Balancing selection is a classic mechanism for maintaining variability in immune genes involved in host-pathogen interactions. However, it remains unclear how widespread the mechanism is across immune genes other than the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). Although occasional reports suggest that balancing selection (heterozygote advantage, negative frequency-dependent selection, and fluctuating selection) may act on other immune genes, the current understanding of the phenomenon in non-MHC immune genes is far from solid. In this review, we focus on Toll-like receptors (TLRs), innate immune genes directly involved in pathogen recognition and immune response activation, as there is a growing body of research testing the assumptions of balancing selection in these genes. After reviewing infection- and fitness-based evidence, along with evidence based on population allelic frequencies and heterozygosity levels, we conclude that balancing selection maintains variation in TLRs, though it tends to occur under specific conditions in certain evolutionary lineages rather than being universal and ubiquitous. Our review also identifies key gaps in current knowledge and proposes promising areas for future research. Improving our understanding of host-pathogen interactions and balancing selection in innate immune genes are increasingly important, particularly regarding threats from emerging zoonotic diseases.

Department of Biodiversity Studies and Bioeducation Faculty of Biology and Environmental Protection University of Łódź Banacha 1 3 90 237 Łódź Poland

Faculty of Science Department of Zoology Charles University Viničná 7 128 43 Prague Czech Republic

Zobrazit více v PubMed

Acevedo-Whitehouse  K, Cunningham  AA. 2006. Is MHC enough for understanding wildlife immunogenetics?  Trends Ecol Evol.  21:433–438. PubMed

Alcaide  M, Edwards  SV. 2011. Molecular evolution of the toll-like receptor multigene family in birds. Mol Biol Evol.  28:1703–1715. PubMed

Antonides  J, Mathur  S, Sundaram  M, Ricklefs  R, DeWoody  JA. 2019. Immunogenetic response of the bananaquit in the face of malarial parasites. BMC Evol Biol.  19:107. PubMed PMC

Armstrong  C, Davies  RG, González-Quevedo  C, Dunne  M, Spurgin  LG, Richardson  DS. 2019. Adaptive landscape genetics and malaria across divergent island bird populations. Ecol Evol.  9:12482–12502. PubMed PMC

Ashley  NT, Weil  ZM, Nelson  RJ. 2012. Inflammation: mechanisms, costs, and natural variation. Annu Rev Ecol Evol Syst.  43:385–406.

Barreiro  LB, Ben-Ali  M, Quach  H, Laval  G, Patin  E, Pickrell  JK, Bouchier  C, Tichit  M, Neyrolles  O, Gicquel  B, et al.  2009. Evolutionary dynamics of human toll-like receptors and their different contributions to host defense. PLoS Genet.  5:e1000562. PubMed PMC

Bateson  ZW, Hammerly  SC, Johnson  JA, Morrow  ME, Whittingham  LA, Dunn  PO. 2016. Specific alleles at immune genes, rather than genome-wide heterozygosity, are related to immunity and survival in the critically endangered Attwater’s prairie-chicken. Mol Ecol.  25:4730–4744. PubMed

Charbonnel  N, Pemberton  J. 2005. A long-term genetic survey of an ungulate population reveals balancing selection acting on MHC through spatial and temporal fluctuations in selection. Heredity.  95:377–388. PubMed

Cornetti  L, Hilfiker  D, Lemoine  M, Tschirren  B. 2018. Small-scale spatial variation in infection risk shapes the evolution of a Borrelia resistance gene in wild rodents. Mol Ecol.  27:3515–3524. PubMed

Darfour-Oduro  KA, Megens  HJ, Roca  A, Groenen  MA, Schook  LB. 2016. Evidence for adaptation of porcine Toll-like receptors. Immunogenetics  68:179–189. PubMed PMC

Davies  CS, Taylor  MI, Hammers  M, Burke  T, Komdeur  J, Dugdale  HL, Richardson  DS. 2021. Contemporary evolution of the innate immune receptor gene TLR3 in an isolated vertebrate population. Mol Ecol.  30:2528–2542. PubMed

de Groot  NG, Otting  N, Doxiadis  GG, Balla-Jhagjhoorsingh  SS, Heeney  JL, van Rood  JJ, Gagneux  P, Bontrop  RE. 2002. Evidence for an ancient selective sweep in the MHC class I gene repertoire of chimpanzees. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A.  99:11748–11753. PubMed PMC

Downing  T, Lloyd  AT, O’Farrelly  C, Bradley  DG. 2010. The differential evolutionary dynamics of avian cytokine and TLR gene classes. J Immunol.  184:6993–7000. PubMed

Drzewińska-Chańko  J, Włodarczyk  R, Gajewski  A, Rudnicka  K, Dunn  PO, Minias  P. 2021. Immunocompetent birds choose larger breeding colonies. J Anim Ecol.  90:2325–2335. PubMed

Ferrer-Admetlla  A, Bosch  E, Sikora  M, Marquès-Bonet  T, Ramírez-Soriano  A, Muntasell  A, Navarro  A, Lazarus  R, Calafell  F, Bertranpetit  J, Casals  F. 2008. Balancing selection is the main force shaping the evolution of innate immunity genes. J Immunol.  181:1315–1322. PubMed

Ferwerda  B, McCall  MB, Alonso  S, Giamarellos-Bourboulis  EJ, Mouktaroudi  M, Izagirre  N, Syafruddin  D, Kibiki  G, Cristea  T, Hijmans  A, et al.  2007. TLR4 polymorphisms, infectious diseases, and evolutionary pressure during migration of modern humans. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A.  104:16645–16650. PubMed PMC

Fiddaman  SR, Vinkler  M, Spiro  SG, Levy  H, Emerling  CA, Boyd  AC, Dimopoulos  EA, Vianna  JA, Cole  TL, Pan  H, et al.  2022. Adaptation and cryptic pseudogenization in penguin toll-like receptors. Mol Biol Evol.  39:msab354. PubMed PMC

Fijarczyk  A, Babik  W. 2015. Detecting balancing selection in genomes: limits and prospects. Mol Ecol.  24:3529–3545. PubMed

Fumagalli  M, Sironi  M. 2014. Human genome variability, natural selection and infectious diseases. Curr Opin Immunol.  30:9–16. PubMed

Gavan  MK, Oliver  MK, Douglas  A, Piertney  SB. 2015. Gene dynamics of toll-like receptor 4 through a population bottleneck in an insular population of water voles (Arvicola amphibius). Conserv Genet.  16:1181–1193.

Gilroy  DL, Phillips  KP, Richardson  DS, van Oosterhout  C.  2017. Toll-like receptor variation in the bottlenecked population of the Seychelles warbler: computer simulations see the ‘ghost of selection past’and quantify the ‘drift debt’. J Evol Biol.  30:1276–1287. PubMed

Gilroy  DL, van Oosterhout  C, Komdeur  J, Richardson  DS. 2017. Toll-like receptor variation in the bottlenecked population of the endangered Seychelles warbler. Anim Conserv.  20:235–250. PubMed

Grueber  CE, Sutton  JT, Heber  S, Briskie  JV, Jamieson  IG, Robertson  BC. 2017. Reciprocal translocation of small numbers of inbred individuals rescues immunogenetic diversity. Mol Ecol.  26:2660–2673. PubMed

Grueber  CE, Wallis  GP, Jamieson  IG. 2013. Genetic drift outweighs natural selection at toll-like receptor (TLR) immunity loci in a re-introduced population of a threatened species. Mol Ecol.  22:4470–4482. PubMed

Grueber  CE, Wallis  GP, Jamieson  IG. 2014. Episodic positive selection in the evolution of avian Toll-like receptor innate immunity genes. PLoS One.  9:e89632. PubMed PMC

Gutierrez  B, Escalera-Zamudio  M, Pybus  OG. 2019.  Parallel molecular evolution and adaptation in viruses. Curr Opin Virol.  34:90–96. PubMed PMC

Ham-Dueñas  JG, Canales-del-Castillo  R, Voelker  G, Ruvalcaba-Ortega  I, Aguirre-Calderón  CE, González-Rojas  JI. 2020. Adaptive genetic diversity and evidence of population genetic structure in the endangered Sierra Madre Sparrow (Xenospiza baileyi). PLoS One.  15:e0232282. PubMed PMC

Hartmann  SA, Schaefer  HM, Segelbacher  G. 2014. Genetic depletion at adaptive but not neutral loci in an endangered bird species. Mol Ecol.  23:5712–5725. PubMed

Hedrick  PW. 2012. What is the evidence for heterozygote advantage selection?  Trends Ecol Evol.  27:698–704. PubMed

Hughes  AL, Yeager  M. 1998. Natural selection at major histocompatibility complex loci of vertebrates. Annu Rev Genet.  32:415–435. PubMed

Ji  J, Ramos-Vicente  D, Navas-Pérez  E, Herrera-Úbeda  C, Lizcano  JM, Garcia-Fernàndez  J, Escrivà  H, Bayés  À, Roher  N. 2018. Characterization of the TLR family in Branchiostoma lanceolatum and discovery of a novel TLR22-like involved in dsRNA recognition in amphioxus. Front Immunol.  9:2525. PubMed PMC

Jongejan  F, Uilenberg  G. 2004. The global importance of ticks. Parasitology  129:S3–S14. PubMed

Kaspers  B, Schat  KA, Göbel  TW, Vervelde  L. 2022. Avian immunology. 3rd ed. London: Academic Press.

Key  FM, Teixeira  JC, de Filippo  C, Andrés  AM. 2014. Advantageous diversity maintained by balancing selection in humans. Curr Opin Genet Dev.  29:45–51. PubMed

Kloch  A, Wenzel  MA, Laetsch  DR, Michalski  O, Bajer  A, Behnke  JM, Welc-Falęciak  R, Piertney  SB. 2018. Signatures of balancing selection in toll-like receptor (TLRs) genes—novel insights from a free-living rodent. Sci Rep.  8:8361. PubMed PMC

Králová  T, Albrecht  T, Bryja  J, Hořák  D, Johnsen  A, Lifjeld  JT, Novotný  M, Sedláček  O, Velová  H, Vinkler  M. 2018. Signatures of diversifying selection and convergence acting on passerine Toll-like receptor 4 in an evolutionary context. Mol Ecol.  27:2871–2883. PubMed

Kumar  H, Kawai  T, Akira  S. 2011. Pathogen recognition by the innate immune system. Int Rev Immunol.  30:16–34. PubMed

Lara  CE, Grueber  CE, Holtmann  B, Santos  ES, Johnson  SL, Robertson  BC, Castaño-Villa  GJ, Lagisz  M, Nakagawa  S. 2020. Assessment of the dunnocks’ introduction to New Zealand using innate immune-gene diversity. Evol Ecol.  34:803–820.

Lazarus  R, Vercelli  D, Palmer  LJ, Klimecki  WJ, Silverman  EK, Richter  B, Riva  A, Ramoni  M, Martinez  FD, Weiss  ST, Kwiatkowski  DJ. 2002. Single nucleotide polymorphisms in innate immunity genes: abundant variation and potential role in complex human disease. Immunol Rev.  190:9–25. PubMed

Lebov  J, Grieger  K, Womack  D, Zaccaro  D, Whitehead  N, Kowalcyk  B, MacDonald  PDM. 2017. A framework for one health research. One Health.  3:44–50. PubMed PMC

Leveque  G, Forgetta  V, Morroll  S, Smith  AL, Bumstead  N, Barrow  P, Loredo-Osti  JC, Morgan  K, Malo  D. 2003. Allelic variation in TLR4 is linked to susceptibility to Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium infection in chickens. Infect Immun.  71:1116–1124. PubMed PMC

Levy  H, Fiddaman  SR, Vianna  JA, Noll  D, Clucas  GV, Sidhu  JK, Polito  MJ, Bost  CA, Phillips  RA, Crofts  S, et al.  2020. Evidence of pathogen-induced immunogenetic selection across the large geographic range of a wild seabird. Mol Biol Evol.  37:1708–1726. PubMed PMC

Lundberg  M, Zhong  X, Konrad  A, Olsen  RA, Råberg  L. 2020. Balancing selection in pattern recognition receptor signalling pathways is associated with gene function and pleiotropy in a wild rodent. Mol Ecol.  29:1990–2003. PubMed

Migalska  M, Sebastian  A, Radwan  J. 2019. Major histocompatibility complex class I diversity limits the repertoire of T cell receptors. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A.  116:5021–5026. PubMed PMC

Minias  P, Drzewinska-Chanko  J, Wlodarczyk  R. 2021. Evolution of innate and adaptive immune genes in a non-model waterbird, the common tern. Infect Genet Evol.  95:105069. PubMed

Minias  P, Pikus  E, Whittingham  LA, Dunn  PO. 2018. A global analysis of selection at the avian MHC. Evolution.  72:1278–1293. PubMed

Morger  J, Bajnok  J, Boyce  K, Craig  PS., Rogan  MT, Lun  ZR, Hide  G, Tschirren  B. 2014. Naturally occurring Toll-like receptor 11 (TLR11) and Toll-like receptor 12 (TLR12) polymorphisms are not associated with Toxoplasma gondii infection in wild wood mice. Infect Genet Evol.  26:180–184. PubMed

Nelson-Flower  MJ, Germain  RR, MacDougall-Shackleton  EA, Taylor  SS, Arcese  P. 2018. Purifying selection in the toll-like receptors of song sparrows Melospiza melodia. J Hered.  109:501–509. PubMed

Nevoux  M, Arlt  D, Nicoll  M, Jones  C, Norris  K. 2013. The short-and long-term fitness consequences of natal dispersal in a wild bird population. Ecol Lett.  16:438–445. PubMed

Nielsen  R, Bustamante  C, Clark  AG, Glanowski  S, Sackton  TB, Hubisz  MJ, Fledel-Alon  A, Tanenbaum  DM, Civello  D, White  TJ, et al.  2005. A scan for positively selected genes in the genomes of humans and chimpanzees. PLoS Biol.  3:e170. PubMed PMC

Novák  K. 2014. Functional polymorphisms in toll-like receptor genes for innate immunity in farm animals. Vet Immunol Immunopathol.  157:1–11. PubMed

Ortutay  C, Siermala  M, Vihinen  M. 2007. Molecular characterization of the immune system: emergence of proteins, processes, and domains. Immunogenetics  59:333–348. PubMed

Perrin  A, Khimoun  A, Faivre  B, Ollivier  A, de Pracontal  N, Théron  F, Loubon  M, Leblond  G, Duron  O, Garnier  S. 2021. Habitat fragmentation differentially shapes neutral and immune gene variation in a tropical bird species. Heredity  126:148–162. PubMed PMC

Piccinini  AM, Midwood  KS. 2010. DAMPening inflammation by modulating TLR signalling. Mediat Inflamm.  2010:672395. PubMed PMC

Podlaszczuk  P, Indykiewicz  P, Kamiński  M, Minias  P. 2021. Physiological condition reflects polymorphism at the toll-like receptors in a colonial waterbird. Ornithology  138:ukab052.

Quéméré  E, Galan  M, Cosson  J-F, Klein  F, Aulagnier  S, Gilot-Fromont  E, Merlet  J, Bonhomme  M, Hewison  AJM, Charbonnel  N. 2015. Immunogenetic heterogeneity in a widespread ungulate: the European roe deer (Capreolus capreolus). Mol Ecol.  24:3873–3887. PubMed

Quéméré  E, Hessenauer  P, Galan  M, Fernandez  M, Merlet  J, Chaval  Y, Morellet  N, Verheyden  H, Gilot-Fromont  E, Charbonnel  N. 2021. Pathogen-mediated selection favours the maintenance of innate immunity gene polymorphism in a widespread wild ungulate. J Evol Biol.  34:1156–1166. PubMed

Quéméré  E, Rossi  S, Petit  E, Marchand  P, Merlet  J, Game  Y, Galan  M, Gilot-Fromont  E. 2020. Genetic epidemiology of the Alpine ibex reservoir of persistent and virulent brucellosis outbreak. Sci Rep.  10:4400. PubMed PMC

Råberg  L, Sim  D, Read  AF. 2007. Disentangling genetic variation for resistance and tolerance to infectious diseases in animals. Science  318:812–814. PubMed

Radwan  J, Babik  W, Kaufman  J, Lenz  TL, Winternitz  J. 2020. Advances in the evolutionary understanding of MHC polymorphism. Trends Genet.  36:298–311. PubMed

Roach  JC, Glusman  G, Rowen  L, Kaur  A, Purcell  MK, Smith  KD, Hood  LE, Aderem  A. 2005. The evolution of vertebrate toll-like receptors. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A.  102:9577–9582. PubMed PMC

Santos  ES, Santos  LLS, Lagisz  M, Nakagawa  S, Sheldon  B. 2015. Conflict and cooperation over sex: the consequences of social and genetic polyandry for reproductive success in dunnocks. J Anim Ecol.  84:1509–1519. PubMed

Schmid-Hempel  P. 2011. Evolutionary parasitology: the integrated study of infections, immunology, ecology, and genetics. New York: Oxford University Press.

Sepil  I, Moghadam  HK, Huchard  E, Sheldon  BC. 2012. Characterization and 454 pyrosequencing of major histocompatibility complex class I genes in the great tit reveal complexity in a passerine system. BMC Evol Biol.  12:68. PubMed PMC

Shultz  AJ, Sackton  TB. 2019. Immune genes are hotspots of shared positive selection across birds and mammals. Elife  8:e41815. PubMed PMC

Spurgin  LG, Richardson  DS. 2010. How pathogens drive genetic diversity: MHC, mechanisms and misunderstandings. Proc R Soc B.  277:979–988. PubMed PMC

Świderská  Z, Šmídová  A, Buchtová  L, Bryjová  A, Fabiánová  A, Munclinger  P, Vinkler  M. 2018. Avian Toll-like receptor allelic diversity far exceeds human polymorphism: an insight from domestic chicken breeds. Sci Rep.  8:17878. PubMed PMC

Takahata  N, Nei  M. 1990. Allelic genealogy under over-dominant and frequency-dependent selection and polymorphism of major histocompatibility complex loci. Genetics  124:967–978. PubMed PMC

Těšický  M, Velová  H, Novotný  M, Kreisinger  J, Beneš  V, Vinkler  M. 2020. Positive selection and convergent evolution shape molecular phenotypic traits of innate immunity receptors in tits (Paridae). Mol Ecol.  29:3056–3070. PubMed

Tschirren  B, Andersson  M, Scherman  K, Westerdahl  H, Mittl  PR, Råberg  L.  2013. Polymorphisms at the innate immune receptor TLR2 are associated with Borrelia infection in a wild rodent population. Proc R Soc B.  280:20130364. PubMed PMC

Tschirren  B, Andersson  M, Scherman  K, Westerdahl  H, Råberg  L. 2012. Contrasting patterns of diversity and population differentiation at the innate immunity gene toll-like receptor 2 (TLR2) in two sympatric rodent species. Evolution  66:720–731. PubMed

Tschirren  B, Råberg  L, Westerdahl  H. 2011. Signatures of selection acting on the innate immunity gene Toll-like receptor 2 (TLR2) during the evolutionary history of rodents. J Evol Biol.  24:1232–1240. PubMed

Vanpé  C, Debeffe  L, Galan  M, Hewison  AM, Gaillard  JM, Gilot-Fromont  E, Morellet  N, Verheyden  H, Cosson  JF, Cargnelutti  B, et al.  2016. Immune gene variability influences roe deer natal dispersal. Oikos  125:1790–1801.

Velová  H, Gutowska-Ding  MW, Burt  DW, Vinkler  M. 2018. Toll-like receptor evolution in birds: gene duplication, pseudogenization, and diversifying selection. Mol Biol Evol.  35:2170–2184. PubMed PMC

Verweij  SP, Karimi  O, Pleijster  J, Lyons  JM, de Vries  HJ, Land  JA, Morré  SA, Ouburg  S. 2016. TLR2. TLR 4, and TLR9 genotypes and haplotypes in the susceptibility to and clinical course of Chlamydia trachomatis infections in Dutch women. FEMS Pathog Dis.  74:ftv107. PubMed PMC

Vinkler  M, Adelman  JS, Ardia  DR. 2022. Evolutionary and ecological immunology. In: Kaspers  B, Schat  KA, Göbel  TW, Vervelde  L (eds) Avian immunology. 3rd ed. Academic Press, London, pp 519–557.

Vinkler  M, Albrecht  T. 2009. The question waiting to be asked: Innate immunity receptors in the perspective of zoological research. Folia Zool.  58:15–28.

Vinkler  M, Bainová  H, Bryja  J. 2014. Protein evolution of toll-like receptors 4, 5 and 7 within Galloanserae birds. Genet Sel Evol.  46:72. PubMed PMC

Vinkler  M, Bainová  H, Bryjová  A, Tomášek  O, Albrecht  T, Bryja  J. 2015. Characterisation of Toll-like receptors 4, 5, and 7 and their genetic variation in the grey partridge. Genetica  143:101–112. PubMed

Walsh  C, Gangloff  M, Monie  T, Smyth  T, Wei  B, McKinley  TJ, Maskell  D, Gay  N, Bryant  C. 2008. Elucidation of the MD-2/TLR4 interface required for signaling by lipid IVa. J Immunol.  181:1245–1254. PubMed

Wang  X, Quinn  PJ, Yan  A. 2015. Kdo 2-lipid A: structural diversity and impact on immunopharmacology. Biol Rev.  90:408–427. PubMed PMC

Webb  AE, Gerek  ZN, Morgan  CC, Walsh  TA, Loscher  CE, Edwards  SV, O’Connell  MJ. 2015. Adaptive evolution as a predictor of species-specific innate immune response. Mol Biol Evol.  32:1717–1729. PubMed PMC

Wlasiuk  G, Khan  S, Switzer  WM, Nachman  MW. 2009. A history of recurrent positive selection at the toll-like receptor 5 in primates. Mol Biol Evol.  26:937–949. PubMed PMC

Woolhouse  MEJ, Webster  JP, Domingo  E, Charlesworth  B, Levin  BR. 2002. Biological and biomedical implications of the co-evolution of pathogens and their hosts. Nat Genet.  32:569–577. PubMed

Xu  W, Zhou  X, Fang  W, Chen  X. 2020. Genetic diversity of toll-like receptor genes in the vulnerable Chinese egret (Egretta eulophotes). PLoS One.  15:e0233714. PubMed PMC

Zdorovenko  GM, Zdorovenko  EL, Varbanets  LD. 2007. Composition, structure, and biological properties of lipopolysaccharides from different strains of Pseudomonas syringae pv. atrofaciens. Microbiology  76:683–697. PubMed

Twelve toll-like receptor (TLR) genes in the family Equidae - comparative genomics, selection and evolution

Understanding the evolution of immune genes in jawed vertebrates