The microbial symbionts of eukaryotes influence disease resistance in many host-parasite systems. Symbionts show substantial variation in both genotype and phenotype, but it is unclear how natural selection maintains this variation. It is also unknown whether variable symbiont genotypes show specificity with the genotypes of hosts or parasites in natural populations. Genotype by genotype interactions are a necessary condition for coevolution between interacting species. Uncovering the patterns of genetic specificity among hosts, symbionts, and parasites is therefore critical for determining the role that symbionts play in host-parasite coevolution. Here, we show that the strength of protection conferred against a fungal pathogen by a vertically transmitted symbiont of an aphid is influenced by both host-symbiont and symbiont-pathogen genotype by genotype interactions. Further, we show that certain symbiont phylogenetic clades have evolved to provide stronger protection against particular pathogen genotypes. However, we found no evidence of reciprocal adaptation of co-occurring host and symbiont lineages. Our results suggest that genetic variation among symbiont strains may be maintained by antagonistic coevolution with their host and/or their host's parasites.

Current Address Department of Biology University of Rochester Rochester NY 14627 USA

Current Address Institute of Entomology Biology Centre CAS Branisovska 31 Ceske Budejovice 37005 Czech Republic

Department of Zoology University of Oxford Oxford OX1 3PS United Kingdom

See more in PubMed

Arnold, A. E. , Mejía L. C., Kyllo D., Rojas E. I., Maynard Z., Robbins N., and Herre E. A.. 2003. Fungal endophytes limit pathogen damage in a tropical tree. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 100:15649–15654. PubMed PMC

Asplen, M. K. , Bano N., Brady C. M., Desneux N., Hopper K. R., Malouines C., Oliver K. M., White J. A., and Heimpel G. E.. 2014. Specialisation of bacterial endosymbionts that protect aphids from parasitoids. Ecol. Entomol. 39:736–739.

Auld, S. K. J. R. , Scholefield J. A., and Little T. J.. 2010. Genetic variation in the cellular response of Daphnia magna (Crustacea: Cladocera) to its bacterial parasite. Proc. Roy Soc. B Biol. Sci. 277:3291–3297. PubMed PMC

Barton, E. S. , White D. W., Cathelyn J. S., Brett‐McClellan K. A., Engle M., Diamond M. S., Miller V. L., and Virgin H. W.. 2007. Herpesvirus latency confers symbiotic protection from bacterial infection. Nature 447:326–U7. PubMed

Bennett, G. M. , and Moran N. A.. 2015. Heritable symbiosis: the advantages and perils of an evolutionary rabbit hole. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 112:10169–10176. PubMed PMC

Bronstein, J. L. 1994. Conditional outcomes in mutualistic interactions. Trends Ecol. Evol. 9:214–217. PubMed

Caragata, E. P. , Dutra H. L. C., and Moreira L. A.. 2016. Exploiting intimate relationships: controlling mosquito‐transmitted disease with Wolbachia . Trends Parasitol 32:207–218. PubMed

Carius, H. , Little T., and Ebert D.. 2001. Genetic variation in a host‐parasite association: potential for coevolution and frequency‐dependent selection. Evolution 55:1136–1145. PubMed

Chandler, S. M. , Wilkinson T. L., and Douglas A. E.. 2008. Impact of plant nutrients on the relationship between a herbivorous insect and its symbiotic bacteria. Proc. Biol. Sci. 275:565–570. PubMed PMC

Degnan, P. H. , and Moran N. A.. 2008. Evolutionary genetics of a defensive facultative symbiont of insects: exchange of toxin‐encoding bacteriophage. Mol. Ecol. 17:916–929. PubMed

Douglas, A. E. , and Werren J. H.. 2016. Holes in the hologenome: why host‐microbe symbioses are not holobionts. MBio 7:e02099–15. PubMed PMC

Duron, O. , and Hurst G. D.. 2013. Arthropods and inherited bacteria: from counting the symbionts to understanding how symbionts count. BMC Biol 11:45. PubMed PMC

Dutra, H. L. C. , Rocha M. N., Dias F. B. S., Mansur S. B., Caragata E. P., and Moreira L. A.. 2016. Wolbachia blocks currently circulating zika virus isolates in Brazilian Aedes aegypti mosquitoes. Cell Host Microbe 19:771–774. PubMed PMC

Ferrari, J. , and Vavre F.. 2011. Bacterial symbionts in insects or the story of communities affecting communities. Philos. T R Soc. B 366:1389–1400. PubMed PMC

Ferrari, J. , Muller C. B., Kraaijeveld A. R., and Godfray H. C.. 2001. Clonal variation and covariation in aphid resistance to parasitoids and a pathogen. Evolution 55:1805–1814. PubMed

Ferrari, J. , West J. A., Via S., and Godfray H. C. J.. 2012. Population genetic structure and secondary symbionts in host‐associated populations of the pea aphid complex. Evolution 66:375–390. PubMed

Frank, S. A. 1997. Models of symbiosis. Am. Nat. 150(Suppl 1):S80–S99. PubMed

Gandon, S. , Buckling A., Decaestecker E., and Day T.. 2008. Host‐parasite coevolution and patterns of adaptation across time and space. J. Evol. Biol. 21:1861–1866. PubMed

Geiger, A. , Ravel S., Mateille T., Janelle J., Patrel D., Cuny G., and Frutos R.. 2007. Vector competence of Glossina palpalis gambiensis for Trypanosoma brucei s.l. and genetic diversity of the symbiont Sodalis glossinidius . Mol. Biol. Evol. 24:102–109. PubMed

Gottlieb, Y. , Zchori‐Fein E., Mozes‐Daube N., Kontsedalov S., Skaljac M., Brumin M., Sobol I., Czosnek H., Vavre F., Fleury F., and Ghanim M.. 2010. The transmission efficiency of tomato yellow leaf curl virus by the whitefly Bemisia tabaci is correlated with the presence of a specific symbiotic bacterium species. J. Virol. 84:9310–9317. PubMed PMC

Haine, E. R. 2008. Symbiont‐mediated protection. Proc. Biol. Sci. 275:353–361. PubMed PMC

Hajek, A. E. , and Papierok B.. 2012. Methods for study of the Entomophthorales Pp. 285–315 in Lacey L. A., ed. Manual of techniques in invertebrate pathology. Academic Press, London.

Hansen, A. K. , Vorburger C., and Moran N. A.. 2012. Genomic basis of endosymbiont‐conferred protection against an insect parasitoid. Genome Res. 22:106–114. PubMed PMC

Haselkorn, T. S. , and Jaenike J.. 2015. Macroevolutionary persistence of heritable endosymbionts: acquisition, retention and expression of adaptive phenotypes in Spiroplasma. Mol. Ecol. 24:3752–3765. PubMed

Haselkorn, T. S. , Markow T. A., and Moran N. A.. 2009. Multiple introductions of the Spiroplasma bacterial endosymbiont into Drosophila . Mol. Ecol. 18:1294–1305. PubMed

Heath, K. D. , and Stinchcombe J. R.. 2014. Explaining mutualism variation: a new evolutionary paradox? Evolution 68:309–317. PubMed

Heath, K. D. , and Tiffin P.. 2007. Context dependence in the coevolution of plant and rhizobial mutualists. Proc. Biol. Sci. 274:1905–1912. PubMed PMC

Heath, K. D. , and Nuismer S. L.. 2014. Connecting functional and statistical definitions of genotype by genotype interactions in coevolutionary studies. Front Genet. 5:77. PubMed PMC

Henry, L. M. , Peccoud J., Simon J.‐C., Hadfield J. D., Maiden M. J. C., Ferrari J., and Godfray H. C. J.. 2013. Horizontally transmitted symbionts and host colonization of ecological niches. Curr. Biol. 23:1713–1717. PubMed PMC

Herre, E. A. , Knowlton N., Mueller U. G., and Rehner S. A.. 1999. The evolution of mutualisms: exploring the paths between conflict and cooperation. Trends Ecol. Evol. 14:49–53. PubMed

Hrček, J. , McLean A. H. C., and Godfray H. C. J.. 2016. Symbionts modify interactions between insects and natural enemies in the field. J. Anim. Ecol. 85:1605–1612. PubMed PMC

Jaenike, J. 2012. Population genetics of beneficial heritable symbionts. Trends Ecol. Evol. 27:227–233. PubMed

Jaenike, J. , Unckless R., Cockburn S. N., Boelio L. M., and Perlman S. J.. 2010. Adaptation via symbiosis: recent spread of a Drosophila defensive symbiont. Science 329:212–215. PubMed

Jones, E. I. , Afkhami M. E., Akçay E., Bronstein J. L., Bshary R., Frederickson M. E., Heath K. D., Hoeksema J. D., Ness J. H., Pankey M. S., et al. 2015. Cheaters must prosper: reconciling theoretical and empirical perspectives on cheating in mutualism. Ecol. Lett. 18:1270–1284. PubMed

Koga, R. , Tsuchida T., and Fukatsu T.. 2003. Changing partners in an obligate symbiosis: a facultative endosymbiont can compensate for loss of the essential endosymbiont Buchnera in an aphid. Proc. Biol. Sci. 270:2543–2550. PubMed PMC

Koskella, B. , and Lively C. M.. 2009. Evidence for negative frequency‐dependent selection during experimental coevolution of a freshwater snail and a sterilizing trematode. Evolution 63:2213–2221. PubMed

Kwiatkowski, M. , Engelstädter J., and Vorburger C.. 2012. On genetic specificity in symbiont‐mediated host‐parasite coevolution. PLoS Comput. Biol. 8:e1002633. PubMed PMC

Lambrechts, L. , Fellous S., and Koella J. C.. 2006. Coevolutionary interactions between host and parasite genotypes. Trends Parasitol. 22:12–16. PubMed

Law, R. , and Lewis D. H.. 1983. Biotic environments and the maintenance of sex—some evidence from mutualistic symbioses. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 20:249–276.

Law, R. , and Koptur S.. 1986. On the evolution of non‐specific mutualism. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 27:251–267.

Lively, C. M. , and Dybdahl M. F.. 2000. Parasite adaptation to locally common host genotypes. Nature 405:679–681. PubMed

Łukasik, P. , Guo H., van Asch M., Henry L. M., Godfray H. C. J., and Ferrari J.. 2015. Horizontal transfer of facultative endosymbionts is limited by host relatedness. Evolution 69:2757–2766. PubMed

Łukasik, P. , van Asch M., Guo H., Ferrari J., and Godfray H. C. J.. 2013. Unrelated facultative endosymbionts protect aphids against a fungal pathogen. Ecol. Lett. 16:214–218. PubMed

Martinez, J. , Longdon B., Bauer S., Chan Y.‐S., Miller W. J., Bourtzis K., Teixeira L., and Jiggins F. M.. 2014. Symbionts commonly provide broad spectrum resistance to viruses in insects: a comparative analysis of Wolbachia strains. PLoS Pathog. 10:e1004369. PubMed PMC

Martinez, J. , Ok S., Smith S., Snoeck K., Day J. P., and Jiggins F. M.. 2015. Should symbionts be nice or selfish? Antiviral effects of Wolbachia are costly but reproductive parasitism is not. PLoS Pathog. 11:e1005021. PubMed PMC

McLean, A. H. C. , and Godfray H. C. J.. 2015. Evidence for specificity in symbiont‐conferred protection against parasitoids. Proc. Roy Soc. B Biol. Sci. 282:20150977. PubMed PMC

McLean, A. H. C. , Parker B. J., Hrček J., Henry L. M., and Godfray H. C. J.. 2016. Insect symbionts in food webs. Philos. T Roy Soc. B 1–12. PubMed PMC

McLean, A. H. C. , van Asch M., Ferrari J., and Godfray H. C. J.. 2011. Effects of bacterial secondary symbionts on host plant use in pea aphids. Proc. Roy Soc. B Biol. Sci. 278:760–766. PubMed PMC

Moran, N. A. 2007. Symbiosis as an adaptive process and source of phenotypic complexity. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 104(Suppl 1):8627–8633. PubMed PMC

Moreira, L. A. , Iturbe‐Ormaetxe I., Jeffery J. A., Lu G., Pyke A. T., Hedges L. M., Rocha B. C., Hall‐Mendelin S., Day A., Riegler M., et al. 2009. A Wolbachia symbiont in Aedes aegypti limits infection with dengue, Chikungunya, and Plasmodium . Cell 139:1268–1278. PubMed

Mouton, L. , Thierry M., Henri H., Baudin R., Gnankine O., Reynaud B., Zchori‐Fein E., Becker N., Fleury F., and Delatte H.. 2012. Evidence of diversity and recombination in Arsenophonus symbionts of the Bemisia tabaci species complex. BMC Microbiol. 12(Suppl 1):S10. PubMed PMC

Nakayama, S. , Parratt S. R., Hutchence K. J., Lewis Z., Price T. A. R., and Hurst G. D. D.. 2015. Can maternally inherited endosymbionts adapt to a novel host? Direct costs of Spiroplasma infection, but not vertical transmission efficiency, evolve rapidly after horizontal transfer into D. melanogaster . Heredity 114:539–543. PubMed PMC

Oliver, K. M. , Smith A. H., and Russell J. A.. 2014. Defensive symbiosis in the real world—advancing ecological studies of heritable, protective bacteria in aphids and beyond. Funct. Ecol. 28:341–355.

Oliver, K. M. , Degnan P. H., Burke G. R., and Moran N. A.. 2010. Facultative symbionts in aphids and the horizontal transfer of ecologically important traits. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 55:247–266. PubMed

Oliver, K. , Russell J., Moran N., and Hunter M.. 2003. Facultative bacterial symbionts in aphids confer resistance to parasitic wasps. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 100:1803–1807. PubMed PMC

Parker, B. J. , Spragg C. J., Altincicek B., and Gerardo N. M.. 2013. Symbiont‐mediated protection against fungal pathogens in pea aphids: a role for pathogen specificity? Appl. Environ. Microb. 79:2455–2458. PubMed PMC

Parker, B. J. , Garcia J. R., and Gerardo N. M.. 2014. Genetic variation in resistance and fecundity tolerance in a natural host‐pathogen interaction. Evolution 68:2421–2429. PubMed

Parker, B. J. , Barribeau S. M., Laughton A. M., de Roode J. C., and Gerardo N. M.. 2011. Non‐immunological defense in an evolutionary framework. Trends Ecol. Evol. 26:242–248. PubMed

Parker, M. A. 1999. Mutualism in metapopulations of legumes and rhizobia. Am. Nat. 153:S48–S60. PubMed

Peccoud, J. , Ollivier A., Plantegenest M., and Simon J.‐C.. 2009. A continuum of genetic divergence from sympatric host races to species in the pea aphid complex. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 106:7495–7500. PubMed PMC

Pool, J. E. , Wong A., and Aquadro C. F.. 2006. Finding of male‐killing Spiroplasma infecting Drosophila melanogaster in Africa implies transatlantic migration of this endosymbiont. Heredity 97:27–32. PubMed PMC

R Development Core Team . 2015. R: a language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria.

Raychoudhury, R. , Baldo L., Oliveira D. C. S. G., and Werren J. H.. 2009. Modes of acquisition of Wolbachia: horizontal transfer, hybrid introgression, and codivergence in the Nasonia species complex. Evolution 63:165–183. PubMed

Rouchet, R. , and Vorburger C.. 2014. Experimental evolution of parasitoid infectivity on symbiont‐protected hosts leads to the emergence of genotype specificity. Evolution 68:1607–1616. PubMed

Russell, J. A. , Goldman‐Huertas B., Moreau C. S., Baldo L., Stahlhut J. K., Werren J. H., and Pierce N. E.. 2009. Specialization and geographic isolation among Wolbachia symbionts from ants and lycaenid butterflies. Evolution 63:624–640. PubMed

Russell, J. A. , Weldon S., Smith A. H., Kim K. L., Hu Y., Łukasik P., Doll S., Anastopoulos I., Novin M., and Oliver K. M.. 2013. Uncovering symbiont‐driven genetic diversity across North American pea aphids. Mol. Ecol. 22:2045–2059. PubMed

Russell, J. , and Moran N.. 2006. Costs and benefits of symbiont infection in aphids: variation among symbionts and across temperatures. Proc. Roy Soc. B Biol. Sci. 273:603–610. PubMed PMC

Sassera, D. , Epis S., Pajoro M., and Bandi C.. 2013. Microbial symbiosis and the control of vector‐borne pathogens in tsetse flies, human lice, and triatomine bugs. Pathog. Glob. Health 107:285–292. PubMed PMC

Scarborough, C. , Ferrari J., and Godfray H.. 2005. Aphid protected from pathogen by endosymbiont. Science 310:1781–1781. PubMed

Scheublin, T. R. , Logtestijn R. Van, and Heijden M. van der. 2007. Presence and identity of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi influence competitive interactions between plant species. J. Ecol. 95:631–638.

Schulenburg, H. , and Ewbank J. J.. 2004. Diversity and specificity in the interaction between Caenorhabditis elegans and the pathogen Serratia marcescens . BMC Evol. Biol. 4:49. PubMed PMC

Schulenburg, H. , Kurtz J., Moret Y., and Siva‐Jothy M. T.. 2009. Introduction. Ecological immunology. Philos. T R Soc. B 364:3–14. PubMed PMC

Sheldon, B. , and Verhulst S.. 1996. Ecological immunology: costly parasite defences and trade‐offs in evolutionary ecology. Trends Ecol. Evol. 11:317–321. PubMed

Teixeira, L. , Ferreira A., and Ashburner M.. 2008. The bacterial symbiont Wolbachia induces resistance to RNA viral infections in Drosophila melanogaster . Plos Biol. 6:e2. PubMed PMC

Therneau, T. M. , and Grambsch P. M.. 2000. Modeling survival data: extending the cox model. Springer, New York.

Tinsley, M. C. , and Majerus M. E.. 2007. Small steps or giant leaps for male‐killers? Phylogenetic constraints to male‐killer host shifts. BMC Evol. Biol. 7:238. PubMed PMC

Tsuchida, T. , Koga R., Shibao H., Matsumoto T., and Fukatsu T.. 2002. Diversity and geographic distribution of secondary endosymbiotic bacteria in natural populations of the pea aphid, Acyrthosiphon pisum . Mol. Ecol. 11:2123–2135. PubMed

Van Valen, L. 1973. A new evolutionary law. Evol. Theory 1:1–30.

Van Veen, F. J. F. , Muller C. B., Pell J. K., and Godfray H. C. J.. 2008. Food web structure of three guilds of natural enemies: predators, parasitoids and pathogens of aphids. J. Anim. Ecol. 77:191–200. PubMed

Wang, J. , Wu Y., Yang G., and Aksoy S.. 2009. Interactions between mutualist Wigglesworthia and tsetse peptidoglycan recognition protein (PGRP‐LB) influence trypanosome transmission. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 106:12133–12138. PubMed PMC

Weeks, A. R. , Turelli M., Harcombe W. R., Reynolds K. T., and Hoffmann A. A.. 2007. From parasite to mutualist: rapid evolution of Wolbachia in natural populations of Drosophila . Plos Biol. 5:997–1005. PubMed PMC

Weyl, E. G. , Frederickson M. E., Yu D. W., and Pierce N. E.. 2010. Economic contract theory tests models of mutualism. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107:15712–15716. PubMed PMC

Woolhouse, M. , Webster J., Domingo E., Charlesworth B., and Levin B.. 2002. Biological and biomedical implications of the co‐evolution of pathogens and their hosts. Nat. Genet. 32:569–577. PubMed

Within-community variation of interspecific divergence patterns in passerine gut microbiota

Metacommunity theory for transmission of heritable symbionts within insect communities

The influence of symbiotic bacteria on reproductive strategies and wing polyphenism in pea aphids responding to stress

See more in PubMed

Dryad
10.5061/dryad.6q750