Facultative symbionts are widespread in arthropods and can provide important services such as protection from natural enemies. Yet what shapes associations with defensive symbionts in nature remains unclear. Two hypotheses suggest that interactions with either antagonists or host plants explain the prevalence of symbionts through shared selective pressures or vectors of symbiont transmission. Here we investigate the factors determining similarities in the Hamiltonella defensa symbiosis shared amongst field-collected aphid species. After accounting for host species relatedness, we find that Hamiltonella's genotype distribution aligns with sharing the same parasitoids, rather than host plants, highlighting parasitoids and hosts as key selective agents shaping the symbiosis across aphid species. Our data indicates parasitoid host specificity drives the prevalence of specific aphid-Hamiltonella associations, suggesting defensive symbioses are maintained by the selective pressure imposed by dominant parasitoids and their aphid hosts. These findings underscore the importance of interactions with natural enemies in explaining patterns of defensive symbiosis in nature.

Biology Centre of the Czech Academy of Sciences Institute of Entomology Ceske Budejovice Czech Republic

School of Biological and Behavioural Sciences Queen Mary University of London London UK

Zobrazit více v PubMed

Ahmed, M. Z. , Li S. J., Xue X., et al. 2015. “The Intracellular Bacterium Wolbachia Uses Parasitoid Wasps as Phoretic Vectors for Efficient Horizontal Transmission.” PLoS Pathogens 11: e1004672. PubMed PMC

Ahmed, Q. , Agarwal M., Alobaidi R., Zhang H., and Ren Y.. 2022. “Response of Aphid Parasitoids to Volatile Organic Compounds From Undamaged and Infested Brassica oleracea With Myzus persicae .” Molecules 27: 1522. PubMed PMC

Ali, M. Y. , Naseem T., Zhang J., Pan M., Zhang F., and Liu T. X.. 2022. “Plant Volatiles and Herbivore Induced Plant Volatiles From Chili Pepper Act as Attractant of the Aphid Parasitoid Aphelinus varipes (Hymenoptera: Aphelinidae).” Plants 11: 1350. PubMed PMC

Bates, D. , Mächler M., Bolker B., and Walker S.. 2015. “Fitting Linear Mixed‐Effects Models Using lme4.” Journal of Statistical Software 67: 1–48.

Blüthgen, N. , Menzel F., Hovestadt T., Fiala B., and Blüthgen N.. 2007. “Specialization, Constraints, and Conflicting Interests in Mutualistic Networks.” Current Biology 17: 341–346. PubMed

Callahan, B. J. , McMurdie P. J., Rosen M. J., Han A. W., Johnson A. J. A., and Holmes S. P.. 2016. “DADA2: High‐Resolution Sample Inference From Illumina Amplicon Data.” Nature Methods 13: 581–583. PubMed PMC

Carpenter, M. , Peng L., Smith A. H., et al. 2021. “Frequent Drivers, Occasional Passengers: Signals of Symbiont‐Driven Seasonal Adaptation and Hitchhiking in the Pea Aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum .” Insects 12: 805. PubMed PMC

Caspi‐Fluger, A. , Inbar M., Mozes‐Daube N., et al. 2012. “Horizontal Transmission of the Insect Symbiont Rickettsia Is Plant‐Mediated.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 279: 1791–1796. PubMed PMC

Cayetano, L. , Rothacher L., Simon J. C., and Vorburger C.. 2015. “Cheaper Is Not Always Worse: Strongly Protective Isolates of a Defensive Symbiont Are Less Costly to the Aphid Host.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 282: 20142333. PubMed PMC

Chrostek, E. , Pelz‐Stelinski K., Hurst G. D. D., and Hughes G. L.. 2017. “Horizontal Transmission of Intracellular Insect Symbionts via Plants.” Frontiers in Microbiology 8: 2237. PubMed PMC

Cornwallis, C. K. , van't Padje A., Ellers J., et al. 2023. “Symbioses Shape Feeding Niches and Diversification Across Insects.” Nature Ecology & Evolution 7: 1022–1044. PubMed PMC

Csárdi, G. , Nepusz T., Traag V., et al. 2024. “igraph: Network Analysis and Visualization in R.” July 18, 2024. http://igraph.org/.

Degnan, P. H. , and Moran N. A.. 2008. “Evolutionary Genetics of a Defensive Facultative Symbiont of Insects: Exchange of Toxin‐Encoding Bacteriophage.” Molecular Ecology 17: 916–929. PubMed

Dion, E. , Zélé F., Simon J. C., and Outreman Y.. 2011. “Rapid Evolution of Parasitoids When Faced With the Symbiont‐Mediated Resistance of Their Hosts.” Journal of Evolutionary Biology 24: 741–750. PubMed

Dormann, C. F. , Gruber B., and Fruend J.. 2008. “Introducing the Bipartite Package: Analysing Ecological Networks.” R News 8: 8–11.

Dykstra, H. R. , Weldon S. R., Martinez A. J., et al. 2014. “Factors Limiting the Spread of the Protective Symbiont Hamiltonella defensa in Aphis craccivora Aphids.” Applied and Environmental Microbiology 80: 5818–5827. PubMed PMC

Ferrari, J. , Darby A. C., Daniell T. J., Godfray H. C. J., and Douglas A. E.. 2004. “Linking the Bacterial Community in Pea Aphids With Host‐Plant Use and Natural Enemy Resistance.” Ecological Entomology 29: 60–65.

Ferrari, J. , West J. A., Via S., and Godfray H. C. J.. 2012. “Population Genetic Structure and Secondary Symbionts in Host‐Associated Populations of the Pea Aphid Complex.” Evolution 66: 375–390. PubMed

Flórez, L. V. , Scherlach K., Gaube P., et al. 2017. “Antibiotic‐Producing Symbionts Dynamically Transition Between Plant Pathogenicity and Insect‐Defensive Mutualism.” Nature Communications 8: 15172. PubMed PMC

Frago, E. , Mala M., Weldegergis B. T., et al. 2017. “Symbionts Protect Aphids From Parasitic Wasps by Attenuating Herbivore‐Induced Plant Volatiles.” Nature Communications 8: 1860. PubMed PMC

Gehrer, L. , and Vorburger C.. 2012. “Parasitoids as Vectors of Facultative Bacterial Endosymbionts in Aphids.” Biology Letters 8: 613–615. PubMed PMC

Gimmi, E. , and Vorburger C.. 2021. “Strong Genotype‐By‐Genotype Interactions Between Aphid‐Defensive Symbionts and Parasitoids Persist Across Different Biotic Environments.” Journal of Evolutionary Biology 34: 1944–1953. PubMed PMC

Gimmi, E. , and Vorburger C.. 2024. “High Specificity of Symbiont‐Conferred Resistance in an Aphid‐Parasitoid Field Community.” Journal of Evolutionary Biology 37: 162–170. PubMed

Gimmi, E. , Wallisch J., and Vorburger C.. 2024. “Ecological Divergence Despite Common Mating Sites: Genotypes and Symbiotypes Shed Light on Cryptic Diversity in the Black Bean Aphid Species Complex.” Heredity 132: 320–330. PubMed PMC

Goldstein, E. B. , de Anda Acosta Y., Henry L. M., and Parker B. J.. 2023. “Variation in Density, Immune Gene Suppression, and Coinfection Outcomes Among Strains of the Aphid Endosymbiont Regiella Insecticola.” Evolution 77: 1704–1711. PubMed

Gonella, E. , Pajoro M., Marzorati M., et al. 2015. “Plant‐Mediated Interspecific Horizontal Transmission of an Intracellular Symbiont in Insects.” Scientific Reports 5: 15811. PubMed PMC

Graham, M. H. 2003. “Confronting Multicollinearity in Ecological Regression Models.” Ecology 84: 2809–2815.

Guindon, S. , Dufayard J. F., Lefort V., Anisimova M., Hordijk W., and Gascuel O.. 2010. “New Algorithms and Methods to Estimate Maximum‐Likelihood Phylogenies: Assessing the Performance of PhyML 3.0.” Systematic Biology 59: 307–321. PubMed

Hafer‐Hahmann, N. , and Vorburger C.. 2020. “Parasitoids as Drivers of Symbiont Diversity in an Insect Host.” Ecology Letters 23: 1232–1241. PubMed

Hafer‐Hahmann, N. , and Vorburger C.. 2024. “Parasitoid Species Diversity Has no Effect on Protective Symbiont Diversity in Experimental Host‐Parasitoid Populations.” Ecology and Evolution 14: e11090. PubMed PMC

Henry, L. M. , Maiden M. C. J., Ferrari J., and Godfray H. C. J.. 2015. “Insect Life History and the Evolution of Bacterial Mutualism.” Ecology Letters 18: 516–525. PubMed

Henry, L. M. , Peccoud J., Simon J. C., et al. 2013. “Horizontally Transmitted Symbionts and Host Colonization of Ecological Niches.” Current Biology 23: 1713–1717. PubMed PMC

Henry, Y. , Brechbühler E., and Vorburger C.. 2022. “Gated Communities: Inter‐ and Intraspecific Diversity of Endosymbionts Across Four Sympatric Aphid Species.” Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 10: 816184.

Heyworth, E. R. , Smee M. R., and Ferrari J.. 2020. “Aphid Facultative Symbionts Aid Recovery of Their Obligate Symbiont and Their Host After Heat Stress.” Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 8: 56.

Higashi, C. H. V. , Nichols W. L., Chevignon G., et al. 2023. “An Aphid Symbiont Confers Protection Against a Specialized RNA Virus, Another Increases Vulnerability to the Same Pathogen.” Molecular Ecology 32: 936–950. PubMed PMC

Jackson, R. , Monnin D., Patapiou P. A., et al. 2022. “Convergent Evolution of a Labile Nutritional Symbiosis in Ants.” ISME Journal 16: 2114–2122. PubMed PMC

Jackson, R. , Parapiou P. A., Golding G., et al. 2023. “Evidence of Phylosymbiosis in Formica Ants.” Frontiers in Microbiology 14: 1044286. PubMed PMC

Jaenike, J. 2012. “Population Genetics of Beneficial Heritable Symbionts.” Trends in Ecology & Evolution 27: 226–232. PubMed

Kaech, H. , and Vorburger C.. 2021. “Horizontal Transmission of the Heritable Protective Endosymbiont Hamiltonella Defensa Depends on Titre and Haplotype.” Frontiers in Microbiology 11: 628755. PubMed PMC

Kaltenpoth, M. , Gottler W., Herzner G., and Strohm E.. 2005. “Symbiotic Bacteria Protect Wasp Larvae From Fungal Infestation.” Current Biology 15: 475–479. PubMed

Leclair, M. , Buchard C., Mahéo F., Simon J. C., and Outreman Y.. 2021. “A Link Between Communities of Protective Endosymbionts and Parasitoids of the Pea Aphid Revealed in Unmanipulated Agricultural Systems.” Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 9: 618331.

Lefort, V. , Longueville J. E., and Gascuel O.. 2017. “SMS: Smart Model Selection in PhyML.” Molecular Biology and Evolution 34: 2422–2424. PubMed PMC

Letunic, I. , and Bork P.. 2024. “Interactive Tree of Life (iTOL) v6: Recent Updates to the Phylogenetic Tree Display and Annotation Tool.” Nucleic Acids Research 52: W78–W82. PubMed PMC

Li, Q. , Fan J., Sun J., Wang M. Q., and Chen J.. 2018. “Plant‐Mediated Horizontal Transmission of Hamiltonella defensa in the Wheat Aphid Sitobion miscanthi .” Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 66: 13367–13377. PubMed

Li, S. J. , Ahmed M. Z., Lv N., et al. 2017. “Plant–Mediated Horizontal Transmission of Wolbachia Between Whiteflies.” ISME Journal 11: 1019–1028. PubMed PMC

Łukasik, P. , Guo H., van Asch M., Henry L. M., Godfray H. C. J., and Ferrari J.. 2015. “Horizontal Transfer of Facultative Endosymbionts Is Limited by Host Relatedness.” Evolution 69: 2757–2766. PubMed

Łukasik, P. , van Asch M., Guo H., Ferrari J., and Godfray H. C. J.. 2013. “Unrelated Facultative Endosymbionts Protect Aphids Against a Fungal Pathogen.” Ecology Letters 16: 214–218. PubMed

Lynn‐Bell, N. L. , Strand M. R., and Oliver K. M.. 2019. “Bacteriophage Acquisition Restores Protective Mutualism.” Microbiology 165: 985–989. PubMed

Martinez, A. J. , Kim K. L., Harmon J. P., and Oliver K. M.. 2016. “Specificity of Multi‐Modal Aphid Defenses Against Two Rival Parasitoids.” PLoS One 11: e0154670. PubMed PMC

Mateos, M. , Winter L., Winter C., Higareda‐Alvear V. M., Martinez‐Romero E., and Xie J.. 2016. “Independent Origins of Resistance or Susceptibility of Parasitic Wasps to a Defensive Symbiont.” Ecology and Evolution 6: 2679–2687. PubMed PMC

McLean, A. H. C. , and Godfray H. C. J.. 2015. “Evidence for Specificity in Symbiont‐Conferred Protection Against Parasitoids.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 282: 20150977. PubMed PMC

McLean, A. H. C. , and Godfray H. C. J.. 2017. “The Outcome of Competition Between Two Parasitoid Species Is Influenced by a Facultative Symbiont of Their Aphid Host.” Functional Ecology 31: 927–933.

McLean, A. H. C. , Godfray H. C. J., Ellers J., and Henry L. M.. 2019. “Host Relatedness Influences the Composition of Aphid Microbiomes.” Environmental Microbiology Reports 11: 808–816. PubMed PMC

Moran, N. A. , Russell J. A., Koga R., and Fukatsu T.. 2005. “Evolutionary Relationships of Three New Species of Enterobacteriaceae Living as Symbionts of Aphids and Other Insects.” Applied and Environmental Microbiology 71: 3302–3310. PubMed PMC

Munson, M. A. , Baumann P., and Kinsey M. G.. 1991. “ Buchnera gen. nov. and Buchnera aphidicola sp. nov., a Taxon Consisting of the Mycetocyte‐Associated, Primary Endosymbionts of Aphids.” International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology 41: 566–569.

Niepoth, N. , Ellers J., and Henry L. M.. 2018. “Symbiont Interactions With Non‐Native Hosts Limit the Formation of New Symbioses.” BMC Evolutionary Biology 18: 27. PubMed PMC

Oksanen, J. , Simpson G. L., Blanchet F. G., et al. 2022. “vegan: Community Ecology Package.” July 18, 2024. https://CRAN.R‐project.org/package=vegan/.

Oliver, K. M. , Campos J., Moran N. A., and Hunter M. S.. 2008. “Population Dynamics of Defensive Symbionts in Aphids.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 275: 293–299. PubMed PMC

Oliver, K. M. , and Higashi C. H.. 2019. “Variations on a Protective Theme: Hamiltonella defensa Infections in Aphids Variably Impact Parasitoid Success.” Current Opinion in Insect Science 32: 1–7. PubMed

Oliver, K. M. , and Perlman S. J.. 2020. “Toxin‐Mediated Protection Against Natural Enemies by Insect Defensive Symbionts.” Advances in Insect Physiology 58: 277–316.

Oliver, K. M. , Russell J. A., Moran N. A., and Hunter M. S.. 2003. “Facultative Bacterial Symbionts in Aphids Confer Resistance to Parasitic Wasps.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 100: 1803–1807. PubMed PMC

Osaka, R. , Watada M., Kageyama D., and Nomura M.. 2010. “Population Dynamics of a Maternally‐Transmitted Spiroplasma Infection in Drosophila hydei .” Symbiosis 52: 41–45.

Paradis, E. , and Schliep K.. 2019. “Ape 5.0: An Environment for Modern Phylogenetics and Evolutionary Analyses in R.” Bioinformatics 35: 526–528. PubMed

Pons, I. , Renoz F., Noël C., and Hance T.. 2019. “Circulation of the Cultivable Symbiont Serratia symbiotica in Aphids Is Mediated by Plants.” Frontiers in Microbiology 10: 764. PubMed PMC

R Core Team . 2023. “R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing.” July 18, 2024. https://www.r‐project.org/.

Rouchet, R. , and Vorburger C.. 2012. “Strong Specificity in the Interaction Between Parasitoids and Symbiont‐Protected Hosts.” Journal of Evolutionary Biology 25: 2369–2375. PubMed

Russell, J. A. , Latorre A., Sabater‐Muñoz B., Moya A., and Moran N. A.. 2003. “Side‐Stepping Secondary Symbionts: Widespread Horizontal Transfer Across and Beyond the Aphidoidea.” Molecular Ecology 12: 1061–1075. PubMed

Smith, A. H. , O'Connor M. P., Deal B., et al. 2021. “Does Getting Defensive Get You Anywhere?—Seasonal Balancing Selection, Temperature, and Parasitoids Shape Real‐World, Protective Endosymbiont Dynamics in the Pea Aphid.” Molecular Ecology 30: 2449–2472. PubMed

Soleimannejad, S. , Ross P. A., and Hoffmann A. A.. 2023. “Effect of Rickettsiella viridis Endosymbionts Introduced Into Myzus persicae Aphids on Parasitism by Diaeretiella rapae: A Combined Strategy for Aphid Control?” Biological Control 187: 105377.

Tamura, K. , Stecher G., and Kumar S.. 2021. “MEGA11: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis Version 11.” Molecular Biology and Evolution 38: 3022–3027. PubMed PMC

Toju, H. , and Fukatsu T.. 2011. “Diversity and Infection Prevalence of Endosymbionts in Natural Populations of the Chestnut Weevil: Relevance of Local Climate and Host Plants.” Molecular Ecology 20: 853–868. PubMed

Tougeron, K. , and Iltis C.. 2022. “Impact of Heat Stress on the Fitness Outcomes of Symbiotic Infection in Aphids: A Meta‐Analysis.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 289: 20212660. PubMed PMC

Tsuchida, T. , Koga R., Shibao H., Matsumoto T., and Fukatsu T.. 2002. “Diversity and Geographic Distribution of Secondary Endosymbiotic Bacteria in Natural Populations of the Pea Aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum .” Molecular Ecology 11: 2123–2135. PubMed

Tzuri, N. , Caspi‐Fluger A., Betelman K., Rohkin Shalom S., and Chiel E.. 2021. “Horizontal Transmission of Microbial Symbionts Within a Guild of Fly Parasitoids.” Microbial Ecology 81: 818–827. PubMed

Vorburger, C. 2022. “Defensive Symbionts and the Evolution of Parasitoid Host Specialization.” Annual Review of Entomology 67: 329–346. PubMed

Vorburger, C. , Gehrer L., and Rodriguez P.. 2010. “A Strain of the Bacterial Symbiont Regiella insecticola Protects Aphids Against Parasitoids.” Biology Letters 6: 109–111. PubMed PMC

Wang, I. J. 2013. “Examining the Full Effects of Landscape Heterogeneity on Spatial Genetic Variation: A Multiple Matrix Regression Approach for Quantifying Geographic and Ecological Isolation.” Evolution 67: 3403–3411. PubMed

Weldon, S. R. , Russell J. A., and Oliver K. M.. 2020. “More Is Not Always Better: Coinfections With Defensive Symbionts Generate Highly Variable Outcomes.” Applied and Environmental Microbiology 86: e02537‐19. PubMed PMC

Wickham, H. 2016. ggplot2: Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis. Springer‐Verlag.

Wu, T. , Monnin D., Lee R. A. R., and Henry L. M.. 2022. “Local Adaptation to Hosts and Parasitoids Shape Hamiltonella defensa Genotypes Across Aphid Species.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 289: 20221269. PubMed PMC

Xie, J. , Butler S., Sanchez G., and Mateos M.. 2014. “Male Killing Spiroplasma Protects Drosophila melanogaster Against Two Parasitoid Wasps.” Heredity 112: 399–408. PubMed PMC

Zhao, D. , Zhang Z., Niu H., and Guo H.. 2023. “Pathogens Are an Important Driving Force for the Rapid Spread of Symbionts in an Insect Host.” Nature Ecology & Evolution 7: 1667–1681. PubMed