Most cited article - PubMed ID 17211582
Case study of combinatorial imaging: what protocol and what chlorophyll fluorescence image to use when visualizing infection of Arabidopsis thaliana by Pseudomonas syringae?
The rate of net CO2 uptake is proportional to dim light and saturates when the light exceeds the plant's assimilation capacity. This simple relationship between constant light and photosynthesis becomes intriguingly complex when the light oscillates. The rates of photosynthesis may differ between the descending and ascending phases of light oscillation. This hysteresis changes with the frequency and amplitude of the light and reports on the dynamics of the photosynthetic reactions and their regulation. Here, we investigated the chlorophyll fluorescence response of Arabidopsis thaliana to light oscillating with three different amplitudes: 100-200, 100-400, and 100-800 μmol photons m-2 s-1, each with periods ranging from 1 s to 8 min. The light amplitudes and periods were chosen to represent light patterns often appearing in nature. Three genotypes were compared: wild-type Col-0 and npq1 and npq4 mutants that are incapacitated in the rapidly reversible energy-dependent non-photochemical quenching (qE). The experiments identified two major dynamic patterns. One was found in oscillation periods shorter than 30 s, characterized by constitutive hysteresis and non-linearity. The other was mainly formed by regulatory hysteresis, occurring when the oscillation periods were longer than 30 s. The mathematical model simulating the chlorophyll fluorescence dynamics qualitatively reproduced the constitutive and regulatory dynamic patterns observed in the experiments. The model simulations illustrated the dynamics of plastoquinone pool reduction and variables affecting non-photochemical quenching that form the constitutive and regulatory hysteresis types. The model simulations provided mechanistic insights into molecular processes forming the plant response to oscillating light.
- Keywords
- chlorophyll fluorescence, frequency domain, harmonics, mathematical model, photosynthesis,
- MeSH
- Arabidopsis * radiation effects physiology metabolism genetics MeSH
- Chlorophyll metabolism MeSH
- Fluorescence MeSH
- Photosynthesis radiation effects physiology MeSH
- Arabidopsis Proteins metabolism genetics MeSH
- Light * MeSH
- Publication type
- Journal Article MeSH
- Names of Substances
- Chlorophyll MeSH
- Arabidopsis Proteins MeSH
BACKGROUND: Non-invasive and high-throughput monitoring of drought in plants from its initiation to visible symptoms is essential to quest drought tolerant varieties. Among the existing methods, chlorophyll a fluorescence (ChlF) imaging has the potential to probe systematic changes in photosynthetic reactions; however, prerequisite of dark-adaptation limits its use for high-throughput screening. RESULTS: To improve the throughput monitoring of plants, we have exploited their light-adaptive strategy, and investigated possibilities of measuring ChlF transients under low ambient irradiance. We found that the ChlF transients and associated parameters of two contrasting Arabidopsis thaliana accessions, Rsch and Co, give almost similar information, when measured either after ~20 min dark-adaptation or in the presence of half of the adaptive growth-irradiance. The fluorescence parameters, effective quantum yield of PSII photochemistry (ΦPSII) and fluorescence decrease ratio (RFD) resulting from this approach enabled us to differentiate accessions that is often not possible by well-established dark-adapted fluorescence parameter maximum quantum efficiency of PSII photochemistry (FV/FM). Further, we screened ChlF transients in rosettes of well-watered and drought-stressed six A. thaliana accessions, under half of the adaptive growth-irradiance, without any prior dark-adaptation. Relative water content (RWC) in leaves was also assayed and compared to the ChlF parameters. As expected, the RWC was significantly different in drought-stressed from that in well-watered plants in all the six investigated accessions on day-10 of induced drought; the maximum reduction in the RWC was obtained for Rsch (16%), whereas the minimum reduction was for Co (~7%). Drought induced changes were reflected in several features of ChlF transients; combinatorial images obtained from pattern recognition algorithms, trained on pixels of image sequence, improved the contrast among drought-stressed accessions, and the derived images were well-correlated with their RWC. CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrate here that ChlF transients and associated parameters measured even in the presence of low ambient irradiance preserved its features comparable to that of measured after dark-adaptation and discriminated the accessions having differential geographical origin; further, in combination with combinatorial image analysis tools, these data may be readily employed for early sensing and mapping effects of drought on plant's physiology via easy and fully non-invasive means.
- Keywords
- Chlorophyll fluorescence transients, Drought, Natural accessions, Non-invasive methods, Plant phenotyping, Whole plant rosettes,
- Publication type
- Journal Article MeSH
BACKGROUND: An easy and non-invasive method for measuring plant cold tolerance is highly valuable to instigate research targeting breeding of cold tolerant crops. Traditional methods are labor intensive, time-consuming and thereby of limited value for large scale screening. Here, we have tested the capacity of chlorophyll a fluorescence (ChlF) imaging based methods for the first time on intact whole plants and employed advanced statistical classifiers and feature selection rules for finding combinations of images able to discriminate cold tolerant and cold sensitive plants. RESULTS: ChlF emission from intact whole plant rosettes of nine Arabidopsis thaliana accessions was measured for (1) non-acclimated (NAC, six week old plants grown at room temperature), (2) cold acclimated (AC, NAC plants acclimated at 4°C for two weeks), and (3) sub-zero temperature (ST) treated (STT, AC plants treated at -4°C for 8 h in dark) states. Cold acclimation broadened the slow phase of ChlF transients in cold sensitive (Co, C24, Can and Cvi) A. thaliana accessions. Similar broadening in the slow phase of ChlF transients was observed in cold tolerant (Col, Rsch, and Te) plants following ST treatments. ChlF parameters: maximum quantum yield of PSII photochemistry (FV/FM) and fluorescence decrease ratio (RFD) well categorized the cold sensitive and tolerant plants when measured in STT state. We trained a range of statistical classifiers with the sequence of captured ChlF images and selected a high performing quadratic discriminant classifier (QDC) in combination with sequential forward floating selection (SFFS) feature selection methods and found that linear combination of three images showed a reasonable contrast between cold sensitive and tolerant A. thaliana accessions for AC as well as for STT states. CONCLUSIONS: ChlF transients measured for an intact whole plant is important for understanding the impact of cold acclimation on photosynthetic processes. Combinatorial imaging combined with statistical classifiers and feature selection methods worked well for the screening of cold tolerance without exposing plants to sub-zero temperatures. This opens up new possibilities for high-throughput monitoring of whole plants cold tolerance via easy and fully non-invasive means.
- Keywords
- Arabidopsis thaliana, Chlorophyll a fluorescence transients, Cold acclimation, Cold tolerance, High-throughput screening, Whole plant,
- Publication type
- Journal Article MeSH
Non-invasive, high-throughput screening methods are valuable tools in breeding for abiotic stress tolerance in plants. Optical signals such as chlorophyll fluorescence emission can be instrumental in developing new screening techniques. In order to examine the potential of chlorophyll fluorescence to reveal plant tolerance to low temperatures, we used a collection of nine Arabidopsis thaliana accessions and compared their fluorescence features with cold tolerance quantified by the well established electrolyte leakage method on detached leaves. We found that, during progressive cooling, the minimal chlorophyll fluorescence emission rose strongly and that this rise was highly dependent on the cold tolerance of the accessions. Maximum quantum yield of PSII photochemistry and steady state fluorescence normalized to minimal fluorescence were also highly correlated to the cold tolerance measured by the electrolyte leakage method. In order to further increase the capacity of the fluorescence detection to reveal the low temperature tolerance, we applied combinatorial imaging that employs plant classification based on multiple fluorescence features. We found that this method, by including the resolving power of several fluorescence features, can be well employed to detect cold tolerance already at mild sub-zero temperatures. Therefore, there is no need to freeze the screened plants to the largely damaging temperatures of around -15°C. This, together with the method's easy applicability, represents a major advantage of the fluorescence technique over the conventional electrolyte leakage method.
- MeSH
- Acclimatization * MeSH
- Arabidopsis physiology MeSH
- Chlorophyll physiology MeSH
- Electrolytes metabolism MeSH
- Fluorescence MeSH
- Stress, Physiological MeSH
- Cold Temperature * MeSH
- Publication type
- Journal Article MeSH
- Names of Substances
- Chlorophyll MeSH
- Electrolytes MeSH
Automatic discrimination of plant species is required for precision farming and for advanced environmental protection. For this task, reflected sunlight has already been tested whereas fluorescence emission has been only scarcely considered. Here, we investigated the discriminative potential of chlorophyll fluorescence imaging in a case study using three closely related plant species of the family Lamiaceae. We compared discriminative potential of eight classifiers and four feature selection methods to identify the fluorescence parameters that can yield the highest contrast between the species. Three plant species: Ocimum basilicum, Origanum majorana and Origanum vulgare were grown separately as well as in pots where all three species were mixed. First, eight statistical classifiers were applied and tested in simulated species discrimination. The performance of the Quadratic Discriminant Classifier was found to be the most efficient. This classifier was further applied in combination with four different methods of feature selection. The Sequential Forward Floating Selection was found as the most efficient method for selecting the best performing subset of fluorescence images. The ability of the combinatorial statistical techniques for discriminating the species was also compared to the resolving power of conventional fluorescence parameters and found to be more efficient.
- MeSH
- Ocimum basilicum chemistry MeSH
- Time Factors MeSH
- Chlorophyll analysis MeSH
- Origanum chemistry MeSH
- Species Specificity MeSH
- Fluorescence * MeSH
- Spectrometry, Fluorescence MeSH
- Publication type
- Journal Article MeSH
- Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't MeSH
- Names of Substances
- Chlorophyll MeSH