The Canadian province of Alberta contains substantial oilsands reservoirs, consisting of bitumen, clay and sand. Extracting oil involves separating bitumen from inorganic particles using hot water and chemical diluents, resulting in liquid tailings waste with ecotoxicologically significant compounds. Ongoing efforts aim to reclaim tailings-affected areas, with protist colonisation serving as one assessment method of reclamation progress. Oilsands-associated protist communities have mainly been evaluated using amplicon sequencing of the 18S rRNA V4 region; however, this barcode may overlook important protist groups. This study examined how community assessment methods between the V4 and V9 regions differ in representing protist diversity across four oilsands-associated environments. The V9 barcode identified more operational taxonomical units (OTUs) for Discoba, Metamonada and Amoebozoa compared with the V4. A comparative shotgun metagenomics approach revealed few eukaryotic contigs but did recover a complete Paramicrosporidia mitochondrial genome, only the second publicly available from microsporidians. Both V4 and V9 markers were informative for assessing community diversity in oilsands-associated environments and are most effective when combined for a comprehensive taxonomic estimate, particularly in anoxic environments.

Department of Biological Sciences University of Calgary Calgary Alberta Canada

Department of Parasitology Faculty of Science Charles University Vestec Czech Republic

Division of Infectious Diseases Department of Medicine and Department of Biological Sciences University of Alberta Edmonton Alberta Canada

Institute of Parasitology Biology Centre Czech Academy of Sciences České Budějovice Czech Republic

Life Science Research Centre Faculty of Science University of Ostrava Ostrava Czech Republic

Zobrazit více v PubMed

Aguilar, M. , Richardson E., Tan B. F., et al. 2016. “Next‐Generation Sequencing Assessment of Eukaryotic Diversity in Oil Sands Tailings Ponds Sediments and Surface Water.” Journal of Eukaryotic Microbiology 63: 732–743. PubMed

Albakistani, E. A. , Nwosu F. C., Furgason C., et al. 2022. “Seasonal Dynamics of Methanotrophic Bacteria in a Boreal Oil Sands End Pit Lake.” Applied and Environmental Microbiology 88: e0145521. PubMed PMC

Altschul, S. F. , Gish W., Miller W., Myers E. W., and Lipman D. J.. 1990. “Basic Local Alignment Search Tool.” Journal of Molecular Biology 215: 403–410. PubMed

Archibald, J. M. , Simpson A. G. B., and Slamovits C. H., eds. 2017. Handbook of the Protists. Cham: Springer.

Berger, S. A. , Krompass D., and Stamatakis A.. 2011. “Performance, Accuracy, and Web Server for Evolutionary Placement of Short Sequence Reads Under Maximum Likelihood.” Systematic Biology 60: 291–302. PubMed PMC

Beule, L. , and Karlovsky P.. 2020. “Improved Normalization of Species Count Data in Ecology by Scaling With Ranked Subsampling (SRS): Application to Microbial Communities.” PeerJ 8: e9593. PubMed PMC

Brown, L. D. , and Ulrich A. C.. 2015. “Oil Sands Naphthenic Acids: A Review of Properties, Measurement, and Treatment.” Chemosphere 127: 276–290. PubMed

Capella‐Gutiérrez, S. , Silla‐Martínez J. M., and Gabaldón T.. 2009. “trimAl: A Tool for Automated Alignment Trimming in Large‐Scale Phylogenetic Analyses.” Bioinformatics 25: 1972–1973. PubMed PMC

Caporaso, J. G. , Kuczynski J., Stombaugh J., et al. 2010. “QIIME Allows Analysis of High‐Throughput Community Sequencing Data.” Nature Methods 7: 335–336. PubMed PMC

Céza, V. , Kotyk M., Kubánková A., et al. 2022. “Free‐Living Trichomonads Are Unexpectedly Diverse.” Protist 173: 125883. PubMed

Choi, J. , and Park J. S.. 2020. “Comparative Analyses of the V4 and V9 Regions of 18S rDNA for the Extant Eukaryotic Community Using the Illumina Platform.” Scientific Reports 10: 6519. PubMed PMC

Czech, L. , Barbera P., and Stamatakis A.. 2020. “Genesis and Gappa: Processing, Analyzing and Visualizing Phylogenetic (Placement) Data.” Bioinformatics 36: 3263–3265. PubMed PMC

Darling, A. E. , Mau B., and Perna N. T.. 2010. “Progressivemauve: Multiple Genome Alignment With Gene Gain, Loss and Rearrangement.” PLoS One 5: e11147. PubMed PMC

de Vargas, C. , Audic S., Henry N., et al. 2015. “Ocean Plankton. Eukaryotic Plankton Diversity in the Sunlit Ocean.” Science 348: 1261605. PubMed

Decelle, J. , Romac S., Sasaki E., Not F., and Mahé F.. 2014. “Intracellular Diversity of the V4 and V9 Regions of the 18S rRNA in Marine Protists (Radiolarians) Assessed by High‐Throughput Sequencing.” PLoS One 9: e104297. PubMed PMC

del Campo, J. , Pons M. J., Herranz M., et al. 2019. “Validation of a Universal Set of Primers to Study Animal‐Associated Microeukaryotic Communities.” Environmental Microbiology 21: 3855–3861. PubMed

Dixon, P. 2003. “VEGAN, a Package of R Functions for Community Ecology.” Journal of Vegetation Science 14: 927–930.

Dunthorn, M. , Klier J., Bunge J., and Stoeck T.. 2012. “Comparing the Hyper‐Variable V4 and V9 Regions of the Small Subunit rDNA for Assessment of Ciliate Environmental Diversity.” Journal of Eukaryotic Microbiology 59: 185–187. PubMed

Edgar, R. C. 2004. “MUSCLE: Multiple Sequence Alignment With High Accuracy and High Throughput.” Nucleic Acids Research 32: 1792–1797. PubMed PMC

Ersoy, E. , Schaffer M. E., and Ditzen J.. 2019. “BP Statistical Review of World Energy 2019.” researchportal.hw.ac.uk/en/publications/bp‐statistical‐review‐of‐world‐energy‐2019.

Foght, J. M. , Gieg L. M., and Siddique T.. 2017. “The Microbiology of Oil Sands Tailings: Past, Present, Future.” FEMS Microbiology Ecology 93: fix034. PubMed

Furgason, C. C. , Smirnova A. V., Dacks J. B., and Dunfield P. F.. 2024. “Phytoplankton Ecology in the Early Years of a Boreal Oil Sands End Pit Lake.” Environmental Microbiomes 19: 3. PubMed PMC

Golby, S. , Ceri H., Gieg L. M., Chatterjee I., Marques L. L. R., and Turner R. J.. 2012. “Evaluation of Microbial Biofilm Communities From an Alberta Oil Sands Tailings Pond.” FEMS Microbiology Ecology 79: 240–250. PubMed

Government of Alberta . 2023. “Oil Sands Facts and Statistics.” www.alberta.ca/oil‐sands‐facts‐and‐statistics.

Greiner, S. , Lehwark P., and Bock R.. 2019. “OrganellarGenomeDRAW (OGDRAW) Version 1.3.1: Expanded Toolkit for the Graphical Visualization of Organellar Genomes.” Nucleic Acids Research 47: W59–W64. PubMed PMC

Guillou, L. , Bachar D., Audic S., et al. 2013. “The Protist Ribosomal Reference Database (PR2): A Catalog of Unicellular Eukaryote Small Sub‐Unit rRNA Sequences With Curated Taxonomy.” Nucleic Acids Research 41, no. Database issue: D597–D604. PubMed PMC

Gurevich, A. , Saveliev V., Vyahhi N., and Tesler G.. 2013. “QUAST: Quality Assessment Tool for Genome Assemblies.” Bioinformatics 29: 1072–1075. PubMed PMC

Han, Y. , Guo C., Guan X., et al. 2022. “Comparison of Deep‐Sea Picoeukaryotic Composition Estimated From the V4 and V9 Regions of 18S rRNA Gene With a Focus on the Hadal Zone of the Mariana Trench.” Microbial Ecology 83: 34–47. PubMed

Hein, F. J. 2006. “Heavy Oil and Oil (Tar) Sands in North America: An Overview & Summary of Contributions.” Natural Resources Research 15: 67–84.

Hein, F. J. 2017. “Geology of Bitumen and Heavy Oil: An Overview.” Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 154: 551–563.

Holden, A. A. , Donahue R. B., and Ulrich A. C.. 2011. “Geochemical Interactions Between Process‐Affected Water From Oil Sands Tailings Ponds and North Alberta Surficial Sediments.” Journal of Contaminant Hydrology 119: 55–68. PubMed

Holowenko, F. M. , MacKinnon M. D., and Fedorak P. M.. 2001. “Naphthenic Acids and Surrogate Naphthenic Acids in Methanogenic Microcosms.” Water Research 35: 2595–2606. PubMed

Hong, P. Y. , Mantilla‐Calderon D., and Wang C.. 2020. “Metagenomics as a Tool to Monitor Reclaimed‐Water Quality.” Applied and Environmental Microbiology 86: e00724. PubMed PMC

Hrynyshyn, J. 2012. “End Pit Lakes Guidance Document 2012.” Cumulative Environmental Management Association. www.cclmportal.ca/resource/end‐pit‐lakes‐guidance‐document‐2012.

Hu, S. K. , Liu Z., Lie A. A. Y., et al. 2015. “Estimating Protistan Diversity Using High‐Throughput Sequencing.” Journal of Eukaryotic Microbiology 62: 688–693. PubMed

IEA . 2021. “World Energy Outlook.” www.iea.org/reports/world‐energy‐outlook‐2021.

Jin, S. , Lee H. G., Park C., and Kim K. Y.. 2023. “Small‐Organelle‐Enriched Metagenomics: An Improved Method for Environmental DNA‐Based Identification of Marine Plankton.” Limnology and Oceanography: Methods 21: 178–191.

Jordaan, S. M. 2012. “Land and Water Impacts of Oil Sands Production in Alberta.” Environmental Science & Technology 46: 3611–3617. PubMed

Kalyaanamoorthy, S. , Minh B. Q., Wong T. K. F., Von Haeseler A., and Jermiin L. S.. 2017. “ModelFinder: Fast Model Selection for Accurate Phylogenetic Estimates.” Nature Methods 14: 587–589. PubMed PMC

Karlicki, M. , Antonowicz S., and Karnkowska A.. 2022. “Tiara: Deep Learning‐Based Classification System for Eukaryotic Sequences.” Bioinformatics 38: 344–350. PubMed PMC

Katoh, K. , and Standley D. M.. 2013. “MAFFT Multiple Sequence Alignment Software Version 7: Improvements in Performance and Usability.” Molecular Biology and Evolution 30: 772–780. PubMed PMC

Kelley, L. A. , Mezulis S., Yates C. M., Wass M. N., and Sternberg M. J. E.. 2015. “The Phyre2 Web Portal for Protein Modeling, Prediction and Analysis.” Nature Protocols 10: 845–858. PubMed PMC

Kembel, S. W. , Cowan P. D., Helmus M. R., et al. 2010. “Picante: R Tools for Integrating Phylogenies and Ecology.” Bioinformatics 26: 1463–1464. PubMed

Kezlya, E. , Tseplik N., and Kulikovskiy M.. 2023. “Genetic Markers for Metabarcoding of Freshwater Microalgae: Review.” Biology 12: 1038. PubMed PMC

Kim, E. , Sprung B., Duhamel S., Filardi C., and Kyoon S. M.. 2016. “Oligotrophic Lagoons of the South Pacific Ocean Are Home to a Surprising Number of Novel Eukaryotic Microorganisms.” Environmental Microbiology 18: 4549–4563. PubMed

Kodikara, S. , Ellul S., and Lê Cao K.‐A.. 2022. “Statistical Challenges in Longitudinal Microbiome Data Analysis.” Briefings in Bioinformatics 23: bbac273. PubMed PMC

Kolisko, M. , Flegontova O., Karnkowska A., et al. 2020. “EukRef‐Excavates: Seven Curated SSU Ribosomal RNA Gene Databases.” Database 2020: baaa080. PubMed PMC

Lang, B. F. , Beck N., Prince S., Sarrasin M., Rioux P., and Burger G.. 2023. “Mitochondrial Genome Annotation With MFannot: A Critical Analysis of Gene Identification and Gene Model Prediction.” Frontiers in Plant Science 14: 1222186. PubMed PMC

Lawrence, G. A. , Tedford E. W., and Pieters R.. 2015. “Suspended Solids in an End Pit Lake: Potential Mixing Mechanisms.” Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering 43: 211–217.

Levy Karin, E. , Mirdita M., and Söding J.. 2020. “MetaEuk‐Sensitive, High‐Throughput Gene Discovery, and Annotation for Large‐Scale Eukaryotic Metagenomics.” Microbiome 8: 48. PubMed PMC

Li, Y. , Gao P., Sun X., et al. 2022. “Primary Succession Changes the Composition and Functioning of the Protist Community on Mine Tailings, Especially Phototrophic Protists.” ACS Environmental Au 2: 396–408. PubMed PMC

Liddicoat, C. , Krauss S. L., Bissett A., et al. 2022. “Next‐Generation Restoration Metrics: Using Soil eDNA Bacterial Community Data to Measure Trajectories Towards Rehabilitation Targets.” Journal of Environmental Management 310: 114748. PubMed

Maddison, W. P. , and Maddison D. R.. 2023. “Mesquite: A Modular System for Evolutionary Analysis.”

Mahé, F. , Rognes T., Quince C., de Vargas C., and Dunthorn M.. 2015. “Swarmv2: Highly‐Scalable and High‐Resolution Amplicon Clustering.” PeerJ 3: e1420. PubMed PMC

Mazancová, E. , Zadrobílková E., Yubuki N., and Čepička I.. 2023. “Phylogenetic and Morphological Diversity of Free‐Living Diplomonads.” European Journal of Protistology 91: 126024. PubMed

Minh, B. Q. , Nguyen M. A. T., and Von Haeseler A.. 2013. “Ultrafast Approximation for Phylogenetic Bootstrap.” Molecular Biology and Evolution 30: 1188–1195. PubMed PMC

Monier, A. , Worden A. Z., and Richards T. A.. 2016. “Phylogenetic Diversity and Biogeography of the Mamiellophyceae Lineage of Eukaryotic Phytoplankton Across the Oceans.” Environmental Microbiology Reports 8: 461–469. PubMed

Muñoz‐Gómez, S. A. 2023. “Energetics and Evolution of Anaerobic Microbial Eukaryotes.” Nature Microbiology 8: 197–203. PubMed

Nguyen, L. T. , Schmidt H. A., von Haeseler A., and Minh B. Q.. 2015. “IQ‐TREE: A Fast and Effective Stochastic Algorithm for Estimating Maximum‐Likelihood Phylogenies.” Molecular Biology and Evolution 32: 268–274. PubMed PMC

Nix, P. G. , and Martin R. W.. 1992. “Detoxification and Reclamation of Suncor's Oil Sand Tailings Ponds.” Environmental Toxicology and Water Quality 7: 171–188.

Nurk, S. , Meleshko D., Korobeynikov A., and Pevzner P. A.. 2017. “MetaSPAdes: A New Versatile Metagenomic Assembler.” Genome Research 27: 824–834. PubMed PMC

Ondov, B. D. , Bergman N. H., and Phillippy A. M.. 2011. “Interactive Metagenomic Visualization in a Web Browser.” BMC Bioinformatics 12: 385. PubMed PMC

Pagenkopp Lohan, K. M. , Fleischer R. C., Carney K. J., Holzer K. K., and Ruiz G. M.. 2016. “Amplicon‐Based Pyrosequencing Reveals High Diversity of Protistan Parasites in ships' Ballast Water: Implications for Biogeography and Infectious Diseases.” Microbial Ecology 71: 530–542. PubMed

Penner, T. J. , and Foght J. M.. 2010. “Mature Fine Tailings From Oil Sands Processing Harbour Diverse Methanogenic Communities.” Canadian Journal of Microbiology 56: 459–470. PubMed

Piredda, R. , Tomasino M. P., D'Erchia A. M., et al. 2017. “Diversity and Temporal Patterns of Planktonic Protist Assemblages at a Mediterranean Long Term Ecological Research Site.” FEMS Microbiology Ecology 93: fiw200. PubMed

Quandt, C. A. , Beaudet D., Corsaro D., et al. 2017. “The Genome of an Intranuclear Parasite, Paramicrosporidium saccamoebae, Reveals Alternative Adaptations to Obligate Intracellular Parasitism.” eLife 6: e29594. PubMed PMC

Ramos‐Padrón, E. , Bordenave S., Lin S., et al. 2011. “Carbon and Sulfur Cycling by Microbial Communities in a Gypsum‐Treated Oil Sands Tailings Pond.” Environmental Science & Technology 45: 439–446. PubMed

Richardson, E. , Bass D., Smirnova A., Paoli L., Dunfield P., and Dacks J. B.. 2020. “Phylogenetic Estimation of Community Composition and Novel Eukaryotic Lineages in Base Mine Lake: An Oil Sands Tailings Reclamation Site in Northern Alberta.” Journal of Eukaryotic Microbiology 67: 86–99. PubMed

Richter, D. J. , Berney C., Strassert J. F. H., et al. 2022. “EukProt: A Database of Genome‐Scale Predicted Proteins Across the Diversity of Eukaryotes.” Peer Community Journal 2: e56.

Rodríguez‐Martínez, R. , Leonard G., Milner D. S., et al. 2020. “Controlled Sampling of Ribosomally Active Protistan Diversity in Sediment‐Surface Layers Identifies Putative Players in the Marine Carbon Sink.” ISME Journal 14: 984–998. PubMed PMC

Saidi‐Mehrabad, A. , He Z., Tamas I., et al. 2013. “Methanotrophic Bacteria in Oilsands Tailings Ponds of Northern Alberta.” ISME Journal 7: 908–921. PubMed PMC

Schoenle, A. , Hohlfeld M., Hermanns K., et al. 2021. “High and Specific Diversity of Protists in the Deep‐Sea Basins Dominated by Diplonemids, Kinetoplastids, Ciliates and Foraminiferans.” Communications Biology 4: 501. PubMed PMC

Small, C. C. , Cho S., Hashisho Z., and Ulrich A. C.. 2015. “Emissions From Oil Sands Tailings Ponds: Review of Tailings Pond Parameters and Emission Estimates.” Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 127: 490–501.

Somerfield, P. J. , Clarke K. R., and Gorley R. N.. 2021. “Analysis of Similarities (ANOSIM) for 2‐Way Layouts Using a Generalised ANOSIM Statistic, With Comparative Notes on Permutational Multivariate Analysis of Variance (PERMANOVA).” Austral Ecology 46: 911–926.

Stairs, C. W. , Táborský P., Salomaki E. D., et al. 2021. “Anaeramoebae Are a Divergent Lineage of Eukaryotes That Shed Light on the Transition From Anaerobic Mitochondria to Hydrogenosomes.” Current Biology 31: 5605–5612.e5. PubMed

Stamatakis, A. 2014. “RAxML Version 8: A Tool for Phylogenetic Analysis and Post‐Analysis of Large Phylogenies.” Bioinformatics 30: 1312–1313. PubMed PMC

Steinegger, M. , and Söding J.. 2017. “MMseqs2 Enables Sensitive Protein Sequence Searching for the Analysis of Massive Data Sets.” Nature Biotechnology 35: 1026–1028. PubMed

Stoeck, T. , Bass D., Nebel M., et al. 2010. “Multiple Marker Parallel Tag Environmental DNA Sequencing Reveals a Highly Complex Eukaryotic Community in Marine Anoxic Water.” Molecular Ecology 19: 21–31. PubMed

Suncor Energy (Syncrude) Operating Inc. (SESOI) . 2023. “Pit Lake Monitoring and Research Report.” era.library.ualberta.ca/items/08a0f2a1‐b675‐4010‐b5d6‐77c51e3ff1a8.

Táborský, P. , Pánek T., and Čepička I.. 2017. “Anaeramoebidae Fam. Nov., a Novel Lineage of Anaerobic Amoebae and Amoeboflagellates of Uncertain Phylogenetic Position.” Protist 168: 495–526. PubMed

Tessler, M. , Neumann J. S., Afshinnekoo E., et al. 2017. “Large‐Scale Differences in Microbial Biodiversity Discovery Between 16S Amplicon and Shotgun Sequencing.” Scientific Reports 7: 6589. PubMed PMC

Tragin, M. , and Vaulot D.. 2018. “Green Microalgae in Marine Coastal Waters: The Ocean Sampling Day (OSD) Dataset.” Scientific Reports 8: 14020. PubMed PMC

Tragin, M. , Zingone A., and Vaulot D.. 2018. “Comparison of Coastal Phytoplankton Composition Estimated From the V4 and V9 Regions of the 18S rRNA Gene With a Focus on Photosynthetic Groups and Especially Chlorophyta.” Environmental Microbiology 20: 506–520. PubMed

van der Heyde, M. , Bunce M., Wardell‐Johnson G., Fernandes K., White N. E., and Nevill P.. 2020. “Testing Multiple Substrates for Terrestrial Biodiversity Monitoring Using Environmental DNA Metabarcoding.” Molecular Ecology Resources 20: 732–745. PubMed

White, K. B. , and Liber K.. 2018. “Early Chemical and Toxicological Risk Characterization of Inorganic Constituents in Surface Water From the Canadian Oil Sands First Large‐Scale End Pit Lake.” Chemosphere 211: 745–757. PubMed

Wideman, J. G. , Monier A., Rodríguez‐Martínez R., et al. 2020. “Unexpected Mitochondrial Genome Diversity Revealed by Targeted Single‐Cell Genomics of Heterotrophic Flagellated Protists.” Nature Microbiology 5: 154–165. PubMed

Wu, Z. L. , Lin Z., Sun Z. Y., Gou M., Xia Z. Y., and Tang Y. Q.. 2020. “A Comparative Study of Mesophilic and Thermophilic Anaerobic Digestion of Municipal Sludge With High‐Solids Content: Reactor Performance and Microbial Community.” Bioresource Technology 302: 122851. PubMed

Yang, S. 2018. “otuSummary: Summarizing OTU Table Regarding the Composition, Abundance and Beta Diversity of Abundant and Rare Biospheres.” R Package Version 0.1.1. https://github.com/cam315/otuSummary.

Yazaki, E. , Kume K., Shiratori T., et al. 2020. “Barthelonids Represent a Deep‐Branching Metamonad Clade With Mitochondrion‐Related Organelles Predicted to Generate no ATP: Barthelonids as a Novel Metamonada Clade.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 287: 20201538. PubMed PMC

Záhonová, K. , Lax G., Sinha S. D., et al. 2021. “Single‐Cell Genomics Unveils a Canonical Origin of the Diverse Mitochondrial Genomes of Euglenozoans.” BMC Biology 19: 103. PubMed PMC