switzerland. Health Policy. 2021;125(10):1285–1290. PubMed PMC

Tyler T.R. Procedural justice, legitimacy, and the effective rule of law. Crime Justice. 2003;30:283–357.

Rothstein B., Stolle D. The state and social capital: an institutional theory of generalized trust. Comp Politics. 2008;40(4):441–459.