Most cited article - PubMed ID 34919921
A worldwide review of currently used pesticides' monitoring in agricultural soils
Pesticides can have adverse effects on soil microorganisms, but they are underrepresented in the currently required OECD 216 test for environmental risk assessment of plant protection products (PPP). The guideline monitors soil microbial nitrogen transformation over 28 days, potentially missing long-term effects of persistent pesticides. Additionally, nitrate alone may be not sensitive enough to detect disruptions in microbial functions. We investigated whether functional gene analysis could provide a more sensitive bioindicator of pesticide impact. To compare this method with the standard test, we conducted a microcosm experiment following the OECD 216 experimental setup. To capture long-term effects beyond the typical test period, we extended the incubation duration to 56 days. Four different concentrations of the persistent fungicide boscalid were added based on predicted environmental concentration. We also assessed microbial responses to fungicide exposure by measuring classical soil microbial parameters. According to the standard test, boscalid had no harmful long-term effects on soil microbiota. In contrast, our analysis of functional genes found an overall reduction in the acid phosphatase-encoding phoN gene abundance on Day 56, and correspondingly, in acid phosphatase activity in the highest fungicide treatment. Simultaneously, we observed a tendency towards lower fungal abundance based on measured copy numbers of an ITS region of nuclear ribosomal DNA (rDNA) and increased cumulative CO2 production. These results indicate a fungicide-related response of the microbial community and impaired microbial phosphorus cycling. Extending the experimental period to 56 days revealed long-term effects that would have otherwise been undetected under the typical 28-day test duration.
- Keywords
- Boscalid, Non-target soil microorganisms, OECD 216, Pesticide risk assessment, phoN,
- MeSH
- Biphenyl Compounds MeSH
- Risk Assessment methods MeSH
- Fungi genetics drug effects MeSH
- Soil Pollutants * toxicity MeSH
- Microbiota drug effects MeSH
- Environmental Monitoring * methods MeSH
- Niacinamide analogs & derivatives MeSH
- Pesticides * toxicity MeSH
- Fungicides, Industrial * toxicity MeSH
- Soil Microbiology * MeSH
- Publication type
- Journal Article MeSH
- Names of Substances
- 2-chloro-N-(4-chlorobiphenyl-2-yl)nicotinamide MeSH Browser
- Biphenyl Compounds MeSH
- Soil Pollutants * MeSH
- Niacinamide MeSH
- Pesticides * MeSH
- Fungicides, Industrial * MeSH
During the growing season of 2021, 201 soil samples from conventionally and organically managed fields from 10 European countries and 8 cropping systems were taken, and 192 residues of synthetic pesticides were analyzed. Pesticide residues were found in 97% of the samples, and 88% of the samples contained mixtures of at least 2 substances. A maximum of 21 substances were found in conventionally managed fields, and a maximum of 12 were found in organically managed fields. The number and concentration of pesticide residues varied significantly between conventional and organic fields in 70 and 50% of the case study sites, respectively. Application records were available for a selected number of fields (n = 82), and these records were compared to the detected substances. Residues from 52% of the applied pesticides were detected in the soils. Only 21% of the pesticide residues detected in the soil samples were applied during the 2021 growing season. From the application data, predicted environmental concentrations of residues in soil were calculated and compared to the measured concentrations. These estimates turned out not to be accurate. The results of this study show that most European agricultural soils contain mixtures of pesticide residues and that current calculation methods may not reliably estimate their presence.
- Keywords
- PECs/MECs, farming systems, pesticides, soils,
- MeSH
- Soil Pollutants * MeSH
- Pesticides * analysis MeSH
- Soil chemistry MeSH
- Pesticide Residues * analysis chemistry MeSH
- Agriculture MeSH
- Publication type
- Journal Article MeSH
- Geographicals
- Europe MeSH
- Names of Substances
- Soil Pollutants * MeSH
- Pesticides * MeSH
- Soil MeSH
- Pesticide Residues * MeSH
BACKGROUND: Children in agricultural areas are exposed to organophosphate (OP) and pyrethroid (PYR) insecticides. This explorative study investigated child exposure to OPs and PYRs, comparing temporal and spatial exposure variability within and among urine, wristbands, and dust samples. METHODS: During spraying season 2018, 38 South African children in two agricultural areas (Grabouw/Hex River Valley) and settings (farm/village) participated in a seven-day study. Child urine and household dust samples were collected on days 1 and 7. Children and their guardians were wearing silicone wristbands for seven days. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) evaluated temporal agreements between repeated urine and dust samples, Spearman rank correlations (Rs) evaluated the correlations among matrices, and linear mixed-effect models investigated spatial exposure predictors. A risk assessment was performed using reverse dosimetry. RESULTS: Eighteen OPs/PYRs were targeted in urine, wristbands, and dust. Levels of chlorpyrifos in dust (ICC = 0.92) and diethylphosphate biomarker in urine (ICC = 0.42) showed strong and moderate temporal agreement between day 1 and day 7, respectively. Weak agreements were observed for all others. There was mostly a weak correlation among the three matrices (Rs = -0.12 to 0.35), except for chlorpyrifos in dust and its biomarker 3,5,6-trichloro-2-pyridinol in urine (Rs = 0.44). No differences in exposure levels between living locations were observed. However, 21% of the urine biomarker levels exceeded the health-risk threshold for OP exposure. CONCLUSIONS: Observed high short-term variability in exposure levels during spraying season highlights the need for repeated sampling. The weak correlation between the exposure matrices points to different environmental and behavioral exposure pathways. Exceeding risk thresholds for OP should be further investigated.
- Keywords
- Biomonitoring, Child exposure, Endocrine disruptors, Pesticide, Vulnerable populations,
- Publication type
- Journal Article MeSH